Ah, good choice! I was there only once, but I loved it. For different reasons than you. Sounds like a great trip! My problem with the concept of "I have already had my dream vacation" is that each dream vacation leaves me craving another.
Still working on it; the defining aspect would be length. I don't want to be rushing around trying to fit too much into a few days like I usually do. My fiance. One that included several days in London, Italy and the Maldives. Although the one that included several days in Bora Bora, the Cook Islands, and Aukland was tough competition.
You'll get them! I've found the perfect place.... Awesome crab cakes (awesome seafood in general), water view, and not touristy.