• Welcome! The TrekBBS is the number one place to chat about Star Trek with like-minded fans.
    If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

Discovery at SDCC - Consolidated Thread

You know something.
giphy.gif
 
This is about the level of detail I've always assumed that captains had on those chair arms.

Why?

Because Kirk could jettison a manned instrument pod from his chair without giving an order.

So the controls were always pretty comprehensive.
 
Didn't he also have a comm panel built into it?

The TOS one also had slots for data discs as well.

And you've Kirk record his log at it.

I don't recall where I found this, it may have been in this thread or forum, but

https://twitter.com/TheApexFan/media

This account has images of all the props and close ups of their info plaques.
 
Everything is looking great! There's not one thing that I dislike. I'm a little meh over the new tricorders, but I don't dislike them. Everything else ranges from freaking fantastic to very nice.
 
So why are they using port and starboard but forward and rear? That's so silly to me. Fore and aft are the words they couldn't remember or be bothered to look up.
 
But that's the thing, it's not an advancement, it's a de-evolution. DSC is 10 years before TOS, yet the tech in DSC looks like it's 70 years more advanced than TOS. That absolutely should be explained.
Here's the explanation.

TOS was made 50 years ago. Discovery is made now using modern technologies and modern design sensibilities so that it will appeal to a modern audience. No more needs to be said.

There is no in story explanation. It's all real world explanations. And, that is entirely fine.
 
I'm asking if anyone can come up with one.

For instance:
Enterprise communicator
GaJzrfh.jpg


Kelvin Communicator
3asYF0Q.jpg

Kirk Era communicator
R6wnAOh.jpg


Which one "devolved?"

Or, how about this Andorian handheld device
fg7O6u7.jpg

or this NX-01 computer display
AhIuxtm.jpg


vs this Kirk era computer
PrAyaw6.jpg
And that is exactly my point on why DSC doesn't have to look like TOS to fit in canon. ENT already showed, for better or worse, tech in the NX-01 that is seemingly more advanced than ships launched 100 years later. The JJ films show us two additional Prime, pre-TOS ships with touch screens and monitors galore (NX-326 Franklin and NCC-0514 Kelvin). Even though DSC takes place 10 years before TOS, the Discovery and Shenzou's registries (1031 and 1227) are smack dab between the Kelvin and Connie; retaining older technology and design is plausible.

The way I see it, the tech in TOS is advanced in function despite being retro in appearance.
 
And that is exactly my point on why DSC doesn't have to look like TOS to fit in canon. ENT already showed, for better or worse, tech in the NX-01 that is seemingly more advanced than ships launched 100 years later. The JJ films show us two additional Prime, pre-TOS ships with touch screens and monitors galore (NX-326 Franklin and NCC-0514 Kelvin). Even though DSC takes place 10 years before TOS, the Discovery and Shenzou's registries (1031 and 1227) are smack dab between the Kelvin and Connie; retaining older technology and design is plausible.

The way I see it, the tech in TOS is advanced in function despite being retro in appearance.
Exactly. The tech isn't more advanced, it just looks different.
 
If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

Sign up / Register


Back
Top