Sure, rain on our hopes and dreams with your reality nonsense!
Agents of SHIELD: Season 6
- Thread starter OCD Geek
- Start date
EW.com has posted their post finale interview with the showrunners.
I was just thinking, why didn't they just go back in time and grab a Coulson from earlier in the timeline? They have a time machine, so couldn't they have just grabbed him, and then once they were done, dropped him back off?
I was just thinking, why didn't they just go back in time and grab a Coulson from earlier in the timeline? They have a time machine, so couldn't they have just grabbed him, and then once they were done, dropped him back off?
They (ABC) are not going to bring back Peggy as the lead character. They cancelled her show for whatever reason (ratings). They wouldn't redo the same (in their minds) mistake.
I thought they DID take a past Coulson and relay to him everything he missed. And enhanced him making him "like an LMD", but still Coulson. Did I misunderstand that?
They created a LMD/Chronicom Coulson with the brain scan data from the Framework arc, which they then updated with the events that took place in the meantime.
Last edited:
Avengers: Endgame made it very clear that nothing is "erased" by time travel, that the model of time travel used in Back to the Future and a million other movies is total nonsense. We saw again and again in the movie that going back and changing events did not alter your own timeline's past, but just created a separate branch where things happened differently. So that question has already been answered.
In real-world terms, Endgame was written by the creators/producers of Agent Carter, and they actually included AC's Jarvis in the movie. So I doubt very much that they intended A:E to contradict AC in any way.
But why then did we not see Rogers on the show? Did he go back after the show ended? Jason
I don't know, is II the other LMD AIDA made or the puppeted clone we just saw atomized?
We'll call him "Trip".
The Agent Carter TV series occurred in 1946 and 1947. Steve Rogers appears in 1948. KISS.
Weird stuff: Black Widow is pushing Sharon Carter / Agent 13 onto Steve Rogers; "She's nice." Is Sharon Carter the daughter of the son of Peggy Carter (not married), or maybe the granddaughter of Peggy's brother? Could she be the granddaughter of Steve Rogers, himself? Probably not. If the granddaughter of Peggy's brother, then it would make her zero blood relationship to Steve, but he would still be her granduncle by marriage assuming he marries Peggy. Still weird.
Weird stuff: Black Widow is pushing Sharon Carter / Agent 13 onto Steve Rogers; "She's nice." Is Sharon Carter the daughter of the son of Peggy Carter (not married), or maybe the granddaughter of Peggy's brother? Could she be the granddaughter of Steve Rogers, himself? Probably not. If the granddaughter of Peggy's brother, then it would make her zero blood relationship to Steve, but he would still be her granduncle by marriage assuming he marries Peggy. Still weird.
For Agents of Shield:
They are in 1931 New York City. Too early for any Peggy Carter or Howard Stark (both about 12 years old plus Peggy is in England.) They are there for what reason? I can't think of any comic book reason, so, it might be a new story creation.
Last edited:
Or rather, it was in the main timeline and the past where Steve married Peggy was the alternate one. The film's writers and directors have disagreed on whether Steve went back to the original past or an alternate past, but the latter interpretation is hugely problematical, so I prefer to think it was an alternate timeline as the directors say it was, and that Agent Carter took place in the main MCU.
Although as Henoch points out, Agent Carter is safe in either interpretation, because Steve came back no earlier than 1948 according to the writers.
According to Captain America: Civil War, Peggy was Sharon's aunt, or more likely her great-aunt as the Marvel Wiki says.
Spoiler policy is six months. Endgame came out a little over three months ago. Thanks all.
A. He took retirement. B. He was involved, but under a different name with a new secret identity. Probably spent in deep cover fighting the commies or the reds. Based on his age and super soldier formula, he could make it effectively up to the late 70's. By then, new superheroes took over like Hank Pym's Ant-Man.
Last edited:
Spoiler tags for Endgame people.
No, you're not getting it at all
Past Cap was the one living in an alternate timeline.
Endgame and Agent Carter are in the same timeline we've been seeing since the movies started. The main timeline wasn't altered
Endgame and Agent Carter are in the same timeline we've been seeing since the movies started. The main timeline wasn't altered
Similar threads
