• Welcome! The TrekBBS is the number one place to chat about Star Trek with like-minded fans.
    If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

Spoilers Star Trek: Discovery 1x12 - "Vaulting Ambition"

Rate the episode...


  • Total voters
    269
Really thought this was a "gift" of a slave at first...... not dinner.
Mirror_Saru.jpg
 
This is Enterprise mission statement, the show is not about Enterprise

The motto is universal. Just change one word and it could work for Discovery too:
Space: the final frontier. These are the voyages of the starship Discovery. Its continuing mission: to explore strange new worlds, to seek out new life and new civilizations, to boldly go where no one has gone before.

Looks like you stick to much in the past and what you comfortable with.

Not really. I said I enjoy Discovery and I do. At the same time, I can still wish that parts of the show were different. There was a lot of good about Old Trek too. Not all of it needs to be rejected.
 
Ok I'm just going to keep on putting up theories and then I can say "told you so" if like 1 out of 100 sticks.

What if MU Lorca and Burnham come out victorious and return to the PU. Out of respect for Lorca Burnham hides his origin. And out of respect for Burnham Lorca lies and tells star fleet he has rescued Burnham from the MU and the person that mutinied was in fact her MU counterpart. Sets up next season Burnham back as commander and resolves that there then never was a star fleet mutiny.

psst....burhnam don't tell your brother it was really you the whole time.
 
I don't think Discovery's "characters" really qualify as such yet honestly.
Really! Imagine that!

To the extent it exists it has been widely inconsistent (things like Burnham first being written as a pesudo-Vulcan, and then having it dropped entirely).
Characters evolving beyond their initial origin stories to actually DEVELOP over time? Can't have that!
 
Ok I'm just going to keep on putting up theories and then I can say "told you so" if like 1 out of 100 sticks.

What if MU Lorca and Burnham come out victorious and return to the PU. Out of respect for Lorca Burnham hides his origin. And out of respect for Burnham Lorca lies and tells star fleet he has rescued Burnham from the MU and the person that mutinied was in fact her MU counterpart. Sets up next season Burnham back as commander and resolves that there then never was a star fleet mutiny. psst....burhnam don't tell your brother it was really you the whole time.

If MU Lorca wins, why would he give up being emperor of the Terran Empire just to be a random Starfleet captain in the PU?
 
Due to this, it would be anticlimactic to get back to Prime next week. There's basically no story left in this season, save for stalling tactics. There's absolutely nothing left for them to do but return to the prime universe, give the Federation the cloaking technology, and work out some sort of armistice - all of which can be dealt with in a few scenes. Thus, I expect that they'll continue to flounder around in the Mirrorverse now until the last episode.

We do have to find out what Captain Killy's been up to in the Prime Universe and clean up whatever mess she's made.

I'd guess we get one ep dealing with Lorca vs Georgieu, one dealing with Mirror Stamets and the damage he's caused to the mycelial network, and one cleaning up after Killy.
 
If MU Lorca wins, why would he give up being emperor of the Terran Empire just to be a random Starfleet captain in the PU?

What if he gets thrown back to PU with no manner which to return to MU

I think the spore drive jump back to PU will be its last!
 
Yup, it was so great when it happened, that one time.

I don't need episodes to be super long but they do often feel too short and last week was the only one I didn't think to myself "man that felt kinda short"

Broadcast tv shows are typically around 42 minutes.

The length of Discovery episodes have been: 42, 38, 47, 49, 47, 44, 47, 40, 47, 48, 49, and 37.

So 8 of the 12 episodes have been longer than what they would have to be to be on broadcast television, and 4 have been shorter.
 
I must have missed hearing it in DS9 and Discovery. They did have Zephram say it at the beginning of ENT so they did have it.

My point is that the idea of boldly exploring the unknown is not unique to a particular ship. There is nothing that says that only ships with the name Enterprise are allowed to have that motto. And that motto of exploration would certainly be very appropriate for a ship literally named Discovery.
 
Really! Imagine that!


Characters evolving beyond their initial origin stories to actually DEVELOP over time? Can't have that!

You're reading a lot more into the show than is actually there - at least yet.

Here's an exercise for you. For each of the six main cast members of the Discovery, tell me five things about them off the top of your head which don't relate to the plot.

You might be able to do it for one or two of them, but I'm guessing not all. The reason is very little has been done to establish the characters exist yet as anything separate from devices to move along the plot.
 
Space: the final frontier. These are the voyages of the starship Discovery. Its continuing mission: to explore strange new worlds, to seek out new life and new civilizations, to boldly go where no one has gone before.

Discovery is a mushroom science vessel, its only mission is aid in winning the war against the Klingons. Its not there to explore strange new worlds or seek out new life or any of the above.
 
Anyways, this Star trek is too à la LOST for me.

I'm thinking about MU Lorca:

First he said he can't stand bright light because of the buran accident. When he is tortured by L'rell, she said his eyes are damaged. We saw he cured his eyes to see the klingon ship destruction.

And now they say his eyes were never damaged, they are just made so?

He didn't cure his eye to see the destruction. He used that spray they've shown him use previously that temporarily help his eyes. But yeah, they weren't damaged - just a physiological difference between the PU and MU.
 
My point is that the idea of boldly exploring the unknown is not unique to a particular ship. There is nothing that says that only ships with the name Enterprise are allowed to have that motto. And that motto of exploration would certainly be very appropriate for a ship literally named Discovery.
Kind of hard to do exploration in the middle of a war. Defiant was not out there discovering much during the Dominion War.
 
Yeah, I too thought this at first, but both Stamets seemed very comfortable in their locations, so I don't think they actually switched. And if the other posters are correct in that they heard MU Stamets say "he did it", then that confirms it

I didn't take it as either being comfortable in their locations so much as disoriented and unaware of where they were.

I too heard the Stamets aboard the MU flagship mutter "I did it!" right after he awoke, but in the context of the scene this is immediately after Culber tells Prime!Stamets that all he has to do to return to his body is open his eyes. Cue close-up of MU!Stamets opening his eyes, saying "I did it!," and stumbling out of bed before the camera tracks sideways to hold on a Sickbay monitor showing the Terran Empire logo, center frame. If that's not cincimatic language for "oh shit Stamets is in the wrong body. Dun dun dun." I don't know what is.

The Stamets aboard Discovery expressing concern about the mycelial garden is harder to explain if hes really MU!Stamets, but I did notice he brushed off Tilly informing him of Culber's death by saying "I know" in a dismissive tone. It's hard to believe Prime!Stamets would so casually dismiss his feelings for his partner not thirty seconds after saying goodbye forever (as far as he knows.)
 
He didn't cure his eye to see the destruction. He used that spray they've shown him use previously that temporarily help his eyes. But yeah, they weren't damaged - just a physiological difference between the PU and MU.

Which is a cool trick, as light levels are extremely subjective: "there's an evil quality to the light here" can be poetic or physically accurate, but the audience can never tell those apart, because our eyes always adapt.

For all we know, ISS Enterprise in "Mirror, Mirror" was menacingly dark as well. Our eyes would simply be constitutionally incapable of telling.

Timo Saloniemi
 
Regarding Roman empire in MU, I thought it was established that MU history diverged when mirror Zefram Cochrane shot the Vulcan first contact dude.
No, the altered credit sequence shows the change goes back further.
To view this content we will need your consent to set third party cookies.
For more detailed information, see our cookies page.
 
Actually the MU Stamets woke up on the flagship and said "He did it!". The visualization (showing it fade from PU Stamets in quarters trying to open eyes to MU Stamets on bed opening eyes) made you think they switched places but what they said and how they acted appeared as though no switch occurred.
 
I too heard the Stamets aboard the MU flagship mutter "I did it!" right after he awoke, but in the context of the scene this is immediately after Culber tells Prime!Stamets that all he has to do to return to his body is open his eyes. Cue close-up of MU!Stamets opening his eyes, saying "I did it!," and stumbling out of bed before the camera tracks sideways to hold on a Sickbay monitor showing the Terran Empire logo, center frame. If that's not cincimatic language for "oh shit Stamets is in the wrong body. Dun dun dun." I don't know what is.

The Stamets in the lab clearly said "He did it" not "I did it." If you disagree, just go back and listen again.
 
He didn't cure his eye to see the destruction. He used that spray they've shown him use previously that temporarily help his eyes. But yeah, they weren't damaged - just a physiological difference between the PU and MU.
Have they shown any other Mirror Universe character to have light aversion when they crossed over?
 
If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

Sign up / Register


Back
Top