• Welcome! The TrekBBS is the number one place to chat about Star Trek with like-minded fans.
    If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

Lower Decks Trailer Analysis

I was also basing it on the fact that space travel is a lot more common in Star Trek's time than it is today. It really is analogous to modern day sea travel. Unlike NASA, you have people going into space just to do "menial" or "routine" stuff like serving food, cleaning, or whatever. Now yes, there are likely cases of people doing these jobs doubling up and contributing to the "more important" tasks, particularly on smaller ships just like happens today, but in the end, not everyone in Starfleet is going to have the equivalent of a few PHDs, or even be Academy graduates or even have any post-secondary education. Hell, there is canonical precedent in on screen material for this notion, given Simon Tarses in The Drumhead even said he chose to go the enlisted route as opposed to becoming an officer exactly because he was 18 and not interested in spending years in a classroom.

Oh, I agree that there are the enlisted who don't go through the academy, they would probably do the lower engineering tasks like maintenance. But even though they exist, that is not how Starfleet has been portrayed. Unless there are massive numbers of enlisted that we just don't see, most of the "basic" work is carried out by officers - which is also backed up in canon. Starfleet, as portrayed, is mostly super-educated and super-capable officers doing most things. For everything else there should be automated processes and robots.

Regardless of all this, the characters in LDS are officers and thus they should be highly capable, highly educated, best of what the Federation can find - even on a second-tier ship (second contact doesn't mean bottom of the barrel, just specialized).

If there are actually large numbers of enlisted, as would be logical following current naval tradition, that would only make it more likely the young officers we are following should be elite.
 
Last edited:
Regardless of all this, the characters in LDS are officers and thus they should be highly capable, highly educated, best of what the Federation can find
Well, they're still in a comedy show. So, their capability is still going to be limited by quirks ;)
 
The Kelvinverse movies are also what I would call modern Trek. We might as well call it the Abramsverse though since everything made within it has a connection to Abrams and that also includes Kurtzman. When Kurtzman finally leaves we will I guess move onto the next phase of the franchise whatever that might be.


Jason
 
I’ve been trying to watch the trailer. Unfortunately every where I look (including CBS itself) it says ‘video not available’. So I’ve been trying to watch the different reviews to see it. And really I’m not impressed. Really the animation style is very flat and boring. And the voices are annoying, and so is the comedy or lack of comedy. I’m thinking that, from the trailer, “Lower Decks” is the ‘jump the shark’ series, and I’m thinking of skipping it.
 
I’ve been trying to watch the trailer. Unfortunately every where I look (including CBS itself) it says ‘video not available’. So I’ve been trying to watch the different reviews to see it. And really I’m not impressed. Really the animation style is very flat and boring. And the voices are annoying, and so is the comedy or lack of comedy. I’m thinking that, from the trailer, “Lower Decks” is the ‘jump the shark’ series, and I’m thinking of skipping it.
The series jumped the shark long ago.
 
It at least explains how the Enterprise had only 203 and then suddenly 400 people aboard - more rooms were built into all that empty space ;)
 
I'm not. I just wanted to make sure you were reacting to the right thing. ;)

JTFC! That makes no damn sense! Why all of the empty space the wild curves, rails and turns?! Do the show runners not realize these things are just ELEVATORS that can also go sideways and that's something that we have TODAY! I mean... You're telling me on the Enterprise which is supposed to only be slightly bigger than an aircraft carrier has the huge, empty, cavern in the middle of it with the turbocars doing wild spins and turns on rails just to go up or down a couple floors and maybe slide over a couple dozen feet?

Good. GOD!
 
Last edited:
If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

Sign up / Register


Back
Top