• Welcome! The TrekBBS is the number one place to chat about Star Trek with like-minded fans.
    If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

CBS/Paramount sues to stop Axanar

Status
Not open for further replies.
Anyways, our support us page is the same thing as crowdfunding page. You donate, you get the perks at that reward level. CBS is allowing crowdnfunding (for now anyways), this is no different. All money donated goes towards out next production, in this case "The Requiem" .

But what happens to the money that is beyond what you need or is donated after whatever cut off you have to set your budget? Has CBS given any guidance as far as that is concerned?

No, but at this point in time we are about 200k short of what we want to be to get everything done in the best way possible. We want to stretch episode 2 by 15-20 minutes also (maybe even split it into 2 episodes) , that budgets well above what we got on the KS drive, then there is all the post work and costs with that. We never had quite enough for the pilot, actually owed a little bit.
 
They are coaching fans with "talking points" now.

Any examples?
here you go


Hi everyone,


We've worked up a series of talking points about the lawsuit that will help keep the online conversations productive and on-point (from our position, anyway). Please feel free to use these talking points in your own comments when you post them to Facebook or any of the comments sections of the dozens of articles currently running their stories about the lawsuit.

=========================
Key Talking Points re: CBS/Paramount Lawsuit

1. Axanar Productions (Alec) found out about the lawsuit through the news media. The lawsuit was not served until Wednesday, Dec. 30th.

2. Axanar Productions and Alec are known at CBS and could have contacted the production directly with their concerns and suggestions for addressing those concerns; but chose to file a lawsuit instead.

3. Axanar Productions takes this lawsuit seriously and wants to work out an amicable and mutually beneficial solution with the original IP owners. We have already reached out to them.

4. For more than forty years, CBS and Paramount have allowed fans to produce Star Trek films. We celebrate ALL fan films on our website and have documented much of the history of Star Trek fan films there (in articles written, incidentally, by a Star Trek fan).

5. We’re not doing anything new here – we’re just doing it differently and with the help of fans who are professionals in various aspects of production, design, marketing, etc. If there’s a professional “edge” to Axanar Production’s work, it’s because these fans are really good at what they do.

6. We believe that fans who work on Axanar Production’s projects (i.e. PRELUDE TO AXANAR and AXANAR) should be compensated for their effort beyond a pat on the back. We can’t afford to pay full union rates, but we do pay something to help defer the costs associated with providing skilled talent to our projects. There are aspects of production which cannot be done by unskilled fans, and almost every fan film deals with this problem by occasionally paying skilled technicians for their time when necessary.

7. Why CBS and Paramount have decided to sue Axanar Productions and thousands of Star Trek fans by proxy is beyond us. It seems an odd thing to do given we’re on the verge of a year-long celebration of Star Trek’s 50th anniversary.

8. Fan activism in Axanar Production’s defense is welcome – after all, Star Trek has a history of fans rushing to the franchise’s rescue since the mid-1960’s when Bjo Trimble and thousands of other Trek fans flooded the mailroom at NBC to give the original series a third season.

9. While fan support is appreciated, Axanar Productions won’t actively coordinate a response to either CBS or Paramount. We want to work with them on this issue, not intentionally antagonize them.

10. We ask fans to be civil, respectful, factual and persistent in expressing their displeasure and urge all parties to work out a mutually beneficial outcome.

11. All fan films solicit for donations. We're certainly not the only fan film that has utilized the power of crowd-funding to raise hundreds of thousands of dollars. We're just the most open and honest about how much has been raised, and where the money goes. Our Axanar Annual Report is hailed as a standard in crowd funding. This 23 page document details where every dollar from both of our Kickstarter campaigns was spent, as well as lessons learned and a detailed explanation of costs.

http://www.axanarproductions.com/revised-axanar-annual-report-released/

NOTE:

DO NOT talk about any legal argument.
DO NOT criticize CBS or Paramount or any Star Trek

Best Regards,

Robert Meyer Burnett
 
Yes, "don't talk about any legal argument", because you'll get completely crushed by the massive weight of the facts.
 
They are coaching fans with "talking points" now.

Any examples?
here you go


Hi everyone,


We've worked up a series of talking points about the lawsuit that will help keep the online conversations productive and on-point (from our position, anyway). Please feel free to use these talking points in your own comments when you post them to Facebook or any of the comments sections of the dozens of articles currently running their stories about the lawsuit.

=========================
Key Talking Points re: CBS/Paramount Lawsuit

1. Axanar Productions (Alec) found out about the lawsuit through the news media. The lawsuit was not served until Wednesday, Dec. 30th.

2. Axanar Productions and Alec are known at CBS and could have contacted the production directly with their concerns and suggestions for addressing those concerns; but chose to file a lawsuit instead.

3. Axanar Productions takes this lawsuit seriously and wants to work out an amicable and mutually beneficial solution with the original IP owners. We have already reached out to them.

4. For more than forty years, CBS and Paramount have allowed fans to produce Star Trek films. We celebrate ALL fan films on our website and have documented much of the history of Star Trek fan films there (in articles written, incidentally, by a Star Trek fan).

5. We’re not doing anything new here – we’re just doing it differently and with the help of fans who are professionals in various aspects of production, design, marketing, etc. If there’s a professional “edge” to Axanar Production’s work, it’s because these fans are really good at what they do.

6. We believe that fans who work on Axanar Production’s projects (i.e. PRELUDE TO AXANAR and AXANAR) should be compensated for their effort beyond a pat on the back. We can’t afford to pay full union rates, but we do pay something to help defer the costs associated with providing skilled talent to our projects. There are aspects of production which cannot be done by unskilled fans, and almost every fan film deals with this problem by occasionally paying skilled technicians for their time when necessary.

7. Why CBS and Paramount have decided to sue Axanar Productions and thousands of Star Trek fans by proxy is beyond us. It seems an odd thing to do given we’re on the verge of a year-long celebration of Star Trek’s 50th anniversary.

8. Fan activism in Axanar Production’s defense is welcome – after all, Star Trek has a history of fans rushing to the franchise’s rescue since the mid-1960’s when Bjo Trimble and thousands of other Trek fans flooded the mailroom at NBC to give the original series a third season.

9. While fan support is appreciated, Axanar Productions won’t actively coordinate a response to either CBS or Paramount. We want to work with them on this issue, not intentionally antagonize them.

10. We ask fans to be civil, respectful, factual and persistent in expressing their displeasure and urge all parties to work out a mutually beneficial outcome.

11. All fan films solicit for donations. We're certainly not the only fan film that has utilized the power of crowd-funding to raise hundreds of thousands of dollars. We're just the most open and honest about how much has been raised, and where the money goes. Our Axanar Annual Report is hailed as a standard in crowd funding. This 23 page document details where every dollar from both of our Kickstarter campaigns was spent, as well as lessons learned and a detailed explanation of costs.

http://www.axanarproductions.com/revised-axanar-annual-report-released/

NOTE:

DO NOT talk about any legal argument.
DO NOT criticize CBS or Paramount or any Star Trek

Best Regards,

Robert Meyer Burnett


Out curiosity was that emailed to the donor base?

7. Why CBS and Paramount have decided to sue Axanar Productions and thousands of Star Trek fans by proxy is beyond us. It seems an odd thing to do given we’re on the verge of a year-long celebration of Star Trek’s 50th anniversary.

Now CBS is suing fans by proxy. Oh, brother.

6. We believe that fans who work on Axanar Production’s projects (i.e. PRELUDE TO AXANAR and AXANAR) should be compensated for their effort beyond a pat on the back. We can’t afford to pay full union rates, but we do pay something to help defer the costs associated with providing skilled talent to our projects. There are aspects of production which cannot be done by unskilled fans, and almost every fan film deals with this problem by occasionally paying skilled technicians for their time when necessary.

You know, I have no problem with paying people for work done. That's admirable that they want to do that. I have a problem with the use of CBS's IP and their Kickstarter as the means to build the infrastructure for a for-profit business, i.e. Ares Studios. That's the bigger egregious act here.

8. Fan activism in Axanar Production’s defense is welcome – after all, Star Trek has a history of fans rushing to the franchise’s rescue since the mid-1960’s when Bjo Trimble and thousands of other Trek fans flooded the mailroom at NBC to give the original series a third season.

Oh brother.

11. All fan films solicit for donations. We're certainly not the only fan film that has utilized the power of crowd-funding to raise hundreds of thousands of dollars. We're just the most open and honest about how much has been raised, and where the money goes. Our Axanar Annual Report is hailed as a standard in crowd funding. This 23 page document details where every dollar from both of our Kickstarter campaigns was spent, as well as lessons learned and a detailed explanation of costs.

Now it's a fan film and not a professional independent STAR TREK production. Ah, the semantics game.

9. While fan support is appreciated, Axanar Productions won’t actively coordinate a response to either CBS or Paramount. We want to work with them on this issue, not intentionally antagonize them.

10. We ask fans to be civil, respectful, factual and persistent in expressing their displeasure and urge all parties to work out a mutually beneficial outcome.

NOTE:

DO NOT talk about any legal argument.
DO NOT criticize CBS or Paramount or any Star Trek

Best Regards,

Robert Meyer Burnett

Burnett's twitter rant would say otherwise.
 
Last edited:
Axanar Coffee. ?

Wow. I don't even think theres ever been an official Star Trek coffee has there? If there had id have bought some
 
Why CBS and Paramount have decided to sue Axanar Productions and thousands of Star Trek fans by proxy...

Fuck,now that's really going to fuel the Axanar Faithful's egos. "CBS is suing me for being a Axanar fan!!!" If you though they were insufferable before, just wait.
 
8. Fan activism in Axanar Production’s defense is welcome – after all, Star Trek has a history of fans rushing to the franchise’s rescue since the mid-1960’s when Bjo Trimble and thousands of other Trek fans flooded the mailroom at NBC to give the original series a third season.

:lol: Sounds like someone has read too many books by Marc Cushman. The effect and reach of the 1968 letter-writing campaign to save Star Trek has been frequently exaggerated in the service of the self-congratulatory mythology of Star Trek and its fans. It speaks volumes that they're invoking a nostalgic fantasy here.

11. All fan films solicit for donations. We're certainly not the only fan film that has utilized the power of crowd-funding to raise hundreds of thousands of dollars. We're just the most open and honest about how much has been raised, and where the money goes. Our Axanar Annual Report is hailed as a standard in crowd funding. This 23 page document details where every dollar from both of our Kickstarter campaigns was spent, as well as lessons learned and a detailed explanation of costs.

"All fan films solicit for donations" is a blatant lie. Claims of openness and honesty are a bit suspect in light of the fact that they've been fundraising based on the participation of Tony Todd in spite of the fact that he's apparently been off the production for the past 4-5 months.
 
9. While fan support is appreciated, Axanar Productions won’t actively coordinate a response to either CBS or Paramount. We want to work with them on this issue, not intentionally antagonize them.

10. We ask fans to be civil, respectful, factual and persistent in expressing their displeasure and urge all parties to work out a mutually beneficial outcome.

NOTE:

DO NOT talk about any legal argument.
DO NOT criticize CBS or Paramount or any Star Trek

Best Regards,

Robert Meyer Burnett


This stuff is hilarious considering Burnett's and Peters' behavior the last 24 hours.
 
I know the word fan is based on the word fanatic, but sweet Jesus some of the comments on the Axanar Fan page are just insane and some almost scary.

Some are a little borderline, but this one made my morning...

1003240_973107226115318_7083345571062712438_n.jpg


"Out of office reply: Thank you for your correspondence. Email replies are limited due to being dead."

Not to mention Gene Roddenberry himself outright sold ALL his rights to the original Star Trek IP to Paramount in 1969; AND even got into a bit of trouble with Paramount for starting 'Lincoln Enterprises' back in the day and selling Star Trek memorabilia - which was settled out of court between the parties.

That some fans still thought she was alive and somehow held the rights is just mind-boggling.
 
Why CBS and Paramount have decided to sue Axanar Productions and thousands of Star Trek fans by proxy...

Fuck,now that's really going to fuel the Axanar Faithful's egos. "CBS is suing me for being a Axanar fan!!!" If you though they were insufferable before, just wait.

That's started already - people are seeing this as an attack on fandom hence the calls to boycott Beyond and 2017 (as if)
 
Funded, I suspected, by a crap-ton of naive fans that believe Axanar still has a chance in hell getting made

Once I saw the Axanar coffee page, I figure the entire project is about as likely to happen as another TNG movie.

CBS is probably in "HULK SMASH!!!" mode now. :lol:

It looks like the coffee page is actually a fan/supporter of Axanar selling coffee then donating proceeds to Axanar, unless I read wrong. Not sure if that makes a difference as far as Axanar having ties to the website by accepting the money. Unless this guy is also part of the Axanar team.

From the Axanar Coffee "about us" page:

I was web surfing one night looking for Star Trek audio dramas. I stumbled across Prelude to Axanar. I was simply blown away, not by the special effects, but by the level of writing that stays true to the ideals set forth by Gene Roddenberry. Looking back at that moment I recognized their commitment and that providence had moved. The amount and variety of support was humbling and we wanted to help too; even it was only to make sure that they were properly caffeinated while they did this wonderful work. We sent 20 pounds of coffee with a custom label to Axanar Productions as a gift. Alec then approached us to do a line of coffee to help with fundraising, this is the result.

In the short time that we have been involved with Axanar Productions what I've noticed is a community of highly talented people willing to give generously of their talents in pursuit of a greater good. It's an ethos which anyone who loves Star Trek would find familiar. In keeping with that we are proud to partner with Axanar Productions to offer these coffees. I have faith you’ll like them; they are the best we know how to do.



Kevin Kane
 
I must say Axanar's direct appeals to the faithful are putting it more squarely in the television evangelist camp. What's next? Requests for prayers? "Give us 6 million dollars or the Great Bird is going to call us home"?
 
Dub said:
It looks like the coffee page is actually a fan/supporter of Axanar selling coffee then donating proceeds to Axanar, unless I read wrong. Not sure if that makes a difference as far as Axanar having ties to the website by accepting the money. Unless this guy is also part of the Axanar team.
It's a business venture between Peters and the coffee sellers. Whichever way you look at it the coffee is sold using the Star Trek brand name. That's trading on the goodwill of someone else's IP.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

Sign up / Register


Back
Top