• Welcome! The TrekBBS is the number one place to chat about Star Trek with like-minded fans.
    If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

DC Movies - To Infinity and Beyond

I'm a fan of epic 3 hour movies. Back in the day when cinemas still used film it was usually broken into two parts and you could stretch your legs and go to the bathroom. It was kind of like watching a stage play.
 
I'm a fan of epic 3 hour movies. Back in the day when cinemas still used film it was usually broken into two parts and you could stretch your legs and go to the bathroom. It was kind of like watching a stage play.
ROTK and Endgame needed a bathroom break in the middle! And when orchestras play LOTR live in concert they do add an intermission :)
 
I recently watched Aquaman and Shazam for the first time. I liked Shazam a lot more as I felt far more invested in the characters and felt the lead performances were stronger.

Would definitely be in favour of the drum-playing octopus from Aquaman returning though.
 
I loved Wonder Woman, really liked Aquaman, Shazam and The Suicide Squad, was meh on Suicide Squad and Justice League (though I did finally feel like I was watching Superman, weird upper lip and all), hated MoS, REALLY hated BvS, and haven't yet seen WW84 and the JL Snyder cut.
 
MoS, BvS, WW(1), Aquaman and ZSJL are among the strongest, most coherent, structurally sound attempts to place comic book characters & their fantasy conflicts in real world settings ever attempted, and feel like a naturally connected world thanks to story, not Easter eggs and just dropping situations into films and expecting it make sense. Most of the lead characters (namely Superman, Batman & Wonder Woman) all feel like versions of their printed counterparts seen over the decades. Its very rare for any comic book movie's characters to come so close, that one could not imagine any other performers in those roles.

Wonder Woman and Aquaman were not very established here in the Netherlands when growing up, so I'll have to take your word on them.
I agree with you on Batman and Superman. WW1 was still a very enjoyable film for me, but not as great as some feel it is. Aquaman.... I enjoyed it too. But it felt to me like trying to grab in on the succes of GotG and Thor Ragnarok, with more humor added, loads of odd looking cgi creatures and more colorful.
 
I’m amazed we haven’t got any GL stuff since then. Closest we got is Stargirl and whatever they are doing with Diggle.
All they need to do is adapt Johns’ run and they would have the perfect franchise.
Hubby and I thought Green Lantern: First Flight would've made a terrific live-action film.

The extended cut on Blu-ray does exactly that.
Good. I liked Green Lantern, but thought it needed a good editor.

MoS, BvS, WW(1), Aquaman and ZSJL are among the strongest, most coherent, structurally sound attempts to place comic book characters & their fantasy conflicts in real world settings ever attempted, and feel like a naturally connected world thanks to story, not Easter eggs and just dropping situations into films and expecting it make sense. Most of the lead characters (namely Superman, Batman & Wonder Woman) all feel like versions of their printed counterparts seen over the decades. Its very rare for any comic book movie's characters to come so close, that one could not imagine any other performers in those roles.
I hated MoS when we saw it in the theater and when I catch parts of it on TV, I still don't like it. I understand now that Snyder planned MoS, BvS, and JL as a trilogy, with Clark becoming the beacon of hope I love in JL, but I just didn't connect with Supes in MoS. YMMV

The best part of BvS for me was Affleck & Irons. They really captured the characters IMO. Sadly, as much as I usually like Jesse Eisenberg, I didn't dig his version of Lex. Hubby told me the extended cut is better, but I haven't seen it yet.

ZSJL made so much more sense! I wanted to beat up Whedon even more than I already did. :mad:

Wonder Woman was perfect. I will happily watch it a million times. I will have to re-watch WW84 to see if I like it better the 2nd time (that happens for me sometimes).

I recently watched Aquaman and Shazam for the first time. I liked Shazam a lot more as I felt far more invested in the characters and felt the lead performances were stronger.

Would definitely be in favour of the drum-playing octopus from Aquaman returning though.
I really liked Aquaman! I didn't expect much going in, but it was fun and gorgeous (not just Jason and Amber :)). I saw it again and still like it.

Shazam! was marvelous! ;) Zack Levi was perfect. My dad had complained the superhero movies had gotten too dark, so we showed him Shazam! and he loved it! Again, I saw it more than once and still liked it.
 
I loved Amy Adams in MoS. Not so much in BvS. The only part of BvS I really unreservedly liked was Gal Gadot.

Wonder Woman was perfect. I will happily watch it a million times. I will have to re-watch WW84 to see if I like it better the 2nd time (that happens for me sometimes).

I know I'm really in the minority on this one, but I adored WW84 from the first moment I saw it (watched it twice right off the bat). I'd say it's slightly more fun than the first one, which I also love, and maybe even a tad higher than MoS for me (which is around the same level for me as WW). It feels like a fantastic continuation of the original film's style while also playing in a totally different era (of all the retro 80s films that came out in recent years, WW84 was by far the best at actually feeling like an 80s movie yet also still being fun from a modern viewpoint). Plus, Pedro Pascal absolutely killed it, imo. Best villain in the dceu movies.
 
I know I'm really in the minority on this one, but I adored WW84 from the first moment I saw it (watched it twice right off the bat). I'd say it's slightly more fun than the first one, which I also love, and maybe even a tad higher than MoS for me (which is around the same level for me as WW). It feels like a fantastic continuation of the original film's style while also playing in a totally different era (of all the retro 80s films that came out in recent years, WW84 was by far the best at actually feeling like an 80s movie yet also still being fun from a modern viewpoint). Plus, Pedro Pascal absolutely killed it, imo. Best villain in the dceu movies.
As someone who was a teenager in the 80s, they definitely got the feel right. The mall looked terrifyingly familiar. :lol:

Pedro was terrific, but I wouldn't say he was a villain so much as someone who got in waaaaaay over his head. I wish they hadn't called him Max Lord. It had me expecting something different.
 
I hate it when DC movies/tv uses characters in name only like that because it means that we aren't going to see a more comics accurate version of the character any time soon. A Justice League reboot of the nineties version of the League GotG style might actually have been a success.
 
The last thing anyone wanted to see was a joke-splattered JL movie, which is what a GOTG-styled movie would have been. Essentially, that's a MCU format championed not only by GOTG, but other films in that franchise, like Whedon's, and we saw what a disaster it was when Whedon tried to apply to the theatrical version of JL.
 
There's nothing wrong with jokes (even lots of them) in a superhero movie. And if there were, Wonder Woman, Aquaman and especially Shazam would have been disasters, too.

Obviously the style of humor (and presentation in general) used in a Justice League movie should be very different from the style of the GotG because they are very different groups of characters but I do not believe anyone said otherwise.
 
Last edited:
The last thing anyone wanted to see was a joke-splattered JL movie, which is what a GOTG-styled movie would have been. Essentially, that's a MCU format championed not only by GOTG, but other films in that franchise, like Whedon's, and we saw what a disaster it was when Whedon tried to apply to the theatrical version of JL.

I was referring to the line up of Blue Beetle, Guy Gardner, Mister Miracle, etc by DeMatteis and Giffen. The era where Max Lord appeared--but I guess that was the 80s, wasn't it?
 
Remember when Gavin O’Connor was meant to make the sequel to Suicide Squad? Well, it seems that a change in regime at WB also meant a change in what was wanted from the film:

there was a regime change at DC Films, and suddenly the studio was asking him for a distinctly different take than the one he was writing. “What happened was during the latter part of writing the script there was a whole regime change at DC, and when that happened, they wanted it to be a comedy,” he recalled. “And I’m like, ‘i’m not writing a comedy.‘ I mean, It [was] fun, but it’s not a yuk-fest. And the new regime wanted a different movie than I was writing.”


https://theplaylist.net/gavin-oconnor-suicide-sq-20210912/?utm_source=dlvr.it&utm_medium=twitter

Personally, as I loved TSS, I think his loss was our gain.
 
There's nothing wrong with jokes (even lots of them) in a superhero movie. And if there were, Wonder Woman, Aquaman and especially Shazam would have been disasters, too.

Wonder Woman had very light moments here and there, and was not filled with jokes like certain superhero films. Largely, it was a darker film ending on a somber note, which is why it worked so well as a WW's origin story set during a war.

Superhero films need their own voices, and that comes from not copy+pasting that same approach used in a number of superhero movies.
 
Superhero films need their own voices, and that comes from not copy+pasting that same approach used in a number of superhero movies.
Yeah if only the DCEU had been like that and MOS, and BvS and the Snyder cut of JL hadn't all been in the same vein as The Dark Knight and The Dark Knight rises eh eh?
 
If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

Sign up / Register


Back
Top