• Welcome! The TrekBBS is the number one place to chat about Star Trek with like-minded fans.
    If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

Overlooked franchises you'd like to see movies of...

Blakes 7
The Moon is a harsh Mistress

I never saw Blake's 7. But if they did a remake, maybe they would finally release the original on DVD in the US.

I'd love to see a movie version of The Moon Is a Harsh Mistress. However, I have very little faith that Hollywood would do any justice to the book's underlying libertarian philosophy. Also, I'm not entirely sure how they'd do all of the stuff with the Moon's light gravity. I think maybe they'd need to do it as a photo-realistic CGI film, like Robert Zemeckis' Beowulf.
 
...I'd still like to see new/better movie (or more likely TV) versions of:

Dune
Other than William Hurt's abominable "performance" as Duke Leto and Susan Sarandon's ridiculous casting as Julie Cox's younger sister(!) - not to mention hammy acting - what would you suggest as a better way to do Dune on TV?
Give it the "Game of Thrones" treatment on HBO or the like but without the added expense of bringing back the whole cast every season. Should make for a solid 3-4 year series adapting the first handful of actually decent books.
 
...I'd still like to see new/better movie (or more likely TV) versions of:

Dune
Other than William Hurt's abominable "performance" as Duke Leto and Susan Sarandon's ridiculous casting as Julie Cox's younger sister(!) - not to mention hammy acting - what would you suggest as a better way to do Dune on TV?
Give it the "Game of Thrones" treatment on HBO or the like but without the added expense of bringing back the whole cast every season. Should make for a solid 3-4 year series adapting the first handful of actually decent books.
I've never seen Game of Thrones, so I'm not sure of what you mean.

It would be interesting to see an adaptation of God Emperor of Dune.
 
To me, the SciFi Dune mini series of Dune and then Children of Dune (which was technically Dune Messiah and CoD) were the ultimate Dune adaptations. I honestly don't think they could be adapted better. I mean, I'm not against other attempts, but as far as I'm concerned we've already gotten near perfect adaptations of the first few books.
 
Some of Peter F. Hamilton's works. Commonwealth Saga or Night's Dawn trilogy would be truly epic to see on big screen. Though I don't know how well can you turn those bricks of books into movies that aren't 4 hours long a piece.
 
To me, the SciFi Dune mini series of Dune and then Children of Dune (which was technically Dune Messiah and CoD) were the ultimate Dune adaptations. I honestly don't think they could be adapted better. I mean, I'm not against other attempts, but as far as I'm concerned we've already gotten near perfect adaptations of the first few books.

On CoD, I have to say, it was like the first three quarters of the mini-series were really, really close to the novels, while the finale was something completely different.
 
Probably not much of a deep-SF/F fan, so not many franchises to choose from which haven't been done in some form already. But I'd still like to see new/better movie (or more likely TV) versions of:

Asimov Robots/Baley
Dune
League of Extraordinary Gentlemen (esp)


LoEG is getting a new movie
.

Yeah, but it isn't a sequel or follow-on to the first one, which is disheartening.

I hated Watchmen (film and comic) and the LXG comic. They were cynical, dystopian garbage.

LXG the movie was really good. I liked the "boy's own adventure" motif and the performances were superb.
 
Some of Peter F. Hamilton's works. Commonwealth Saga or Night's Dawn trilogy would be truly epic to see on big screen. Though I don't know how well can you turn those bricks of books into movies that aren't 4 hours long a piece.

His earlier "Greg Mandel" trilogy, about a cybernetically-enhanced detective in a tropical, post-global warming Britain, has potential, too.

(Full disclosure: I saw to the first American editions of those books.)
 
Last edited:
Probably not much of a deep-SF/F fan, so not many franchises to choose from which haven't been done in some form already. But I'd still like to see new/better movie (or more likely TV) versions of:

Asimov Robots/Baley
Dune
League of Extraordinary Gentlemen (esp)


LoEG is getting a new movie
.

Yeah, but it isn't a sequel or follow-on to the first one, which is disheartening.

I hated Watchmen (film and comic) and the LXG comic. They were cynical, dystopian garbage.

LXG the movie was really good. I liked the "boy's own adventure" motif and the performances were superb.
You are literally the first person I have ever heard say a good thing about the League of Extraordinary Gentlemen movie, and something bad about the Watchmen comic.
 
To me, the SciFi Dune mini series of Dune and then Children of Dune (which was technically Dune Messiah and CoD) were the ultimate Dune adaptations. I honestly don't think they could be adapted better. I mean, I'm not against other attempts, but as far as I'm concerned we've already gotten near perfect adaptations of the first few books.

On CoD, I have to say, it was like the first three quarters of the mini-series were really, really close to the novels, while the finale was something completely different.

I can't really remember if the ending of CoD was different, I need to watch that one again (I have Dune but not CoD, the DVD is extremely expensive :wtf: ). I did like the changes I do remember in CoD, though. Having Leto and his sister be older was good, I don't think hiring age appropriate kids (I think they're maybe 9-12 in the book?) would have worked better, and James McAvoy was great.
 

Yeah, but it isn't a sequel or follow-on to the first one, which is disheartening.

I hated Watchmen (film and comic) and the LXG comic. They were cynical, dystopian garbage.

LXG the movie was really good. I liked the "boy's own adventure" motif and the performances were superb.
You are literally the first person I have ever heard say a good thing about the League of Extraordinary Gentlemen movie, and something bad about the Watchmen comic.


I happened to really like the LXG movie too despite its flaws.
 
Harry Harrison's The Stainless Steel Rat
Anne McCaffrey's Pern
Kim Stanley Robinson's Mars Trilogy
Michael Moorcock's Elric of Melnibone / Corum / Hawkmoon / Jhary-a-Conel / Eternal Champion
Larry Niven's Ringworld / Known Space
Alastair Reynolds Revelation Space


I hated Watchmen (film and comic) and the LXG comic. They were cynical, dystopian garbage.

LXG the movie was really good.

Words fail me. I've got nothing...
 

Yeah, but it isn't a sequel or follow-on to the first one, which is disheartening.

I hated Watchmen (film and comic) and the LXG comic. They were cynical, dystopian garbage.

LXG the movie was really good. I liked the "boy's own adventure" motif and the performances were superb.
You are literally the first person I have ever heard say a good thing about the League of Extraordinary Gentlemen movie, and something bad about the Watchmen comic.

Forgive me if I don't find projects that make a major plot point about a superhero who can't "perform" unless he's wearing his costume compelling material.

Or one character raping another to death.
 
Yeah, but it isn't a sequel or follow-on to the first one, which is disheartening.

I hated Watchmen (film and comic) and the LXG comic. They were cynical, dystopian garbage.

LXG the movie was really good. I liked the "boy's own adventure" motif and the performances were superb.
You are literally the first person I have ever heard say a good thing about the League of Extraordinary Gentlemen movie, and something bad about the Watchmen comic.

Forgive me if I don't find projects that make a major plot point about a superhero who can't "perform" unless he's wearing his costume compelling material.

It had something to say about confidence, self image and feeling less than useful. And it was hardly a major plot point. It was an 'aside'.
 
Yeah, but it isn't a sequel or follow-on to the first one, which is disheartening.

I hated Watchmen (film and comic) and the LXG comic. They were cynical, dystopian garbage.

LXG the movie was really good. I liked the "boy's own adventure" motif and the performances were superb.
You are literally the first person I have ever heard say a good thing about the League of Extraordinary Gentlemen movie, and something bad about the Watchmen comic.

Forgive me if I don't find projects that make a major plot point about a superhero who can't "perform" unless he's wearing his costume compelling material.

Or one character raping another to death.

Not every story has to be uplifting and inspirational. Darker stories and themes are also worthy of exploration.

Sometimes you want Frank Capra or George Lucas. Other times you want Alfred Hitchcock or David Lynch . . . .
 
I've been waiting for a SPECTRE movie (based on the ghostly DC comic book hero) for years now . ...

Although I suppose the title of the new Bond movie complicates matters.
 
If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

Sign up / Register


Back
Top