• Welcome! The TrekBBS is the number one place to chat about Star Trek with like-minded fans.
    If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

Spoilers Picard 1x1, "Remembrance"

Rate the episode


  • Total voters
    473
Not if along with the end of the evacuation Federation fleet, the worlds they were to be evacuated to closed off too. Patrick Stewart wanted his show to be a mirror of the refugee crisis. If the Federation decided "Since the fleet is closed off, why should these worlds or our worlds still be open to Romulans, our enemy?"

If the Fed also blocked worlds for Romulus to evacuate to, they couldn't evacuate millions because there would be no place to put those millions.

Romulan space is vast. I doubt the Federation would block the Romulans from evacuting to planets within Romulan held space that is away from the danger zone. That would be interfering with another culture's internal affairs.
 
Last edited:
Romulan space is vast. I doubt the Federation would block the Romulans from evacuting to planets within Romulan held space. That would be interfering with another culture's internal affairs
Vast Romulan space doesn't automatically equal planets habitable for Romulan people. That's why the Genesis project was such a big deal.

Russia and China are vast. Yet wide swaths of Russia are chilly wastes.

If Romulan space was so easy and vast, the Remans would have ditched Remus years ago.
 
Vast Romulan space doesn't automatically equal planets habitable for Romulan people. That's why the Genesis project was such a big deal.

Russia and China are vast. Yet wide swaths of Russia are chilly wastes.

If Romulan space was so easy and vast, the Remans would have ditched Remus years ago.

Not saying it would 'easy'. But I'm certain they would at the very least be able to transport a million people that is outside the danger zone but still within their space. Heck you probably only need ONE planet for that.

Let's says things were flip flopped and the supernova was happening to Earth. I'm pretty sure star feet would be a be to save at least one million by transporting people to places like Vulcan or any of the countless federation worlds/colonys/starbases/moons etc

Also, there should be allot of romulans existing outside the danger zone by default. I'm pretty sure they have populaces living in other systems.
 
Last edited:
Also, the recent Picard prequel comic outright has evacuation of some colony world that is not Romulus, so Picard is already going with a "magical" supernova that threatens multiple star systems. I know it's not strictly canon per se unless it's stated in the show, but it still follows the current writers' story that they have in their heads.

True, but the world could be quite close to the supernova and still be affected. A supernova within some 30 light years would still produce lethal Gamma rays, necessitating an evacuation. My point wasn’t that only Romulus would be affected, but that the Empire should be large enough to contain many worlds completely unaffected.
 
Not saying it would 'easy'. But I'm certain they would at the very least be able to transport a million people that is outside the danger zone but still within their space. Heck you probably only need ONE planet for that.

Let's says things were flip flopped and the supernova was happening to Earth. I'm pretty sure star feet would be a be to save at least one million by transporting people to places like Vulcan or any of the countless federation worlds/colonys/starbases/moons etc

Presumably, that’s what they did. I really hope they don’t go the way of some kind of unbelievable galaxy-shattering space event that obliterates all the Romulans and only leaves a few refugees. That wasn’t believable for Vulcan in ST09, given how many Vulcans are surely living off world, and it would be even less believable here.
 
I'm certain this has been brought up before so apologiesj in advance. But has it been revealed why the Romulans cant save (evacuate) themselves? Or get help from other races other than Starfleet?

No idea, but this song would go good with the Romulans' situation.

To view this content we will need your consent to set third party cookies.
For more detailed information, see our cookies page.
 
Vancouver prefers that lets them stretch as an actor, but a paycheck is a paycheck.

Tampa, Florida often doubles as other cities in TV and films (it's doubled for Chicago and several Midwestern cities).

A rather sad commentary on Tampa, if you ask me; the city is so lacking an identity, it's interchangeable with other cities. (No one would expect New York to double for Boston.)

(Just so you know, I live just across the Bay from Tampa.)
 
Anyone got an alternate link for this that's not region-blocked in the US?

Amazing they took it down/geoblocked it. It was working fine yesterday. Frankly, I’m shocked they gave this clip to Graham Norton. It’s perhaps the most anticipated scene from the whole show among TNG fans. Perhaps they didn’t think very many would be watching. In any case, I couldn’t find a duplicate anywhere on a quick search, but I’d guess one will show up soon. Not long to go now, though. :)
 
Amazing they took it down/geoblocked it. It was working fine yesterday. Frankly, I’m shocked they gave this clip to Graham Norton. It’s perhaps the most anticipated scene from the whole show among TNG fans. Perhaps they didn’t think very many would be watching. In any case, I couldn’t find a duplicate anywhere on a quick search, but I’d guess one will show up soon. Not long to go now, though. :)
It wasn't put out by the BBC, that's why it got pulled.
I was surprised it lasted as long as it did, they only post clips, never the whole show.
(if you find a complete show on Yt it's from some other source and usually several years old)
I watched the entire thing myself though.
(didn't think to DL it) :brickwall:
 
Last edited:
It wouldn't be the first time the AQ had to deal with a refuge situation. The Bajorans were sort of in the same boat for awhile as well. Of course if they do lock Romulans up will they dare explore the idea of Romulan Joker being created?


Jason
 
For those that have already seen the first (3) episode(s): would you suggest any episodes that should be added to the pre-Picard watch lists? Based on the comments I've read here and elsewhere, I have added "The measure of a man", "The offspring" and "Inheritance" to mine. Any more suggestions based on having seen the actual episodes?
 
For those that have already seen the first (3) episode(s): would you suggest any episodes that should be added to the pre-Picard watch lists? Based on the comments I've read here and elsewhere, I have added "The measure of a man", "The offspring" and "Inheritance" to mine. Any more suggestions based on having seen the actual episodes?

Don't forget 'Nemesis' because of its Romulus/Shinzon plot and the Data/Picard relationship.

Plus 'First Contact' due to the connection between Picard, Data, and the Borg Queen that might come handy later when we try to figure out Dahj's origins. BOBW was the Borg's invasion story and how Picard turned into Locutus that I think is also important, but 'First Contact' is also another pivotal event that might be important in the 'Picard' series later.
 
Last edited:
If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

Sign up / Register


Back
Top