Your 'Not Only is it Not A Guilty Pleasure' movie/episode

[TheSubCommander]

Movies
TMP
Generations
Insurrection
Nemesis

TOS Episodes
Alternative Factor
I, Mudd
Spectre of the Gun
Savage Curtain

TNG Episodes
Naked Now
The Battle
Time Squared
Masks
Hero Worship

DS9 Episodes
Sons of Mogh
A Simple Investigation
Empok Nor
It's only a paper moon

Voyager Episodes
Prototype
Warlord
Mortal Coil
Thirty Days
Timeless

Enterprise episodes
Acquisition
Impulse
Bounty
Carbon Creek

 

[Amaris]

I think Wesley would have been a better character if they had let Wil rework his dialogue to sound like a real teenager. His performances were always good, they just gave him some awful $h!t to say.

Agreed. I particularly like episodes where Wil's personality shone through, even for brief moments, and Wesley was genuinely human/normal. The dialogue, though, just hokey as hell, and it wasn't right, and isn't right, to saddle Wheaton with that to bear.

 

[Timelord79 (he/him)]

Search For Spock. Am I the only person who thinks this movie is pretty good, and a worthy follow up to TWOK?

SFS has always been one of my favorite TOS Films. I was shocked when I first heard people saying that it was one of the "bad Trek films" I'm also surprised when people complain about them undoing Spock's death, because when I saw TWOK when I was 9 I came out of the theater with several theories on how he would return in ST III. I never had a doubt that he would be back.

SFS seems to me to be the flip side of the Menagerie, with Kirk and Crew doing whatever they can and possibly sacrificing everything for Spock, just as he was willing to risk everything to help Captain Pike.

For the longest time I didn't like SFS very much.
Then I saw the original undubbed version.
The German dubbing is sooo bad, not to speak of the translated Klingon, which killed the whole ending.

In the original all the really good acting came finally through.

The biggest problem of that movie is the low budget Nimoy had to work with and the cheap soundstages which really made it look like an overlong TV episode.

Imagine the same story with suitable location shooting and enhanced CGI surroundings for large scale Genesis landscapes to make it look like the exotic strange world it was supposed to be.