• Welcome! The TrekBBS is the number one place to chat about Star Trek with like-minded fans.
    If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

Spoilers Star Trek: Discovery 2x03 - "Point of Light"

Hit it!


  • Total voters
    240
Kenneth Mitchell seems to have the most fun beneath all that Klingon makeup. Him being a complete dick was the highlight of the Klingon storyline last season. I hope they continue to bring him back, Jeffrey Combs style.

Overall, I'd give the episode a 7. All of the individual plotlines worked for me, but I was waiting for something cohesive to tie them all together. Perhaps on a rewatch I'll revise this up a point, as I have for the last two episodes.
 
My feeling was that it was Kirk who had the obsessions and it was Spock, along with McCoy, who helped the captain climb down from his obsessions. I never visioned Spock as the obsessive type.

Spock, T’Pring and pon farr. Or do you think every Vulcan handles matters in such a pent up manner? Spock stealing a starship to help Pike. Spock refusing to go off duty to have surgery to help his father. Spock deciding to purge all emotion through Kolinahr.
 
Last edited:
Eh, not with that Skin colour.

Maybe he’ll be the Albino from DS9 :lol:

I have greatly enjoyed the season so far--I gave tonight's episode an 8, more because it feels like a bridge to several major storylines.

Anyone else think the son of L'Rell and Voq is the Albino?

This was my initial thought as well. Pretty certain it will be the case.
 
I gave it a 7, just like last week.

Not a big fan of Klingons and the whole Spock thing, but it was executed well.

Love Tilly!
 
I give it an 8.

Probably the first episode of Star Trek where I have been interested in Klingon politics.

Likes:

- All the Klingon stuff. Great to see Kenneth Mitchell back as Kol's father and glad to see some genuine brutality in the Klingon fight scene. It was great to see blood being spurted when characters for hit with bat'leth's instead of them keeling over like they had just been poked by a broom handle.

- The revelation of the D7 as a symbol of unified Klingon Empire, implying that each house was designing their own ships or possibly getting them from elsewhere. Great way to explain the differences in Klingon ship design during season one.

- Amanda confessing that she hid her emotions from Spock because she wasn't allowed to show him emotion. Sarek really was a jerk.

- Burnham describing Spock as her 'Little Shadow' (which shows he came around to her after the initial rejection) and her confession that what she did to Spock was to save him from the logic extremists.

- Performances of Mary Chieffo, Shazad Latif, Mary Wiseman.

- What the fuck is that thing they pulled out of Tilly. I love when Trek gives us creepy alien monsters.

Dislikes:

- The Tilly plot, seriously felt like it needed an episode of it's own to do it justice. What Tilly was going through felt glossed over.

- Not 100% sold on Section 31. On a positive, their involvement didn't feel as tacked on as I was expecting.

All things considered, a strong episode that i feel was all about laying ground work for the season ahead.
 
Last edited:
Do we know where Michael's arrival into Sarek' s family is in the timeline in relation to Yesteryear?

Spock was seven when he did the Kahswan. Michael is approximately five years older. The child actress who plays Michael looks around 12 or 13 to me, but she’s probably supposed to be playing younger. It’s also never been really clear to me how a Vulcan child develops in comparison to a human. Given that they live longer, their physical development is probably slower and the age given could be in Vulcan years, not human. . Spock could be older than seven by human standards at the time of the Kahswan. I would say Michael was already living with the family in Yesteryear and is not seen on screen. Maybe she is away at the Vulcan Science Academy boarding school.

I’ve never particularly liked the Klingons. The Klingons on Discovery are tedious in the extreme. I do think they look better with hair.
 
Let's take one example, supported by dialog.

In delivering Pike to Talos IV, Spock worked with the Talosians.

KEEPER [on screen]: What you now seem to hear, Captain Kirk, are my thought transmissions. The Commodore was never aboard your vessel. His presence there and in the shuttlecraft was an illusion. Mister Spock had related to us your strength of will. It was thought the fiction of a court-martial would divert you from too soon regaining control of your vessel. Captain Pike is welcome to spend the rest of his life with us, unfettered by his physical body. The decision is yours and his.
KIRK: Mister Spock, even if regulations are explicit, you could have come to me and explained.
SPOCK: Ask you to face the death penalty, too? One of us was enough, Captain.

This is not obsessive behavior. This is a friend helping his former commander, who he regarded as a friend, and protecting his present commander, who too he regarded as a friend.
 
Giving something a high score then saying it isn’t very good is having two opinions at the same time. Unless these reviews were written by the horde, then they should be ignored...

Ummm.. those rating the episode highly aren't also saying it wasn't very good. There are those who disliked the episode and those who liked it. The greater majority of those on this site liked the episode as evidenced by the poll.

I think your cognitive dissonance is hurting you since your world view is being challenged by facts.
 
Let's take one example, supported by dialog.

In delivering Pike to Talos IV, Spock worked with the Talosians.

KEEPER [on screen]: What you now seem to hear, Captain Kirk, are my thought transmissions. The Commodore was never aboard your vessel. His presence there and in the shuttlecraft was an illusion. Mister Spock had related to us your strength of will. It was thought the fiction of a court-martial would divert you from too soon regaining control of your vessel. Captain Pike is welcome to spend the rest of his life with us, unfettered by his physical body. The decision is yours and his.
KIRK: Mister Spock, even if regulations are explicit, you could have come to me and explained.
SPOCK: Ask you to face the death penalty, too? One of us was enough, Captain.

This is not obsessive behavior. This is a friend helping his former commander, who he regarded as a friend, and protecting his present commander, who too he regarded as a friend.

I’d say it is both. Spock acted emotionally and recklessly, though within the framework of logic. As seen on the series, Vulcans can usually find a logical reason for whatever it is they want to do, and deny that emotion has anything to do with the decision. It isn’t only that he is a hybrid but that he is the son of Sarek and Amanda and had the upbringing he did.
 
People can like DIS if they want but this thread is full of people giving the episode a high score then moaning how it wasn’t a very good episode. That is silly. Either it was good or it wasn’t. Just because DIS is the only “Star Trek” on tv, it doesn’t mean you have to force yourself to like it, bigging up mediocrity...


I gave it a 10 and I have been known to be critical of some aspects of the show. I just felt the episode was well written and well acted. The action scene was top notch which can be rare in Trek. Any episode than can make me emotionally feel something usually gets a high grade. Maybe as time moves on my grade will go down some in repeat viewings but in the here and now I felt it was worth a 10.

Jason
 
8/10, really good episode.

I don't want to harp on about it but the visual redesign of the klingons was a negative in this episode because L'rell played such a massive part but it's harder for her to emote, and in the fight scenes the klingons were sort of clunky when moving, you never saw michael dorn have those issues, smooth as butter because he didn't have to contend with all that makeup and prosthetics
 
Kenneth Mitchell seems to have the most fun beneath all that Klingon makeup. Him being a complete dick was the highlight of the Klingon storyline last season. I hope they continue to bring him back, Jeffrey Combs style.
Yeah, I can imagine him eventually playing Kor as well. Unfortunately, they didn't have the Free Waterfall Jr. thing going on, introducing the next member of the family to avenge the death of the previous one.
 
I gave it an 8, I only took off points for the boring boring boring Klingon hand-to-hand fight scene. I was watching, and thought “could this BE any more boring?” And then it kicked into slo-mo. So the answer is yes, it could be more boring.
 
Not sure why people are doubting a Section 31 with Georgiou show. I mean they basically built a fancy new set for the show which you can see in this episode. That tells me it's already a done deal. The Section 31 ship was way to fancy to just be some random spaceship of the week.


Jason
 
Well, that was quite a shakeup! (In a good way.)

Working on some thoughts about what might have happened between Michael and Spock, but I have to sleep on it before I can put them all together. For now, just a few quick replies to others...

Maybe he’ll be the Albino from DS9 :lol:
Anyone else think the son of L'Rell and Voq is the Albino?
Anyone else think tht Child is the Albino from Ds9?
I thought about that too, as a possibility. Personally, I never really felt that the Albino was meant to be a Klingon in "Blood Oath" (DS9)—nobody says he is there, and in the script he's only identified as a humanoid—but I know that some licensed non-canon sources have said he was, and there's nothing in the episode to say he isn't.

I have a feeling that we haven't seen the last of baby Voq. Although I don't buy into the Albino theories, it would put an interesting twist on the Albino's vendetta against certain Klingon houses-- including Kor.
And it would also tie in with the "take his revenge on the firstborn" angle. I'm not entirely convinced of it, either, but it's most intriguing.

I thought Klingon blood was purple?
Only in ST6. It’s red in the TV shows.
It seems to me for DSC they've gone with something in between, which appears more toward one or the other depending on the light. I've noticed it from the beginning, when Burnham slew Rejac, and thought it was quite clever:

"The Vulcan Hello" (DSC):
discovery1x01-1005.jpg


"Battle At The Binary Stars" (DSC):
discovery1x02-1998.jpg


"Point Of Light" (DSC):
Point-Of-Light-Blood1.png

Point-Of-Light-Blood2.png

Point-Of-Light-Blood3.png

Point-Of-Light-Blood4.png


L'Rell = terrible. They referenced the male Rape stuff from season one, but even consensual relations with L'Rell should be considered male rape. What a horrid beast.
Not gonna lie...I'm into her, and have been all along. I've had a bit of a thing for female Klingons since watching TNG in childhood (major crush on K'Ehleyr), and she's no exception. She's always reminded me of Mara from "Day Of The Dove" (TOS), somehow.

(Also, "male rape"? Isn't it just rape? You know what, nevermind, don't bother answering that...sorry I asked.)

Hang on? Wasn't the Vulcan High Command dissolved? What's Amanda bringing it up for?
Vulcan High Command was first mentioned in one of 24th century series, so I guess it was reformed at some point
T'Pau said it would be "dissolved" after the conclusion of "Kir'Shara" (ENT), and T'Pol confirmed that it had been "disbanded" in "United" (ENT), which left many Vulcan ships without full crew complements. But who knows what happened after that? It may have been reconstituted to meet the looming Romulan threat. (I wonder if this could have anything to do with her refusal of a seat on the Federation Council, per "Amok Time" [TOS]?)

The episode where it was first mentioned was "Infinite Regress" (VGR). Seven of Nine manifested the personality of a Subaltern Lorot of the Vulcan High Command, who had been assimilated by the Borg. (No mention was made of when or where, but an assumption that it was sometime in the 24th century is what originally led to the theory of it being restored at some point after ENT. They probably picked that up from Memory Alpha.)

Now, they are adding a loony-bin artificial intelligence program, created within the Federation and antagonistic to the values of the Federation, into the canon Star Trek. :censored:

(Info on CONTROL: Control_(program))
Well, thanks for posting that link, because I had no idea what other posters were referring to before you did! (I've never read any Trek novels other than Roddenberry's adaptation of TMP, myself.) As someone else said, if there is in fact a connection there, I wonder if there might also be any link to Zora from the "Calypso" short?

I liked when L’Rell was talking to the council in Klingon, but what we heard changed to English. Very Hunt for Red October-esque.
Yep. That's the way they did it in TUC as well. Always liked that sort of transition. And as others have said, I got a kick out of how at the moment they switched, the subtitles briefly went to Klingon! (Also, L'Rell doing the "previously on..." in Klingonese, too.)

I skipped DS9 all together.
You missed out big time. For my money, DS9 is the only previous Trek show that just kept getting better and better through its entire run. (That's right folks, while I recognize it's a contrary opinion to many, I think ENT's first season was its best. I find it quite underrated, and the third and fourth rather overrated by comparison. Sorry.)

The planet the baby Voq was sent to, isn't that the same planet Worf went to and met the Kahless clone?
Yes.

If so was baby Voq one of the Klingons worf met?
I don't remember any albinos in "Righful Heir" (TNG), but he was there a while, and it's not as if we saw everyone he met.

Also may be why the episode is called "Point of Light".
Yes, surely.

Oh, absolutely. That family is probably the most messed up one in Trek, and Sarek seems to be at the root of most of it.
Not to absolve him, as he surely made many mistakes, but ultimately I'd say toxic Vulcan culture is at the root of it. More on that tomorrow...

This was an apology episode from the writers. Klingon hair, communication with screens, and making their ships look like something familiar by showing us D7 which I'm pretty sure has been around before this, making the attitudes of the crew less dark. I liked star trek more when it was the writers that showed us the trek universe rather than the other way around. You can tell that they did a course correction in response to the fan reaction.
I kept getting distracted by watching them do canon-repair work during the episode. [...] They invested a lot of valuable precious minutes correcting their own inconsistencies.
Gee, it's almost like they're doing exactly as they said they would all along...

“The audience just has to be patient, because typically, if it seems like we’re violating canon, we know,” said Harberts. “We know that people might have knee-jerk reactions to things. But we have a plan.”

-Slate, 21 September 2017
O ye of little faith! First, you gripe about the "inconsistencies." Now, you gripe about the "course correction"! Since you obviously enjoy complaining so much, you should be happy they've given you so much to complain about!:p

And as for the one-off K't'inga in "Unexpected" (ENT), it was only a stand-in for a more primitive precursor (variously referred to behind the scenes as a D-4, D-5, or D-6), which had been designed by John Eaves and built as a CGI model by Koji Kuramura, but then was axed at the last minute because, and I shit you not, the producers decided they wanted more windows on it.:rolleyes:

-MMoM:D
 
Last edited:
If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

Sign up / Register


Back
Top