• Welcome! The TrekBBS is the number one place to chat about Star Trek with like-minded fans.
    If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

Anyone going to see the Downton film?

Oh, one final point. Everyone goes on about how great Maggie Smith is, and she is don't get me wrong, but I don't think she'd be quite as effective without having Penelope Wilton to bounce off. #nonfanopinion :)
You're absolutely right about that. Violet and Isobel are great together, and if you go back and watch the show you'll see how that develops — they're constantly sparring, but also become very good friends.
 
You're absolutely right about that. Violet and Isobel are great together, and if you go back and watch the show you'll see how that develops — they're constantly sparring, but also become very good friends.

At one point I whispered to my girlfriend "They like each really though, right?"
 
Am I the only one who is pissed that it looks like Edith has given up her magazine?
And with how Bertie reacted to the news of her pregnancy? the line about secrets says to me he’s not over Marigold, guess Edith is not allowed to be too happy.
 
Am I the only one who is pissed that it looks like Edith has given up her magazine?
And with how Bertie reacted to the news of her pregnancy? the line about secrets says to me he’s not over Marigold, guess Edith is not allowed to be too happy.
I was disappointed that they didn't even give the magazine a name-drop when Edith was complaining to Cora about all the stuff she has to do... not one word about balancing it with running a successful magazine?

As to the latter, I didn't really notice, but I'll pay more attention when I rewatch the movie when it's out on Blu-ray.
 
Despite my best intentions (a week long hospitalization will do that), I finally got to see the Downton movie today.

It's piffle. Enjoyable, charming piffle. Very pretty piffle. Piffle with a budget. But piffle. And I mean that in the best possible way.

It was exactly what I expected from the film. Two hours with these characters, doing the things that I knew from watching the series for six years these characters would do, is no bad thing. The tone meanders exactly as the tone of the series itself meandered. The moments that were meant to be funny were amusing, the moments that were mawkishly sentimental were moving. If there's anything to complain about, it's that the characters seem as though they were frozen in amber since last we saw them, and some actors have so little screen time you wonder what was the point in having them appear at all except that they were around at the end of the series (thinking of Bates, Baxter, and Talbot here).

It all works. It's not really a film, more like an extended episode of the series with a higher budget and more leisurely filming schedule, yet all it really needs to be is a fine time with these characters, and that it does. The plot, such as it is, is wholly incidental to letting the characters welcome us back into their world. It's piffle, the nicest sort of piffle, and that's all anyone needs from Downton Abbey.
 
It's piffle.
I think Mrs Relayer and I decided it was 'tosh'. A little harsh I feel in retrospect. Piffle it is !

We went to an especially cheap midweek afternoon showing at a small and already cheap local cinema. Because I'm, well...cheap !

Having sat through the entirety of the TV show (but never forgiving it for pinching the actor who played my favourite character in the superior Lark Rise To Candleford) while Mrs R watched it, it was the least I could do.
 
It's piffle. Enjoyable, charming piffle. Very pretty piffle. Piffle with a budget. But piffle. And I mean that in the best possible way.

It all works. It's not really a film, more like an extended episode of the series with a higher budget and more leisurely filming schedule, yet all it really needs to be is a fine time with these characters, and that it does.
It's kind of like Star Trek: Insurrection in that regard — a story that isn't terribly consequential, but it's kind of a fun, light-hearted romp with favorite characters that feels like a big-budget two-parter. ;)
 
It's kind of like Star Trek: Insurrection in that regard — a story that isn't terribly consequential, but it's kind of a fun, light-hearted romp with favorite characters that feels like a big-budget two-parter. ;)
Which is precisely why I'll defend Insurrection until my dying breath.
 
Last edited:
Just want to chime in on this, I liked Insurrection too, its not my favourite Next Gen film, but in many ways it's the most Next Gen, Next Gen film!
 
For anyone REALLY into Downton, Fellowes new American set show The Guilded Age might (he's denying it at the moment) serve as a backdoor prequel with one or two of the older Downton characters putting in appearances as much younger versions.
 
I would hope Gilded Age is allowed to stand on its own; to have it be the story of the Levinsons (Cora's family) would be awfully small-world, though it's definitely the right time frame. Maybe her father was one of the so-called robber-barons.
 
If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

Sign up / Register


Back
Top