• Welcome! The TrekBBS is the number one place to chat about Star Trek with like-minded fans.
    If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

Worst command decisions by Captain James T. Kirk

As for "The Galileo Seven", the very fact that the Murasaki phenomenon was there and wasn't going anywhere was telling enough -
I got the impression that the Murasaki phenomenon was short lived, and it wouldn't be possible to return and study it later, towards the middle of the episode didn't it dissolve?
 
Allowing Lt. Bailey to be a bridge officer in The Corbomite Maneuver, he never should have been assigned there in the first place. I don't know how he ever got to be a Lieutenant, given how hard it's supposed to be to get through Starfleet training. The man was obviously unhinged and McCoy was right when he pointed out that Bailey shouldn't be in that position. It puts the whole ship in danger if a command isn't carried out because a bridge officer is having a psychotic episode, screaming at everyone.

Maybe he got there by way of family connections and is trying too hard to prove that he deserves the posting on his own merits (and subsequently fails by trying too hard).
 
I got the impression that the Murasaki phenomenon was short lived, and it wouldn't be possible to return and study it later, towards the middle of the episode didn't it dissolve?

Now there's a novel idea! The original space footage of course was recycled in a fashion that omitted Murasaki from all the later shots, so one could argue that. But it's not as if there would have been much of Murasaki visually to begin with - Kirk's viewscreen showed the green blob, but the action shots with the shuttle never had any green to them save for the planet itself.

And TOS-R swings the other way, showing thick green mist everywhere, all the time...

As for dialogue, no mention is made of transience. Kirk's crew valiantly tries to improve the sensors and the transporters, and eventually they begin to work despite the phenomenon. That is, the phenomenon is not said to have gone away or weakened (although admittedly it is not said to have remained steady or even in existence, either).

Timo Saloniemi
 
Not checking in on Khan and his people on Ceti-Alpha V, or at least making sure that someone in the Federation was.

I always imagined that MU-Kirk used the Botany Bay for target practice. Of course, MU-Khan and his people were probably all good guys that used the BB to escape the tyranny of the early Empire back on earth.
 
Yeah, c'mon Mitchell. Use your God-like powers on the tombstone. :nyah:

wherenomanhasgonebeforehdalt1335.jpg
 
If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

Sign up / Register


Back
Top