• Welcome! The TrekBBS is the number one place to chat about Star Trek with like-minded fans.
    If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

New Firefly...but a Reboot. Say it Ain't So.

20 years have passed. Plenty of time for Mal to move on and sell the ship, itcwas taken etc.
New crew in the serenity on new adventures could work.
 
I loved Firefly.

I don’t need a reboot. Or a continuation. In my opinion, the time has long passed.

I do like the comics and would like to check out the novels.

You were doing so well.



Here's my main issue with those two things, as someone who's watched his Firefly DVDs a few times each and has all the books and comics. Whedon tells us one thing about his 'verse and then shows us the opposite.

Inara. We are told repeatedly that in Firefly's fictional world Inara's role is not just respected, it's prestigious. We also see plenty of scenes of romantic tension between Mal and Inara. Maybe I've been doing things wrong all my life, but I have never tried to start a relationship with a woman I like by repeatedly, angrily calling her a whore. This stuff doesn't just happen, it's written, it's down to Whedon. He created the notion that Inara's in a respected position, he created the connection between Inara and Mal, he created the way Mal talks to her. It is, frankly, kind of fucked up. The hero of the show treats the woman he loves like shit.

Chinese culture. Again, we are told one thing and shown another. We're told the 'verse is Chinese-dominated. We see virtually no Asians in the show. How'd that happen? You don't even have to talk about cultural appropriation, you can just say, hey, this doesn't make a lot of sense.

I agree on the perplexing lack of Asian characters, but with Inara I always got the impression that companion was a respected profession in the Alliance, but the further away you got from the core worlds and out into the boonies, the more likely you'd be to run into more parochial attitudes like Mal's.
 
I do like the comics and would like to check out the novels.

I've read two or three and liked them enough to keep buying them as they come out.

I agree on the perplexing lack of Asian characters, but with Inara I always got the impression that companion was a respected profession in the Alliance, but the further away you got from the core worlds and out into the boonies, the more likely you'd be to run into more parochial attitudes like Mal's.

Hell of a way to flirt, though.
 
TV and the world have moved on and some of the things that made Firefly beloved would not work so well now. Also the chemistry of the cast isn't something anyone can just recreate. Firefly worked so well, perhaps, because it ended too soon. We didn't get some awkward sophomore season that sent it into oblivion, nor did we get some Emmy award winning 3rd season. We got Serenity. The rest is just speculation.

The Expanse took Firefly's place in a lot of ways. I don't doubt Disney will try to reboot it at some point. It will make some money, even if it sucks. but they don't need to right now. They can sit on that backlog of franchises they own and dole them out when their current offerings go stale.
 
Looking back it is surprising that River and Simon weren't Chinese, that seems like it would've been a natural fit. Tam being a Chinese surname was this the original intent? It's been too long for me to remember what the details were in the show regarding them.

Would this be a D+ show or would it be a Hulu show? I could see the latter. Has D+ produced any original content aimed at an older market outside of Star Wars and Marvel? I'm not aware of anything at least in the terms of fiction shows. With such cash cows I'm not sure if they'd be interested in making something in that same realm.
 
Looking back it is surprising that River and Simon weren't Chinese, that seems like it would've been a natural fit. Tam being a Chinese surname was this the original intent? It's been too long for me to remember what the details were in the show regarding them.

I believe that was was the original plan, but I don't have a source handy for that. Sometimes the right actor walks in the door and your plans change. I think we can all agree Summer Glau was the right choice, and thus her brother needs to look like her.
 
I believe that was was the original plan, but I don't have a source handy for that. Sometimes the right actor walks in the door and your plans change. I think we can all agree Summer Glau was the right choice, and thus her brother needs to look like her.

Would have worked just as well if one or both were adopted.
 
I believe that was was the original plan, but I don't have a source handy for that. Sometimes the right actor walks in the door and your plans change. I think we can all agree Summer Glau was the right choice, and thus her brother needs to look like her.
Sean Maher does not look like Glau
 
Would have worked just as well if one or both were adopted.

That's just adding unnecessary story complications. How does a cross racial adoption change the relationship with the parents, are you going to mention they are adopted or just hope the audience figures it out?

Sean Maher does not look like Glau

They have similar coloring and are the same race, that's as good as Hollywood siblings are going to get.
 
That's just adding unnecessary story complications. How does a cross racial adoption change the relationship with the parents, are you going to mention they are adopted or just hope the audience figures it out?

Audiences likes to fill in blanks. The ones who are befuddled by two dissimilar looking people probably wouldn't have been into that show, anyway.



They have similar coloring and are the same race, that's as good as Hollywood siblings are going to get.
:thumbdown:
 
There's your real reason why you'll never see any more; between him and QAnon worshiper Adam Baldwin it's a tainted brand.

There you go -- The Adventures of Jayne Cobb. The Alliance is fair and balanced. Pax is just like the flu. Reavers are fake news and the real threat is the Jewish laser cannon that's floating around in outer space. River's psychic abilities are a blasphemy against God. The Blue Gloves are the strongest and most dedicated Christians in the 'verse.
 
I think that window slipped by some time ago. Star Trek went a few years between TAS and TMP. Firefly was 19 years ago.
 
That's just adding unnecessary story complications. How does a cross racial adoption change the relationship with the parents, are you going to mention they are adopted or just hope the audience figures it out?

You have a post apocalypse, post civil war space western where people speak and dress like 19th century cowboys and are fluent in bad mandarin, but adopting a child of a different race is what you think breaks the audience?
:vulcan:
 
If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

Sign up / Register


Back
Top