(And I actually thought a RoboCop reboot made perfect sense, since the themes and issues raised by the concept are even more relevant today than they were in the '80s. I was disappointed in the result, because it only paid lip service to those themes, but in principle it was worth doing.)
I don't disagree at all actually Christopher. It was the realisation that ultimately killed it for me. I would say that I was pretty hesitant but I had an 'open mind' about it, right up until I saw the final result and I was just like, "Nah, not for me thanks".
There are some franchises that I just think of as being sacrosanct (I don't begrude other people wanting to see them reimagined though, I just think personally I couldn't bring myself to invest in them). If they remade BTTF or something for example, that'd be one where I just couldn't bring myself to watch it, even if I heard only good things about it.
In principal I agree there are places to go with a non-reboot of Indy, but if it came down to restarting the franchise from scratch, then I'm afraid like the BTTF example I cite above, it's another one I'd just be like, "Thanks, but no thanks".
(I'm not against tributes/continuations/adaptations of something like BTTF, I *loved* the Adventure Games and the animated series, but something that basically reworks the franchise into something modern and does that 'Year Zero' type stuff would be a step too far for me. I kind of feel like that about Indiana Jones, even though weirdly I'm 100% okay with something like Doctor Who or Star Trek being given the reboot treatment...)
Give me Indy 5 first while Harrison has still got it in him.
Have it be a passing of the torch to a new character.
That's..... kind of what 'Crystal Skull' was supposed to be.
They backed the wrong horse by casting Shia LeBouf as the new generation IMO, but the principal of the thing was there.
