Starfleet is a Space Navy (military fleet)
- Thread starter Baxten
- Start date
- Status
And a partridge in a pear tree
Random, and slightly peculiar thought, but what it Starfleet
Actually, the US Coast Guard is an example of an armed force which is officially only a military during wartime, the rest of the time it is a maritime enforcement, regulatory and rescue service under a different Executive Department than the military (initially Treasury outside of the WWs, then Transport, and then DHS after 9/11). It is worth noting that it is never referred to as a paramilitary.
Actually, the US Coast Guard is an example of an armed force which is officially only a military during wartime, the rest of the time it is a maritime enforcement, regulatory and rescue service under a different Executive Department than the military (initially Treasury outside of the WWs, then Transport, and then DHS after 9/11). It is worth noting that it is never referred to as a paramilitary.
I think the US Coast Guard/Navy are probably the closest in structure and mission types to Starfleet.
It's not civil! It's military! What was the question?
Diplomacy in Trek is often a contact mission of some kind, charting space is exploring, surveys are exploring, science missions are exploring, the officer exchange program is definitely exploring as it's with a different culture, Okona did his own exploring, but they answered a distress call and got two first contacts out of it.... even the ship maintenance got some exploring in. This is just from memory. Your criteria is too literal...and none have 'military' in the description, though have war games..in which episode we get explicit 'not military' dialogue.
Star Trek is a TV show, and TV shows aren't always 100% realistic. Even ones set in modern militaries have included much of what you just posted. Hell, the Stargate franchise has plenty of examples covering each one of those. And hell, point #7, getting publicly shitfaced on duty, people I know in the military claim that's a regular thing for them. Hell, there are several internet memes on the matter as well.
You do realize the only time Cetacean Ops was mentioned on screen was Yesterday's Enterprise, right? You know, the one where Starfleet definitely is intentionally military?:
Which involves a JAG officer in court, which I'd argue makes it sort of a military episode.
So's a duck, a Porsche and a hamster wheel.
And that show actually had serving USAF officers as technical advisors, and had two different Air Force Chiefs of Staff in cameo roles.
More than that, scripts were actually signed off by the Pentagon before they were filmed (for SG-1, anyway). Richard Dean Anderson was also named an honorary USAF Brigadier General for his portrayal of Jack O'Neill.
Fun story, General John Jumper apparently lobbied the Stargate writers almost immediately after he became Chief of Staff for a cameo on the show. On the DVD commentary for the episode he appeared in, Lost City, it is claimed Jumper's first question upon becoming Chief of Staff was "when do I get my Stargate cameo?"
You tried going to warp without them? Tech.
And there's many episodes featuring an Irishman in a bar, but doesn't make Trek into a comedy series. XD
Weren't the bridge sets for TMP signed off by the pentagon and NASA? Or was that just Walter Koenig being funny?
Don't know about that. An artist involved in the movie also did work for NASA and the Pentagon though, painting murals for them.
They also spend time exploring the concept called 'sense of humour'
The Royal Air Force is a different organisation than the British Army however both are Armed Forces and engage in warfare (along with the Royal Navy and Marines) when necessary
Except Delta Airlines can't execute/revoke the freedom of members of its flight crews for breaking its rules.
And no one expects Delta Airlines to defend the nation from hostile enemies
And they consider themselves explorers as well right????
I took those from the stated mission at the beginning of each episode.
"Captain's log.....we're answering a distress call in the _______ sector..."
"we're doing a routine maintenance..."
and so on.
I was surprised that almost half of the episodes were about a distress call of some sort.
Yes, if we include the planetary survey, and the geological survey, plus the one where the stated mission is exploring _____, then that's 3. The science episodes I mentioned were about checking up on nonstarfleet scientists, such as the terraformers who were behind schedule, or Dr. Ira Graves, who needed medical treatment.
Measure of a Man was one of the "Were at Starbase _______ for routine maintenance....or repairs....or upgrades"
I wasn't really trying to make a point with the list, I just picked a time when the Federation was at peace, Roddenberry's new vision was in full force, Picard was at the height of his Idealism, etc.
I guess it may be useful to add that all of these missions are within the domain of the military. Even exploration. The military has been at the forefront of science and exploration for ages. Most of the known world was explored by the U.S. Navy, the British Navy, and other European Navies, mostly between the 17th and 21st century.
My wife's response, "yes, Starfleet is the Federation's version of the military". I asked her about Picard's line, she seemed to think that he made the statement because he doesn't see himself as a soldier.
As always, everyone's mileage varies. Going around to other forums, they opinion is pretty split on the idea, just as it seems to be here.
As always, everyone's mileage varies. Going around to other forums, they opinion is pretty split on the idea, just as it seems to be here.
Even then, it was retconned that the Federation was at war with the Cardassians and Tzenkethi.
The Minstrel boy...to the wa...- Status
