• Welcome! The TrekBBS is the number one place to chat about Star Trek with like-minded fans.
    If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

What's in YOUR 'head canon'?

Status
Not open for further replies.
I'd have to think in more depth for a more detailed response, but off the top of my head, Abrams trek is an alternate universe I mostly choose to ignore.

The novel verse is mostly non canon, but I like to cherry pick certain elements that appeal to me. I like how Greater Than the Sum tells us that there are two types of drones, assimilated and incubated, which neatly explains the differences between drones like Hugh and those like Seven of Nine. I like to think there was some way that Hugh survived at the end though.

Though I enjoyed the Destiny trilogy, I see this at best an alternate universe thing. It's very eye rolling to me that humans would be at all involved in the creation pf the Borg. Nor does the idea that they'd switch from assimilation to extinction seem plausible as it violates their driving force of achieving perfection through assimilation. Nor do I think the entire collective be destroyed in one fell swoop to be very plausible. Also, how would they have replenished themselves if they ceased assimilating?

I prefer the idea of the growth of "good" Borg who have broken away from the Collective, as was shown with Hugh's Borg planet, the Cooperative from the Voyager Unity episode, and the Unimatrix zero Borg, with their own cubes and spheres. I like to think of all three types of good Borg linking up as a Borg Alliance who eventually join the Federation. The "bad" Borg would still exist, but they'd stay pretty much as they were in Voyager.
 
Last edited:
Number One in Star Trek: Discovery is the same Number One that served under Pike, just reassigned. Bryan Fuller be damned.

Even if there's an episode that takes place at the same time as The Cage, I'll just chalk it up to another transporter accident, goddammit.
Isn't it a bit early to be making those proclamations about a series that isn't even cast yet? What if Discovery's Number One is going to be non-Caucasian, as the early publicity has indicated is pretty likely?

I remember Majel Barrett telling me how she shouted, cried, and threw a fit at Gene when named Riker Number One.
I still remember reading in People magazine that the first officer was going to be named "Number One" (I don't recall if the Riker name was given) and wondering what connection he might have with the character from "The Cage."
 
"Number One" should be a code name for certain individuals genetically enhanced to excel in command and leadership roles.

Yeah, forget that reactionary nonsense about genetic engineering being banned. :rolleyes:

Kor
 
I think the log entries are made after the events, the characters falsely but openly speaking in a false-present tense ... we often see the characters make present tense comments as narration even though they're not shown speaking them in the scene.
 
I think the log entries are made after the events, the characters falsely but openly speaking in a false-present tense ... we often see the characters make present tense comments as narration even though they're not shown speaking them in the scene.

I just love, love episodes that follow this pattern:

-Dramatic showdown, often our captain looking at the viewscreen on the bridge, tensely staring down enemy captain
-cliffhanger music plays, cut to commercial
-return from commercial, show external shot of both ships facing each other
-narration: "Captain's Log, Supplemental. We are currently engaged with a Romulan warbird. Tensions are high, and the stakes have never been so drastic."
-cut to bridge: captain is still at the same spot, still looking at the viewscreen, the two captains about to face off

Like, *when* did Picard have the time to record his log? Did he record it while the channel was still open? Did everyone on the bridge and the enemy ship hear the whole thing?

Which leads me to believe that your theory is probably the most logical one.
 
I'd have to think in more depth for a more detailed response, but off the top of my head, Abrams trek is an alternate universe I mostly choose to ignore.

The novel verse is mostly non canon, but I like to cherry pick certain elements that appeal to me. I like how Greater Than the Sum tells us that there are two types of drones, assimilated and incubated, which neatly explains the differences between drones like Hugh and those like Seven of Nine. I like to think there was some way that Hugh survived at the end though.

Though I enjoyed the Destiny trilogy, I see this at best an alternate universe thing. It's very eye rolling to me that humans would be at all involved in the creation pf the Borg. Nor does the idea that they'd switch from assimilation to extinction seem plausible as it violates their driving force of achieving perfection through assimilation. Nor do I think the entire collective be destroyed in one fell swoop to be very plausible. Also, how would they have replenished themselves if they ceased assimilating?
They hadn't completely given up assimilation, it was just that the Federation and their allies had proven to be so much of a threat that they decided they had to wipe them out. With the way things were built up the beginning and end of the Borg made perfect sense. I think the way things played out in Destiny make more sense than if the Borg had somehow just randomly ended up with a name that was so close to a human term. Yeah, it wasn't the only possible way to go with a Borg origin story, but I thought it was great. I absolutely loved the end of the Borg.
I'm the completely opposite, until we get something set after Nemesis, the novels are what happens after Nemesis for me. It also doesn't hurt that the novels have probably had the most direct hands on involvement from people who wrote and are writing for the shows.
 
I haven't read any of the novels, so I don't know if this happens, but I do know that people are pretty split over whether they are canon or not.
I like to think that Kirayoshi O'Brien goes back to DS9 to get to know Colonel Kira, the woman who gave birth to him.
 
A chilling interpretation of some throwaway lines from "The Squire of Gothos"



Eek, when you consider all the animal heads and taxidermied creatures on his walls...is Trelane a sociopath?
Why, yes! I thought that was a given. Which is why I don't consider SoG to be a "wacky" episode, as some might. Trelane was capable of absolutely anything, not just physically, but morally.
 
Dr. Nichols and Plexicorp kept their knowledge of transparent aluminum a closely guarded trade secret, but they never figured out how to manufacture it. The company eventually went bankrupt for unrelated mismanagement reasons and all research on the material was lost during the liquidation. Someone else invented it independently many years later.

Actually, I believe that Aluminium Oxynitride was already in development at the time of said events:

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Aluminium_oxynitride

This could be said to be the "Transparent Aluminium" (no, I will not remove the I :D) that is later in use.
 
Despite having seen ears and breasts on Andorians in the movies and in Enterprise, I still go with the preimise that they're an insectile race with partial exoskeletons, and their antennas are their ears. Post-TOS representations are erroneous and show a lack of imagination.
 
sn't it a bit early to be making those proclamations about a series that isn't even cast yet? What if Discovery's Number One is going to be non-Caucasian, as the early publicity has indicated is pretty likely?
"Number One" should be a code name for certain individuals genetically enhanced to excel in command and leadership roles.

Yeah, forget that reactionary nonsense about genetic engineering being banned. :rolleyes:

Kor
Funny. I was playing around with a prequel idea many years ago. ( Before Enterprise!!!) And in it I had Number One as a character. She was a Latina who was an Augment and part on an experiment to "mainstream" descendants of the 1990s "supermen"

That's in my head canon now
 
My head canon about Voyager's episode Drone is that Seven's human DNA was in the genetic mix as well as her nanoprobes. And that's why One didn't look like a clone of Ensign Mulcahey.
 
Wesley is Picard's son - the result of a drunken night with Beverly. He's not sure, but strongly suspects. Makes the first few seasons of TNG much more interesting when you assume that.

Why would Picard do something like that to his best friend (Jack)? That's not how Picard acts. He doesn't fool around with his best friend's wife.

Also, neither Picard nor Beverly are the drinking types anyway.
 
I've always wondered why the same actor didn't play both roles in Drone
I know, right? Maybe the writers/producers thought that the actor that played the Nazi officer in The Killing Game had more of some kind of quality they were looking for in the character of One. He also played the part of the Vulcan Mestral in Enterprise's Carbon Creek.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

Sign up / Register


Back
Top