Spoilers Star Trek Discovery 3x12 Season 3 Episode 12 The Good of the People - Promo Trailer

What is the complaint about the Burnham whisper? For several episodes, there have been such complaints in various comments here, on trekcore, on youtube etc. In the meantime, I again like crying, I do not notice. I feel excluded.

 

Its used as a cheap way to make things sound (whispers) dramatic. It's bad acting/directing.

I actually don't mind it too much though just find it funny. Bit like Kirk's stunted speech or Rikers layman's explanations

 

This came from my brother not me, so I have to give proper credit before I post this speculation: He thinks Voyager-J will play a part in this episode.

 

Oh, so another crying type of accusation. Probably soon somebody will have to create the Discovery whispering thread.

 

Well it is a legitimate criticism and so is the crying

I understand they get used by people who also attack DIS in racist and sexist ways but it doesn't mean it's unfounded

 

It's just an acting choice by SMG. I might not like it, but it's not bad acting.

 

I wonder why the leaked titles for earlier episodes this season were spot-on but a few of these later ones have shifted. I'm sure it's been mentioned already but "The Citadel" is now "There Is A Tide..."

I'm guessing it's because postproduction was still well underway for these later episodes when the season premiered?

 

Bad choice then if you want rather than bad acting. But for me the choices made are part of good and bad acting

 

Its a YMMV thing.

 

It's actually a "find anything and everything to winge about" thing.

 

No, "The Citadel" became "Su'Kal". "The Good of the People" became "There is a Tide..."

I strongly suspect that "Outside" won't have that name either.

 

Indeed. Though, it seems rather unfathomable to the Internet that what one person finds bad another would dare find good.

 

Titles often aren't finalized until the last minute, and these are hardly the first examples in the franchise of an episode being titled something other than what was originally reported as its title.

 

Plus you would have to change your avatar
Super inconvenient!

 

So am I not allowed mention it then in case someone else disagrees?

I never told anyone else on here they were wrong if they like the whispering or denied their right to disagree so I really dont get your point

 

Egads.

Guys, so TimeIsAPredator said Burnham whispers? So what? This doesn't sound worthy of making a mountain out of a molehill. Let it go.

The rest of us want to talk about the next episode.

 

Didn't say that at all.

Good point.

 

I think you're right. "Outside" makes sense in the context of the dialogue of "Su'Kal", but I expect we'll see that one change title as well. Soon.

 

^ Probably to "That hope is you, part 2", which is suspiciously still missing.