Since no one else is posting here anymore, I'll just save my thoughts in one big post until the conversation picks up.
6/25 #1: It dawned on me earlier today, that I think Ellie killed Alice, the dog, when she snuck into the Aquarium. Fuck!
#2: If they make me choose who lives in the conflict between Ellie and Abbie, I don't know who I'm going to choose.
6/26 #1: Damn, every time they make you start to really hate a person or group, they suddenly flip things around on you and you suddenly start to sympathize with them. First they did that with Abby, then the Wolves, and now the Seraphites.
Going through the Aquarium as Abby after Ellie has killed everyone there, is definitely a very different experience from going through it and fighting them as Ellie.
The big confrontation at the Theater did not end the way I expected at all.
Damn, just when I though Ellie was actually going to get something as close to a happy ending as someone who went through what she did could get, Tommy had the show up and ruin it.
#3 Just finished it, and damn that was one hell of an ending. Not at all what I expected, but I am very happy with it.