• Welcome! The TrekBBS is the number one place to chat about Star Trek with like-minded fans.
    If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

What would be a deal breaker for you in Discovery?

Status
Not open for further replies.
I think family show is a bit of stretch. It was dealing with some adult subjects. TOS was known for playing "what can we slip past the censors" especially when it came to women's costumes. DS9's war stories and things like Picard's torture aren't exactly stuff for the kiddies.
I started watching Trek when I was six years old. :shrug:

In fact everyone I know started watching Trek when they were either kids or teenagers. Compared to shows like South Park, it's quite tame.
 
I started watching Trek when I was six years old. :shrug:

In fact everyone I know started watching Trek when they were either kids or teenagers.
I was seven, back in 1966 and that's when I started. Still, it wasn't aimed at six or seven year olds. And a lot of it went over my head. The monsters, spaceships and aliens were cool though. Being SF, most parents won't object to letting kids watch it, because as we know, SF is for kids anyway. :p
If parents then and now payed attention, I wonder how many would have let little Jane and Johnny keep watching the show?:shrug:
 
I was seven, back in 1966 and that's when I started. Still, it wasn't aimed at six or seven year olds. And a lot of it went over my head. The monsters, spaceships and aliens were cool though. Being SF, most parents won't object to letting kids watch it, because as we know, SF is for kids anyway. :p
If parents then and now payed attention, I wonder how many would have let little Jane and Johnny keep watching the show?:shrug:
My grandmother was watching it right along with my dad in the sixties. The only conflict was my grandfather complaining that there HAD to be a good western instead of a show with a pointy eared Martian.

And my dad and mother was at the theater with me for TWOK, a movie with all kinds of violence and blood. We still watch new Trek and Star Wars together. Its sort of a family tradition.
.
 
My grandmother was watching it right along with my dad in the sixties. The only conflict was my grandfather complaining that there HAD to be a good western instead of a show with a pointy eared Martian.

And my dad and mother was at the theater with me for TWOK, a movie with all kinds of violence and blood. We still watch new Trek and Star Wars together. Its sort of a family tradition.
.
You're lucky. I couldn't pay my parents to watch any form of Science Fiction. :lol: Or maybe I was lucky.
 
It's hard to say what a deal-breaker is for me. I try to keep an open mind even though I love TOS; I still love some of the newer shows (heck I think I'm one of the few that enjoy "Enterprise). What will be hard to overcome for me is if they substitute political correctness for good story telling. For me the story is the key.
Yes I suspect political correctness instead of good story telling is on the agenda..
 
This is pretty much the only thing that could get me to watch the show. A sincere pro-Trump production would be fascinating, the internet's reaction even moreso. I would pay to watch that.

As it is, I won't pay for CBS All Access, so I guess that's my deal breaker.

No. The stupid would consume all our brains. I know scifi / fantasy requires a lot of suspension of disbelief from audiences, but that would be too much. :guffaw:
 
Yes I suspect political correctness instead of good story telling is on the agenda..

Why would you suspect that at this stage? I don't see any indication for it at all.

They have a relatively diverse cast (that still seems to overrepresent men) but that just seems normal. They obviously don't want to share story details yet so I don't see how anybody can say how important stories are to them.
 
If it's tyranny you're pointing to, that would have been the Obama admin.

Whatever you are smoking? I want some! :lol:

I bet you're still waiting for Obama to invade Texas...

...the substance of which was a gift to the worst terrorist-sponsoring state in the world.

The Saudi's have likely had a hand in killing more American civilians than Iran. Yet, two Bush and the Trump administrations have had no issue buddying up with them. Including selling $110 billion dollars in arms to them just the other day.
 
And they pretend politics won't spoil Star Trek..

It hasn't yet.

The High Ground said:
DATA: But if that is so, Captain, why are their methods so often successful? I have been reviewing the history of armed rebellion and it appears that terrorism is an effective way to promote political change.
PICARD: Yes, it can be, but I have never subscribed to the theory that political power flows from the barrel of a gun.
DATA: Yet there are numerous examples where it was successful. The independence of the Mexican State from Spain, the Irish Unification of 2024, and the Kensey Rebellion.
 
I just associated it with the term 'moral' high ground. It read try hard superior to me.. arrogant.
 
You know for a franchise that preaches how everything will be perfect once we get over our petty bigotries and hatred to finally work together as an united human race a lot of fans seem to actively dislike actually seeing this fulfilled on screen. When they say that humans are treated equally, it means all humans, not just the straight white men. There are plenty of interesting stories that can be told that don't involve how great straight white men are. I know diversity is a scary word with a lot of syllables, It's not going to be a Captain Planet episode. It's going to have aliens and ships zapping at each other.
 
You know for a franchise that preaches how everything will be perfect once we get over our petty bigotries and hatred to finally work together as an united human race a lot of fans seem to actively dislike actually seeing this fulfilled on screen. When they say that humans are treated equally, it means all humans, not just the straight white men. There are plenty of interesting stories that can be told that don't involve how great straight white men are. I know diversity is a scary word with a lot of syllables, It's not going to be a Captain Planet episode. It's going to have aliens and ships zapping at each other.
Where did that come from? No one in this thread has advocated a straight white man agenda..
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

Sign up / Register


Back
Top