Alright episode, horrible sound mix continues.
Very good theory!OK, anyone else wondering if the Rogue Angel will turn out to be the one the Doctor has become, crossing back on its own timestream? It has the Doctor's missing memories because the Angel-Doctor tricks the Division and accesses their records, then she pops back to the past to set all this up. "Rogue Angel" then leaves Claire and turns back into Jodie (possibly the TARDIS reboot has something to do with this?)
That's a pretty good theory and I expect you're right, but I actually hope it's not true. I prefer the idea of an actual Weeping Angel rebelling for its own reasons than The Doctor operating in the appearance of one. We haven't seen Weeping Angels act with any sense of individuality before so it's fascinating to see that level of characterization now and I would hate to see that rolled back.OK, anyone else wondering if the Rogue Angel will turn out to be the one the Doctor has become, crossing back on its own timestream? It has the Doctor's missing memories because the Angel-Doctor tricks the Division and accesses their records, then she pops back to the past to set all this up. "Rogue Angel" then leaves Claire and turns back into Jodie (possibly the TARDIS reboot has something to do with this?)
Yeah, I've been chewing on that thought this whole series, too. Before this series, it seemed safe to assume they were in the distant past but now it's becoming awfully wibbly-wobbly, timey-wimey but without actually saying it (I like the phrase and I often say it, but I'm glad it hasn't been utilized here...yet).The big question is where (or rather when) are the Division? Gallifrey has been destroyed, the Timelords wiped out, and unless they rebadged as the Celestial Intervention Agency there's an argument that the Division has surely been mothballed since time of the First Doctor? So where is 13 being taken? To her present and a Division enclave off-Gallifrey, or to Gallifrey's past when the Division was still a thing? It's problematic either way really.
The big question is where (or rather when) are the Division? Gallifrey has been destroyed, the Timelords wiped out, and unless they rebadged as the Celestial Intervention Agency there's an argument that the Division has surely been mothballed since time of the First Doctor? So where is 13 being taken? To her present and a Division enclave off-Gallifrey, or to Gallifrey's past when the Division was still a thing? It's problematic either way really.
A very good question. They're starting to make it sound like the Division have been the real Time Lords all along, existing somewhere outside of time/space, with what was on Gallifrey a mere front/proxy. If Rassilon was/is part of that, then Twelve may have made the biggest mistake of his lives letting him go.
While I was slightly surprised at the inconsistency initially, I noted the girl said “nobody survives it twice” from the perspective of someone who's only met the angels yesterday, so she was just noting what she had observed to happen in 1901, not stating a universal rule.DenOfGeek says it's inconsistent that Jean and Gerald died because "no-one survives it twice" when that was the whole point of the Angels' battery farm in Angels in Manhattan, however if 1901 was their start point for quantum extraction, there may be no "past" to that version of the village for anyone else to be sent to.
Also, they note there's no tumpty-tums on the end credits... because the Doctor's hearts no longer beat? Nice touch, if so.
If I recall correctly, the problem for Amy and Rory is that their placement in the past via the Weeping Angels became a fixed point in time because of the gravestones they found.ETA: To be clear, I was more concerned if Yaz and Dan are now permanently at risk of a death by angel, or just for the episode, less with Angels in Manhattan, which I don't remember as fondly, so canon be damned. But the context assured me that Yaz and Dan will be safe in the future.
If I recall correctly, the problem for Amy and Rory is that their placement in the past via the Weeping Angels became a fixed point in time because of the gravestones they found.
The Doctor wasn't turned into an Angel; they just covered her in stone - using their own physical template - in preparation for transporting her to the Division.
We use essential cookies to make this site work, and optional cookies to enhance your experience.