• Welcome! The TrekBBS is the number one place to chat about Star Trek with like-minded fans.
    If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

CBS/Paramount sues to stop Axanar

Status
Not open for further replies.
As someone else pointed out, it's a shame they didn't just do "Axanar" as the Docudrama with Trek star cameos/recurring. They could have done a six part miniseries about the entire war with prelude acting as a sort of "presummary"
 
I hope you're not buying into the idea that a fan-film done in the "docudrama" style is somehow covered by Fair Use.
 
Saw this on one of the facebook groups and it struck a chord. The people blindly supporting LFIM as well as his other acolytes need to realize that this is really the 'order of things' (as the Jem'Hadar like to say). What is presented on screen (JJTrek, StD etc.) is hardly all that there is (they should really dive into TrekLit, ST: Online or start checking out some of the fan-produced stuff, whether filmed or written). I think once that point really sinks in, it will become easier to see LFIM for the arrogant charlatan that he is

17884426_1391743970871738_380775328347715844_n.jpg
 
I hope you're not buying into the idea that a fan-film done in the "docudrama" style is somehow covered by Fair Use.

No, but at the time, the climate was very fan film friendly. He was given a LOT of money. If he has actually produced what he said he was going to (or at least produced SOMETHING with the money) then this would have probably never been a big deal. If he hadn't bragged and ran his mouth constantly, and actually released content, then he would have probably been overlooked by the legal department like so many others.

A docudrama series would have been something never seen or done before in the Trek universe. Its why Prelude was so amazing at the time. A series done like that could have so many easter eggs, and so many guest actors doing commentary, and so many awesome space battles, and even a few low budget re-enactment scenes (labeled as such) where Peters could have still played Garth. If he had been smart and creative and efficient he could have been the Trek legend that he wanted to be. They could have gone back to do historical mini series set in so many different eras, with so many different types of uniforms, guest actors and ship CGI, without ever having to spend the money on the sets or the damn warehouse or any of it. They could have filmed the re enactments on the existing available TOS sets when they got the chance and done the talking heads / Federation TV / CGI battles / narrator telling a story thing quickly, efficiently, cheaply, and *repeatedly*.
 
Last edited:
As someone else pointed out, it's a shame they didn't just do "Axanar" as the Docudrama with Trek star cameos/recurring. They could have done a six part miniseries about the entire war with prelude acting as a sort of "presummary"

A lot of the creative team behind prelude wanted to go right into filming on axanar after the KS. Insgtead the studio came first. If they had done that and went right into work on axanar with the prelude team still intact it probably would be done by now and may not have been sued (but could have still triggered guidelines to be made). Alec got a big head and got greedy and the rest is history.
 
Maybe there aren't even 300 by now. I think, there are many donations coming from the "inner circle" under different names. Just to show "outsiders" that it's right to donate to that honorable cause.
Either those "donations" might be drawn back just before the end of the campaign or those "donors" might get a refund "in private". Could be fewer than 100 donors at all.

Yes, I'm this mistrusting.
I think you are dead on. At least 30-40% of those donations looked to be based on "Psst, gimme ten bucks to make it to payday, and I'll pay you right back."
 
Sorry, but I WOULD call the entire Industry Studios Indegogo and any further crowfunding by Alec Peters for 'other' Axanar production projects a scam in that he's NOT doing it for any sort of homage to, or 'love' for Star Trek fandom. For him it's all about starting/maintaining a for profit business and or self financial enrichment first and foremost - period.
But...but...but...it's a NONPROFIT! Nonprofits pay salaries! Film students! Fan films! I'm really into philanthropy now! Really!
 
Read that. It's hilarious! Steven cites a million dollar budget for a movie that was actually made and released, while missing the point - THERE IS NO AXANAR MOVIE AND THERE NEVER WILL BE. And $1.4 million dollars of Trek fan money is gone.

Thank you for that detailed "behind the scenes" budget, Steven! It amplifies what we have been shouting about for a year: There is no movie, but there was plenty of money to make a movie (the sample budget in his blog PROVES it) - so where's the damn movie?
 
Last edited:
Read that. It's hilarious! Steven cites a million dollar budget for a movie that was actually made and released, while missing the point - THERE IS NO AXANAR MOVIE AND THERE NEVER WILL BE. And $1.4 million dollars of Trek fan money is gone.

Thank you for that detailed "behind the scenes" budget, Steven! It amplifies what we have been shouting about for a year: There is no movie, but there was plenty of money to make a movie (the sample budget in his blog PROVES it) - so where's the damn movie?

and he brings up that continues raised $800K. They also produced 8 episodes for that amount too.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

Sign up / Register


Back
Top