Face-ess Of Boe.
You saw it here first...
On a serious note, if they're going to address / resolve the Kelvin timeline in any way, here is the opportunity.
Spoilers Robert Meyer Burnett: "Terra Firma" will ruin Trek canon
- Thread starter Romulan_spy
- Start date
- Status
You saw it here first...
On a serious note, if they're going to address / resolve the Kelvin timeline in any way, here is the opportunity.
I am hoping for a merge soon........
Fair point.....I even groaned a little when I saw they were going to Talos IV last year, but it wound up being one of the season's best episodes for me. I don't care what they do........just do it well.
Star Trek has always been internally consistent until the writers decide otherwise. Has been this way since TOS.
I really don't see the big deal with the Guardian of Foreever having a humanoid form or humanoid avatar or whatever. The thing is ancient and maybe it got sick of looking like a temporal glory hole.
I never watched it. Now I see I made the right call.
This sounds the most likely. There are 800 years for them to work with to find out about the Kelvin Timeline.
The Guardian rumor has been floating around on Reddit for almost a year along with the CGI Spock and one about a really old actor that appears in the finale and was very frail during filming. So much so that they had to add another day to filming because they needed rest and filming was delayed. I’m curious to see what if ANY of the talk is true.
There’s a few different takes one could get from this, going from the Doctor Who reference.
Given the GoF’s purpose, it’s likely that we may get an “Impossible Girl” scenario, which would actually be cool as hell, but would piss off the Burnham haters.
Or, as it appears he’s confirmed since, it will be like when the TARDIS was inside that woman’s head, and was able to communicate with The Doctor in human form.
For whatever it’s worth, both those plots were great in Dr Who (the latter was incredibly popular with viewers, at the time). I could see them working in Trek.
He’s being deliberately vague, though, so F him.
This is turning into a tell your parents you're pregnant to soften the news that you failed your math test situation.
If the Guardian possesses a person Idris-style... well that might kind of cool. If the Guardian simply has a humanoid avatar, that actually sounds closer to Ellison's original concept.
Either way this doesn't seem nearly as canon-destroying as "Ephraim and Dot."
If the Guardian possesses a person Idris-style... well that might kind of cool. If the Guardian simply has a humanoid avatar, that actually sounds closer to Ellison's original concept.
Either way this doesn't seem nearly as canon-destroying as "Ephraim and Dot."
Exactly. And even then, Ephraim and Dot was only canon-destroying if you take Star Trek way too seriously. At the end of the day it was a fun little cartoon and a celebration of TOS. Hardly meant to be taken as something that actually happened.
Soooo....Edith Keeler was the reason the MU and the PU split, am I getting that right?
Yeah it's just a fun cartoon. But I'm kinda of surprised they haven't digitally scrubbed the A off the hull, in that Short Trek since. It was obviously a mistake nobody spotted but wouldn't be there, had anybody realised sooner.
Last edited:
I'm not sure where you're getting that from.
welllll....I'm not sure either
Joan Collins and Saru necking.
- Status