• Welcome! The TrekBBS is the number one place to chat about Star Trek with like-minded fans.
    If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

Spoilers General Disco Chat Thread

If the thread title isn't labeled then you should use spoiler tags (Or at least be super vague.) It just seems weird since most of the threads in this forum do have spoiler tags where all bets are off.
 
Have any energy weapons, other than Georgiou’s drone thing been fired so far in season 2? I don’t believe any have.

The most action we’ve see have been melee weapons.

Season 1 had weapons fire in nearly every episode.
There was Pike's phaser in New Eden. Otherwise I don't remember any. This season has been unusually pacifistic for Star Trek.
 
We're supposed to put up spoiler warnings for the first month a new episode is out. So, technically, it's against board rules to talk about details from any of S2 yet without a spoiler warning. And since this particular thread has no spoiler warning in it up-top, we have to do the Special Spoiler Code in our posts.

Trust me, I found this out the hard way last year. I posted something about DSC in GTD, while the second half of the first season was airing, only to find a mod edit that part into a spoiler bracket. I'd have done the same if I were them but, you know, it had been a while since we had a new Star Trek series, much less one I was interested in, so I didn't even think about that.

2 weeks it says

Spoilers
Generally, buyer beware in this forum if you want to be completely unspoiled. We will try to protect major developments, but if knowing basic details, character names or minutiae will spoil your enjoyment, watch the show before coming into the forum!
If you are posting specific spoilers from episodes, particularly about plot developments, please use spoiler tags and warnings for at least 2 weeks from the date of US release to give people a chance to catch up.
 
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21 (doesn't let you do more than 20 nested spoilers it looks like)
22
23
 
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21 (doesn't let you do more than 20 nested spoilers it looks like)
22
23
Spamming. Comments to PM.
So what, you were told to stop the other behavior, so you're switching up your tactics?
 
Last edited:
There's an interview of Marina Sirtis on AV Club this week. Here's what she has to say about Discovery:

AVC: Have you watched Discovery at all?

MS: I have to, because Jason Isaacs is a friend. [Laughs] It’s compulsory viewing for me. I like it! I love the fact you see how far we’ve moved on from my show. We have the women in such important roles now. I think what they’re doing and what they’re trying to do and kind of succeeding—you know, you have to be honest. Look back at the first season of TNG; how many episodes did we hold our nose? We held our noses and went, “Oh my god, I can’t believe this is on the air, it’s so bad.” They haven’t had that, it’s not bad. They’re starting off way more advanced than we started off.

But I do like the fact that they are trying to maintain what the germ was of Star Trek, what the initial philosophy of Gene Roddenberry was. I think that got lost a bit in some of the incarnations, especially DS9. Listen, there are people who will punch me in the face if I say a bad thing about DS9, but it kind of lost… Star Trek was about space exploration. It was about going out into the universes, about going out and human discovery. It wasn’t about a hotel in space that people came to. So I think that’s where they got it slightly wrong on DS9. But Voyager and Enterprise, they tried to maintain Gene’s philosophy. I think they’re doing it on Discovery, too. I don’t know how they’re doing, numbers-wise, because I don’t know, because they’re a streaming thing, if they can figure that out. But it says a lot about the Star Trek franchise that CBS launches a streaming service with it.
 
What do you mean pacifistic? The first seeming threat encountered, Pike wants to blow it up,
I meant that they haven't actually shot at anything (or been shot at). My phrasing was clumsy. Obviously they aren't actually pacifists.
 
I meant that they haven't actually shot at anything (or been shot at). My phrasing was clumsy. Obviously they aren't actually pacifists.

Well, they haven't encountered anything that has been actively trying to kill them, or were actively at war. Or even stuck on a planet that was really really cold and had to shoot some rocks. I agree, though, that this season has had a much more meditative start than last year. But that was to be expected given the more existential nature of the kind of antagonist the ship is facing than they had last year.
 
Last edited:
There's an interview of Marina Sirtis on AV Club this week. Here's what she has to say about Discovery:

AVC: Have you watched Discovery at all?

MS: I have to, because Jason Isaacs is a friend. [Laughs] It’s compulsory viewing for me. I like it! I love the fact you see how far we’ve moved on from my show. We have the women in such important roles now. I think what they’re doing and what they’re trying to do and kind of succeeding—you know, you have to be honest. Look back at the first season of TNG; how many episodes did we hold our nose? We held our noses and went, “Oh my god, I can’t believe this is on the air, it’s so bad.” They haven’t had that, it’s not bad. They’re starting off way more advanced than we started off.

But I do like the fact that they are trying to maintain what the germ was of Star Trek, what the initial philosophy of Gene Roddenberry was. I think that got lost a bit in some of the incarnations, especially DS9. Listen, there are people who will punch me in the face if I say a bad thing about DS9, but it kind of lost… Star Trek was about space exploration. It was about going out into the universes, about going out and human discovery. It wasn’t about a hotel in space that people came to. So I think that’s where they got it slightly wrong on DS9. But Voyager and Enterprise, they tried to maintain Gene’s philosophy. I think they’re doing it on Discovery, too. I don’t know how they’re doing, numbers-wise, because I don’t know, because they’re a streaming thing, if they can figure that out. But it says a lot about the Star Trek franchise that CBS launches a streaming service with it.
The cruise director of The Love Boat in Space compares Deep Space 9 to a hotel?
 
From what I understand it was either Denise or Marina who was getting the chop, so I think she's probably thankful Denise chose to leave.
 
If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

Sign up / Register


Back
Top