• Welcome! The TrekBBS is the number one place to chat about Star Trek with like-minded fans.
    If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

Mandela Effect

Everybody thinking Kirk said "Beam me up, Scotty" is an example of the Mandela Effect.

Kor
 
There was a terrorist attack in New York that broke the Statue of Liberty, why do we never talk about that? Why is 9/11 thought of as the 1st attack on US soil if there something that severe?

4 deaths vs. 3000 deaths might have something to do with it...
 
The Mandela Effect is just a bunch of people who have trouble remembering things correctly.
JIf and Skippy peanut butter for example. People claim that there was Jiffy peanut butter, but they get the 2 mixed up.
Berenstain Bears is another one. A lot of people claim it was Berenstein Bears.
A lot of people thought Nelson Mandela died a long time ago. There are a bunch of other ones too. It proves that people have crappy memories.

Yes that's why we have schedules, plannings, and post-its... etc

and more generally why we put things in writing.
 
I have read about the Mandela Effect and similar phenomenons before and i think in most cases it's simply false memories or something like that.

But sometimes i wonder, because something like that also happened to me during the early nineties, christmas 1991 to be exact. I remember watching the LOTR animated movie, which was broadcasted on television at that time. The dubbing was different to the one that was on tape, which i bought in 2001 when Peter Jackson's trilogy started. For example the names of the characters were the original english ones instead of the ones used in the german translation of the book (E.g. Frodo Baggins instead of Frodo Beutlin) which was used for the version on tape, Gandalf was dubbed by the same voice actor that was later used for Richard Attenborough in Jurassic Park and the name Smeagol was pronounced different than in the known version (Smeeegol instead of Smeagol).

When i watched the movie on tape i was really surprised at all the differences. First i thought they simply used another dub but i never found anything about another version on the Internet. Apparently the one on tape is the only one that was ever released in Germany.

What makes me wondering the most is the thing with the voice actor. I didn't heard him before and when i saw John Hammond in Jurassic Park for the first time, all i thought is "This guy has the same voice as Gandalf" :-)

I hadn't read the books and didn't knew anything about LOTR when i saw the movie in 1991. Actually seeing it started my interest in reading Tolkien's works and made me a fan.


Since the other Mandela Effect thread got moved to this forum, I'm going to merge this one into that one.
 
There was a terrorist attack in New York that broke the Statue of Liberty, why do we never talk about that? Why is 9/11 thought of as the 1st attack on US soil if there something that severe?
Yeah it’s probably just something like that, just seems strange that it’s never mentioned. You know hoe precious they are about the SoL lol. Plus why refer to 9/11 as the first attack on American soil?
Probably the same reason why some people are completely unaware that the World Trade Center was bombed by international terrorists intending to knock the towers down only eight and a half years before 9/11.:shrug:
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/1993_World_Trade_Center_bombing
 
I love parallel universes and alternate history, but I think the Mandela Effect is a load of hogwash.
 
There was a bit in The Writer's Tale, the interview book on Russell T Davies, where he told the story about how in pre-production of his mini-series The Second Coming, everybody who'd read the script seemed to remember the eyes of the demonic people described as "glowing red". Davies had in fact only written the eyes as "glowing".

While it's fun pondering about alternate universes and timelines, the more likely explanation is that people just tend to conflate memories. If demonic eyes glow, then they must glow red, since demons are red. Mandela was a martyr to his cause, martyrs die for their cause, so obviously Mandela had to have died for his cause.

So, yeah, most likely, the Mandela Effect is more about psychology and neurology than about astrophysics.
 
Well, there's the classic fisherman story whose fish gets bigger each time he tells the story. He doesn't do it (totally) on purpose, it's just that there is a mechanism that gets triggered each time we tell a white lie that makes us believe that lie. Of course, it's not systematic and it takes many stories for the fish to get significantly bigger. Each time the fisherman is convinced of only slightly exaggerating reality which he finds is honest telling. But in the end the fish doubles and then triples in size. That's how impossible legends get started.
 
I have a theory. An event can split two ways, and create parallel universes. By the same token, and for random reasons, parallel universes, if the are close enough together in some significantr way, merge together. And some of us were on alt.uni.A and some on alt.uni.B, and remember events that were true for us on one but not the other.

Or something.
 
I have a theory. An event can split two ways, and create parallel universes. By the same token, and for random reasons, parallel universes, if the are close enough together in some significantr way, merge together. And some of us were on alt.uni.A and some on alt.uni.B, and remember events that were true for us on one but not the other.

Or something.

Or... humans just have terrible memories. :p
 
If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

Sign up / Register


Back
Top