Honestly, I think that the second half of Voyager may have been a bit altered by the previous timeline reset. I don't think 7 of 9 existed as a drone before the events of FC. YMMV.
News Strange New Worlds casting/new characters
- Thread starter F. King Daniel
- Start date
This has been the question. Is M'Benga the CMO? If not, who is?
Personally, I don't think that he is. I think he is serving out his residency and will be transferred to Vulcan to finish up. McCoy takes over as CMO and has more time in grade.
I'm going with Colt being another unknown (and much less murderous) Salt Creature.I just want the real Yeoman Colt.....
Thus the two different looks.
I said this and still stand by it... but I can't help but be excited for Cadet Uhura. Cause I'm stoked that she's returning to TV Trek. Also, cause Uhura is my third favorite character after Kirk and Spock.
No.
Even if M'Benga was a CMO when he joined the Enterprise crew, I'm sure he probably deferred the position to McCoy since Kirk (The Captain) chose "Bones" to be in that position.
I also always thought that M'Benga specifically asked to be transferred to the Enterprise so he could study Spock as a half-human/Vulcan individual.
Something M'Benga would never had access to if he had remained on Vulcan.
I also always thought that M'Benga specifically asked to be transferred to the Enterprise so he could study Spock as a half-human/Vulcan individual.
Something M'Benga would never had access to if he had remained on Vulcan.
Easily fixed. McCoy is the overall CMO for the ship while M'Benga is the night watch CMO.
Looks like they got a good actor for the part. The one thing I've never had an issue with, with the modern TPTB is their ability to cast good actors that fit the roles.
If this version of M'Benga needs to be crammed into the old continuity, then, whatever his position, he obviously left the Enterprise if he is the CMO in SNW. Piper is identified as a department head in "Where No Man...", McCoy is clearly the CMO in the two episodes M'Benga appears in. It is noted in "A Private Little War" that M'Benga spent time on Vulcan, prior to when we see him in TOS.
We have to age him up a bit for SNW, as Booker Bradshaw was only 27 in TOS, but it could be simply that M'Benga wasn't interested in being a starship CMO after giving it a whirl. He returned to the Enterprise under McCoy to finish his commitment to Starfleet in 2267-68.
We have to age him up a bit for SNW, as Booker Bradshaw was only 27 in TOS, but it could be simply that M'Benga wasn't interested in being a starship CMO after giving it a whirl. He returned to the Enterprise under McCoy to finish his commitment to Starfleet in 2267-68.
I am okay with all of this being a rewritten timeline where things like this happen a bit differently.
Yep. This is the First Contact timeline. Everything has been changed since the events of that movie.
Because...in the real world, everything about Star Trek was changed by that movie.
Still don't buy this theory.
Just saw the cast video, was disappointed not to see Dr. Boyce in there. But glad to see M'Benga, good deep cut!
Absolutely untrue.
I doubt they'll show Boyce .
Might become like discovery where there is no or absent Cmo.
Do wish there were more aliens in the main crew. Even if it was a light makeup like a Deltan.
Might become like discovery where there is no or absent Cmo.
Do wish there were more aliens in the main crew. Even if it was a light makeup like a Deltan.
How I approach it. Giant multiverse. Strange New Worlds is its own thing, broad strokes will likely be similar, details will be different. Spock will likely see Sarek in this show, encounter Romulans, go to Iotia and so on, doesn't change the narrative of TOS in any way.
Similar threads
- Poll
