I think this show might actually be forking brilliant. It expertly creates a comedy out of philosophical and metaphysical questions. That takes some bloody good writing and this show pulls it off! The jokes really worked great in last night's episode.
Eleanor finding out that Michael was torturing Chidi with the trolley problem got me thinking. I think Michael's plea a couple episodes back to join their team was fake and all part of his new scheme to mess with them. Basically, Michael knows that trying to pretend it is the good place, will never work. Clearly after so many failed attempts, the gang will always discover the ruse no matter what. So he changed his strategy: admit that it is the good place, since they will discover it anyway, but pretend to be on their team and get them to "fake it" for Real Eleanor while torturing them in other ways, like making Chidi reenact the trolley problem over and over again.