• Welcome! The TrekBBS is the number one place to chat about Star Trek with like-minded fans.
    If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

Yesterday

Without the Beatles, pop music would have never gotten trippy and philosophical.

But record companies would have eventually figured out how to put hot people on an autotuner and sing about partying and sex. Pop music in 2021 would be the same, just actual good music would have diverged from popular music much earlier.
Hard to say conclusively Bob Dylan and Brian Wilson might not have moved things in that direction regardless. Both influenced the Beatles as well as being influenced by them.
 
Hard to say conclusively Bob Dylan and Brian Wilson might not have moved things in that direction regardless. Both influenced the Beatles as well as being influenced by them.

True but Bob Dylan was always pretty nichey even at his most popular, before his accident he was seen as a provocateur. And before the Beatles raised the bar for pop music The Beach Boys were singing catchy singles about surfing and girls.

One thing that might not have happened the same way without the Beatles is the album era. Before the Beatles albums were treated as dumping grounds for B material. Even the Beatles didn’t put their singles on the albums until late.
 
True but Bob Dylan was always pretty nichey even at his most popular, before his accident he was seen as a provocateur. And before the Beatles raised the bar for pop music The Beach Boys were singing catchy singles about surfing and girls.

One thing that might not have happened the same way without the Beatles is the album era. Before the Beatles albums were treated as dumping grounds for B material. Even the Beatles didn’t put their singles on the albums until late.
There was a back and forth going on between the Beatles and the Beach Boys. (And many other acts including Dylan)
Rubber Soul has a country-folk flavor that comes from The Beatles meeting Dylan and listen to country when touring America. Pet Sounds by the Beach Boys is a "response" to Rubber Soul. Pet Sounds in turn influence the development of Sgt. Pepper.
 
Without the Beatles, there might never have been a Rolling Stones. It was the Beatles who convinced the Stones to write their own material rather than just doing Blues covers. Paul even wrote some early songs for them. Post-Beatles, all of the members had a huge direct influence on a great number of musicians--moving their music in different directions. Without the Beatles, it is likely that Ed Sheeren would never have written the songs he has and he would never have been in a movie called Yesterday.
 
There was a back and forth going on between the Beatles and the Beach Boys. (And many other acts including Dylan)
Rubber Soul has a country-folk flavor that comes from The Beatles meeting Dylan and listen to country when touring America. Pet Sounds by the Beach Boys is a "response" to Rubber Soul. Pet Sounds in turn influence the development of Sgt. Pepper.

There certainly was a lot of stoking of the fire. I think it's safe to say that without those two, the music would would have been very different.

Without the Beatles, there might never have been a Rolling Stones. It was the Beatles who convinced the Stones to write their own material rather than just doing Blues covers. Paul even wrote some early songs for them.

Yeah, wasn't 'I Wanna Hold Your Hand' originally meant for the Stones? There was something I know they had turned down and the Beatles ended up doing it anyway.
 
There certainly was a lot of stoking of the fire. I think it's safe to say that without those two, the music would would have been very different.



Yeah, wasn't 'I Wanna Hold Your Hand' originally meant for the Stones? There was something I know they had turned down and the Beatles ended up doing it anyway.
"I Wanna Be Your Man"
 
If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

Sign up / Register


Back
Top