I'd say it has more in common with the NX-01 then the Kelvin Connie.
Kelvin Timeline all but confirmed
- Thread starter captainkirk
- Start date
I'd say it has more in common with the NX-01 then the Kelvin Connie.
Even the engine room being all industrial?
Since Vulcan culture is reluctant and slow to change, that is not altogether surprising.
ETA: Also, most of the time we see Sarek in TOS he is acting in official function as ambassador. This may be more casual cloths, or even something more Earth inspired as part of his cultural understanding.
Last edited:
I like beer.
I never understood the objections to 09's engineering set
I never understood the objections to 09's engineering set
That's just it. People would have preferred an actual engineering set rather than a Budweiser brewery.
What does a fictional futuristic engineering set look like anyway?
Not brewery? Oh wait, we don't know. I know one commentator/Youtuber who theorized that the tanks shown were deuterium storage.
But, this, obviously, is the future:
The odd thing is, if it had been a decade earlier, I might have objected to the beer plant engineering, but while it's not an ideal solution to finding an epic setting for the bowels of the ship (and was replaced in ST Beyond by CGI) it somehow..just works. I never batted an eye during those scenes. It just made the whole ship seem bigger and spacious and real. The tiny engineering sets in the tv shows always seemed claustrophobic to me.I never understood the objections to 09's engineering set
This was one thing that convinced me I had to change perspective a bit..if I could accept it, and it worked I could let some other things go.
RAMA
I tend to agree. When I'm in the film I'm not thinking "Hey, what's a brewery doing in my Star Trek." I'm thinking "Engineering is huge and looks very dangerous" something that you don't want to mess with. Like, if something goes wrong, it will go catastrophically wrong.
I also thought the NIF looked like a great warp reactor core in STID. A brilliant idea.
That's a like and agreement 100%I also thought the NIF looked like a great warp reactor core in STID. A brilliant idea.
Not brewery? Oh wait, we don't know. I know one commentator/Youtuber who theorized that the tanks shown were deuterium storage.
But, this, obviously, is the future:
They shouldn't bother building a new bridge set either then. These should have been more than adequate:
I mean, what does a fictional futuristic bridge set look like anyway? Oh wait, we don't know either.
They wanted a big set that would've blown the budget if they had built it. I didn't find the brewery ideal, but it did the job it needed to do at a likely fraction of the cost.
Movies and TV shows made in this decade will have a certain look (art direction-wise) compared to TV shows made in the 1960s -- even when that art direction is showing a future sci-fi setting.
So no -- the reason they didn't base Sarek's wardrobe on how he dressed in Journey to Babel is NOT because they specifically were trying to emulate the Kelvin universe, and has everything to do with Journey to Babel being a 1960s TV show and DSC being a 2017 TV show. A 2017 TV shows art direction and wardrobe will naturally look more like something else made in the 2010 decade than it would look like something made in 1965.
Last edited:
Hmmm....Adjustable gooseneck task lighting. I suppose the set designers for The Cage were onto something.They shouldn't bother building a new bridge set either then. These should have been more than adequate:
I mean, what does a fictional futuristic bridge set look like anyway? Oh wait, we don't know either.
Agreed - best. engineering. ever.I also thought the NIF looked like a great warp reactor core in STID. A brilliant idea.
Similar threads
