• Welcome! The TrekBBS is the number one place to chat about Star Trek with like-minded fans.
    If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

Spoilers Picard Prequel "Children of Mars"

Human, yes. But not from Earth. Mars has been inhabited for long enough that most humans living there would surely be Martian-born.

Yes, but my point stands. Saying that "First Contact Day" would be considered a "local" holiday only to Earth folks and not their Martian cousins is absurd.
 
Since First Contact inevitably led to the founding of the Federation, I suspect it's celebrated on multiple worlds.

Do they also celebrate first contact between the Vulcans and the Andorians then? Or the Vulcans and the Tellarites? You can't have the Federation without all four after all.
 
"Commemoration" might be the better word for whatever anniversaries of first contact the Vulcans, Andorians and Tellarites share between themselves. Certainly from the Vulcan side of two of those three interspecies relationships...?
 
Do they also celebrate first contact between the Vulcans and the Andorians then? Or the Vulcans and the Tellarites? You can't have the Federation without all four after all.

At least in non-canon Trek literature, the Human-Vulcan first contact is seen as the pivotal moment of local galactic history. Vulcans had made first contact with other species before, but contact with Humanity transformed their society. Ambassador Solkar said outright that the Vulcans recognised themselves in Humans.

Books like "Federation: The First 150 Years", and "Picard: Autobiography" also stress the significance of the event.

It is not about Alien Species A meeting Alien Species B, it's about two disparate cultures meeting, finding they're two sides of a different coin, and then building an unprecedented interstellar union of species. While in the distant past other such unions were formed (Star Trek: DTI book series), in canon nothing before and nothing after has coalesced into a federation like that.
 
At least in non-canon Trek literature, the Human-Vulcan first contact is seen as the pivotal moment of local galactic history. Vulcans had made first contact with other species before, but contact with Humanity transformed their society. Ambassador Solkar said outright that the Vulcans recognised themselves in Humans.

Books like "Federation: The First 150 Years", and "Picard: Autobiography" also stress the significance of the event.

It is not about Alien Species A meeting Alien Species B, it's about two disparate cultures meeting, finding they're two sides of a different coin, and then building an unprecedented interstellar union of species. While in the distant past other such unions were formed (Star Trek: DTI book series), in canon nothing before and nothing after has coalesced into a federation like that.

I dunno man. I guess I could see the Vulcans celebrating First Contact Day. But I see no particular reason why Andorians, Tellarites, or any of the other Federation races would. Federation Day seems good enough.
 
I dunno man. I guess I could see the Vulcans celebrating First Contact Day. But I see no particular reason why Andorians, Tellarites, or any of the other Federation races would. Federation Day seems good enough.

I think if you're on Earth, or in Sol System, you're probably celebrating First Contact Day. It's like if you live abroad, or are on a holiday abroad, you'll often celebrate whatever the national holiday/event is even if it has little significance to you yourself. You're buying into the culture.
 
I think if you're on Earth, or in Sol System, you're probably celebrating First Contact Day. It's like if you live abroad, or are on a holiday abroad, you'll often celebrate whatever the national holiday/event is even if it has little significance to you yourself. You're buying into the culture.

Yeah, this is my headcanon.

I mean, the Federation is already way too human-centric based upon what is depicted onscreen (largely for budgetary reasons). No reason to make it even more "everyone is equal, but humans are the most important race in the quadrant."
 
Perhaps I'm a little sexists, but I always thought that two girls who fought inside a school would just push each other and pull their hair. They punched each other in the face. Perhaps they do boxing as an extracurricular activity?
That is indeed a bit sexist.
 
Not even remotely the same. The first contact in question was humanity's first contact with the aliens. Martians are (mostly) humans and that event is just as much part of their history as it is of Earthlings'.
Lil is from EARTH and so is her Dad.

Even if nobody else at the shipyards celebrates Fist Contact Day, these two do and it obviously upset Lil that her dad couldn't be around in this particular year for the festivities.

And that is the most important aspect to the story being told.
:cool:
 
If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

Sign up / Register


Back
Top