In this thread, you take the plot of an episode from one "Star Trek" series, and reassign it to another.
Please refrain from jokes about real ripoff-episodes. ("Lol, all of TNG to Voyager...oh wait!! Lolz") I've heard it, it bores me.
Some ideas:
TNG: "The Next Phase"
Give to "Voyager"
Torres and Kim take the places of Ro and Geordie, getting lost in the transport accident. This plotline has the feel of an early-seasons episode, with the pair's friendship still forming. Like Ro, B'Elanna initially thinks they're dead, and wonders if the Barge of the Dead is still a myth, or if she's been rejected by the Klingon afterlife altogether.
Tom Paris--who B'Elanna hasn't confessed her feelings to yet--fills the role of Commander Riker, in this sense:
TOM: "I'd like to say a few words at the memorial service."
JANEWAY: "Of course, Harry was your best friend."
TOM: "Actually, I was thinking of B'Elanna."
B'ELANNA: (Invisible to them) "What are you going to say about me?!"
Neelix arranges the oddly festive "memorial service." Kes probably senses that B'Elanna and the Dweeb are still alive. Replace the evil Romulan with a Kazon; it's fun to see those dunderheads tumbling stupidly through space. And of course, B'Elanna doesn't get to find out what Tom was going to say about her, until "Day of Honor" in Season 4.
DS9: "Children of Time"
Give to "Voyager"
While an interesting concept, it felt like a random story to toss into the saga of DS9. Not to mention the contrivance of getting the entire space station's staff onto one ship for some relatively unimportant mission, right as the Federation is on the brink of war.
IMO, this story idea makes far more sense for "Voyager," both logically and thematically. Instead of yanking the most important officers from DS9 away for some contrived mission, just have the entire small starship Voyager and it's full 140 crewmembers fall into a strange anomaly--one they'll soon learn is fairly well-known to regular travelers in this region of space, but of course, they had no preparation for. Faced with their future descendants, Janeway and her crew must decide if they're going to give up on their journey home and settle on this planetoid, or find a way out of this and erase their descendants from the timeline.
Set this some time after Seven of Nine joins the crew, but before Voyager makes contact with Starfleet, and before Tom and B'Elanna have gotten really serious. Tom and B'Elanna get used to the idea of someday having a family together; Janeay and Chakotay start to reconsider their relationship from "Resolutions" (but as a heathy adult relationship rather than a bad romance-novel one); Harry, naturaly, is the most distressed about the situation.
Voyager's knowledge of the Borg, 8472, and other threats comes into the ethical debate. Tuvok points out that Voyager may save more lives in the long-run by continuing home, if only to make it far enough to contact Starfleet and give them the information they've gained in the Delta Quadrant; Neelix or someone then points out that Tuvok might be trying to use logic to justify his desperation to get home to T'Pel and his children.
In the end, one person makes the cold calculation that Voyager's knowledge of the Borg and 8472 getting back to Starfleet is more important than this stranded colony, and resets the timeline. But it isn't Tuvok or Seven of Nine that does it. It isn't even Harry. It's the Doctor. But not the "real" Doctor, the future-Doctor, that's been living with the colony for the last ten generations. He's centuries evolved past his initial programing, and being stranded and constantly seeing friends die around him wile he's the only immortal has changed him. Future-Doc decides that Voyager will save more lives, and their descendants will have higher-quality lives, if they aren't stranded on this planet. Naturally, present-Doc is horrified by his future self's decision to ignore the Hipocratic Oath (though that itself is up for debate, if timeline-erasure is the same as "doing harm.")
VOY: "Before and After"
Give to "Deep Space Nine"
Instead of Kes simply going backwards through her life, Dax is moving backwards through all of its past and future hosts! It starts in the future, when Dax is about to retire to the Pools of Mocha (or whatever they're called). Something happens that causes the Dax symbiont to move backwards through its life, and all its past hosts.
In the alternate future seen here, Ezri is never joined to Dax; instead, Jadzia lives a longer life, and has children with Worf. But things are less happy for everyone else. The Dominion caught the Federation off-guard, causing the Dominion War to last decades, and claiming the lives of Ben Sisko and many other major characters.
In the end, only Jadzia Dax's friends on DS9 are able to help stop the time-jumping. The episode ends with Dax's life reset shortly before the Dominion War starts. Jadzia Dax decides to break the Prime Directive and warn Sisko about the Dominion's surprise attack/Martok being a Changeling/whatever the main factor in the old timeline was, saving her friends and the Federation, even knowing that it might cost her her own happiness. In fact, Dax's knowledge of the future of the war might even be the reason she is eventually murdered.
Seasons later, this makes Jadzia's parting words to Worf, "Our baby would have been so beautiful," so much more tragic and heavy. And Ezri Dax is even more confused, as she knows she wasn't originally "supposed" to be joined, and Dax no longer has any future knowledge to go off of here.
VOY: "Latent Image"
Give to "Next Generation"
After a season or so of the series acting like Tasha Yar never existed, this episode explains why: Data was so affected by her loss that his program malfunctioned, and Picard had all of Data's memories of Tasha erased. Geordie, being the engineer, had to erase his best friend's memories to save him. Guilt and angst all around.
DS9: "Empok Nor"
Give to "Discovery"
"Empok Nor" isn't a bad episode, but like "Children of Time," it's quite random for DS9. On the other hand, have the Discovery find an abandoned space station, after they've jumped into the 32nd Century. Maybe the space station was built in their time period, hence why the tiny remnants of the Federation send them to investigate it. And obviously Saru is the one to go berserk and start killing people, because he needs something to make him interesting.
VOY: "Flashback"
Give to "Discovery"
Adira Tal, still suffering some amnesia, must dig into old memories of a past host to solve some mystery. Perhaps some 32nd Century tech allows Paul or Michael to "mind-meld" with Adira, and "accompany" them into the "past." If it's a memory from Gray Tal's life, Adira's Force-Ghost boyfriend can be the tourguide to the past.
DS9: "Honor Among Thieves"
Give to any post-2009 "Star Trek"
Seriously, trying to do a plot about an undercover cop spying on the space mafia does. Not. Work. With '90s TV censorship. Let Dr. Juratti, ranger-Seven, Michael Burnham, or Book go undercover in a series that can actually show a gritty criminal underworld, with naughty language.
Maybe make it "Discovery," and use this to introduce Book's cat, as the original DS9 episode did for Chester.
GIMME MORE.
Please refrain from jokes about real ripoff-episodes. ("Lol, all of TNG to Voyager...oh wait!! Lolz") I've heard it, it bores me.
Some ideas:
TNG: "The Next Phase"
Give to "Voyager"
Torres and Kim take the places of Ro and Geordie, getting lost in the transport accident. This plotline has the feel of an early-seasons episode, with the pair's friendship still forming. Like Ro, B'Elanna initially thinks they're dead, and wonders if the Barge of the Dead is still a myth, or if she's been rejected by the Klingon afterlife altogether.
Tom Paris--who B'Elanna hasn't confessed her feelings to yet--fills the role of Commander Riker, in this sense:
TOM: "I'd like to say a few words at the memorial service."
JANEWAY: "Of course, Harry was your best friend."
TOM: "Actually, I was thinking of B'Elanna."
B'ELANNA: (Invisible to them) "What are you going to say about me?!"
Neelix arranges the oddly festive "memorial service." Kes probably senses that B'Elanna and the Dweeb are still alive. Replace the evil Romulan with a Kazon; it's fun to see those dunderheads tumbling stupidly through space. And of course, B'Elanna doesn't get to find out what Tom was going to say about her, until "Day of Honor" in Season 4.
DS9: "Children of Time"
Give to "Voyager"
While an interesting concept, it felt like a random story to toss into the saga of DS9. Not to mention the contrivance of getting the entire space station's staff onto one ship for some relatively unimportant mission, right as the Federation is on the brink of war.
IMO, this story idea makes far more sense for "Voyager," both logically and thematically. Instead of yanking the most important officers from DS9 away for some contrived mission, just have the entire small starship Voyager and it's full 140 crewmembers fall into a strange anomaly--one they'll soon learn is fairly well-known to regular travelers in this region of space, but of course, they had no preparation for. Faced with their future descendants, Janeway and her crew must decide if they're going to give up on their journey home and settle on this planetoid, or find a way out of this and erase their descendants from the timeline.
Set this some time after Seven of Nine joins the crew, but before Voyager makes contact with Starfleet, and before Tom and B'Elanna have gotten really serious. Tom and B'Elanna get used to the idea of someday having a family together; Janeay and Chakotay start to reconsider their relationship from "Resolutions" (but as a heathy adult relationship rather than a bad romance-novel one); Harry, naturaly, is the most distressed about the situation.
Voyager's knowledge of the Borg, 8472, and other threats comes into the ethical debate. Tuvok points out that Voyager may save more lives in the long-run by continuing home, if only to make it far enough to contact Starfleet and give them the information they've gained in the Delta Quadrant; Neelix or someone then points out that Tuvok might be trying to use logic to justify his desperation to get home to T'Pel and his children.
In the end, one person makes the cold calculation that Voyager's knowledge of the Borg and 8472 getting back to Starfleet is more important than this stranded colony, and resets the timeline. But it isn't Tuvok or Seven of Nine that does it. It isn't even Harry. It's the Doctor. But not the "real" Doctor, the future-Doctor, that's been living with the colony for the last ten generations. He's centuries evolved past his initial programing, and being stranded and constantly seeing friends die around him wile he's the only immortal has changed him. Future-Doc decides that Voyager will save more lives, and their descendants will have higher-quality lives, if they aren't stranded on this planet. Naturally, present-Doc is horrified by his future self's decision to ignore the Hipocratic Oath (though that itself is up for debate, if timeline-erasure is the same as "doing harm.")
VOY: "Before and After"
Give to "Deep Space Nine"
Instead of Kes simply going backwards through her life, Dax is moving backwards through all of its past and future hosts! It starts in the future, when Dax is about to retire to the Pools of Mocha (or whatever they're called). Something happens that causes the Dax symbiont to move backwards through its life, and all its past hosts.
In the alternate future seen here, Ezri is never joined to Dax; instead, Jadzia lives a longer life, and has children with Worf. But things are less happy for everyone else. The Dominion caught the Federation off-guard, causing the Dominion War to last decades, and claiming the lives of Ben Sisko and many other major characters.
In the end, only Jadzia Dax's friends on DS9 are able to help stop the time-jumping. The episode ends with Dax's life reset shortly before the Dominion War starts. Jadzia Dax decides to break the Prime Directive and warn Sisko about the Dominion's surprise attack/Martok being a Changeling/whatever the main factor in the old timeline was, saving her friends and the Federation, even knowing that it might cost her her own happiness. In fact, Dax's knowledge of the future of the war might even be the reason she is eventually murdered.
Seasons later, this makes Jadzia's parting words to Worf, "Our baby would have been so beautiful," so much more tragic and heavy. And Ezri Dax is even more confused, as she knows she wasn't originally "supposed" to be joined, and Dax no longer has any future knowledge to go off of here.
VOY: "Latent Image"
Give to "Next Generation"
After a season or so of the series acting like Tasha Yar never existed, this episode explains why: Data was so affected by her loss that his program malfunctioned, and Picard had all of Data's memories of Tasha erased. Geordie, being the engineer, had to erase his best friend's memories to save him. Guilt and angst all around.
DS9: "Empok Nor"
Give to "Discovery"
"Empok Nor" isn't a bad episode, but like "Children of Time," it's quite random for DS9. On the other hand, have the Discovery find an abandoned space station, after they've jumped into the 32nd Century. Maybe the space station was built in their time period, hence why the tiny remnants of the Federation send them to investigate it. And obviously Saru is the one to go berserk and start killing people, because he needs something to make him interesting.
VOY: "Flashback"
Give to "Discovery"
Adira Tal, still suffering some amnesia, must dig into old memories of a past host to solve some mystery. Perhaps some 32nd Century tech allows Paul or Michael to "mind-meld" with Adira, and "accompany" them into the "past." If it's a memory from Gray Tal's life, Adira's Force-Ghost boyfriend can be the tourguide to the past.
DS9: "Honor Among Thieves"
Give to any post-2009 "Star Trek"
Seriously, trying to do a plot about an undercover cop spying on the space mafia does. Not. Work. With '90s TV censorship. Let Dr. Juratti, ranger-Seven, Michael Burnham, or Book go undercover in a series that can actually show a gritty criminal underworld, with naughty language.
Maybe make it "Discovery," and use this to introduce Book's cat, as the original DS9 episode did for Chester.
GIMME MORE.