• Welcome! The TrekBBS is the number one place to chat about Star Trek with like-minded fans.
    If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

What are your controversial Star Trek opinions?

You'll be surprised to see how fast things are changing.

One day your Real Life story might get portrayed on TV.

And you will want a accurate casted actor to portray you.

Not just some random schmuck they found that they liked.
I want competency, and that’s not down to factors we have no control over. I didnt choose my races, and I refuse to be defined by them.
 
I want competency, and that’s not down to factors we have no control over. I didnt choose my races, and I refuse to be defined by them.
I wouldn't want to watch a inaccurate documentary if they can't even get the basic facts right in portrayal.

I'd rather define accurate type casting then not.

There are PLENTY of competent actors out there, just give them a shot.

I wouldn't want Hollywood to cast some random Sweedish girl to portray your life story.

That makes no sense to do that.

We need accurate casting requirements and you want to open the play field to just about any rando.
 
I wouldn't want to watch a inaccurate documentary if they can't even get the basic facts right in portrayal.

I'd rather define accurate type casting then not.

There are PLENTY of competent actors out there, just give them a shot.

I wouldn't want Hollywood to cast some random Sweedish girl to portray your life story.

That makes no sense to do that.

We need accurate casting requirements and you want to open the play field to just about any rando.
Ok, I trust you.
 
You'll be surprised to see how fast things are changing.

One day your Real Life story might get portrayed on TV.

And you will want a accurate casted actor to portray you.

Not just some random schmuck they found that they liked.

I would not care what culture the actor playing me in a movie would hail from.
Yes accurate in appearance and portrayal, but that doesn't mean they have to match my "ethnicity"
I have full confidence in American, French and British actors to portray me.

Ok, I trust you.

Why? He literally thinks it would be wrong for a French woman to play a character of any other origin.
 
Why? He literally thinks it would be wrong for a French woman to play a character of any other origin.
No, I think it's wrong for a Sweedish woman to portray Morgan Primus documentary on his life that is accurate to his life story. It's not a random blank slate character that you can shove just about anybody into.
 
Lol, i don’t care as long as she does it well. Infinite Diversity in Infinite Combinations.

My mother was German/Italian. Is this not diversity?
Are you hiring this woman to portray your mother?

Or are you hiring her to protray you?

IMO, only a Half Caucasian of German/Italian mixture + Half Black would be the most accurate way to represent you.

I'm sure we'll find the right actor eventually.
 
Are you hiring this woman to portray your mother?

Or are you hiring her to protray you?

IMO, only a Half Caucasian of German/Italian mixture + Half Black would be the most accurate way to represent you.

I'm sure we'll find the right actor eventually.
Lol. Thank you for being kind to me. cheers. x

I’m not being sarcastic either, you could have attacked me, and you didn’t
 
And what's your Ethnic & National heritage?

That's none of your business. But if you believe that people of different countries are so different that people from other countries can never portray them correctly then you should have no difficulties telling me my "ethnic and national heritage"

No, I think it's wrong for a Sweedish woman to portray Morgan Primus documentary on his life that is accurate to his life story. It's not a random blank slate character that you can shove just about anybody into.

Nope, you said it was wrong that Red October cast an Sean Connery instead of a Russian. That a French woman shouldn't play an English Queen and that skill was less important than having some random ancestor who matches the ethnicity of a character.
 
If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

Sign up / Register


Back
Top