• Welcome! The TrekBBS is the number one place to chat about Star Trek with like-minded fans.
    If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

XBox or Wii?

I'd recommend getting the Wii MotionPlus in any case, as the addition of the second gyro finally gives you 1:1 response, though currently it won't offer enhanced control for most games (though I strongly suspect that they'll EVENTUALLY make the next logical step and offer the required patches to interpret the additional movement data for use in games developed and released before Wii Sports Resort, because all the MotionPlus does is provide an additional stream of movement data for the game to interpret.)
It's not possible to patch Wii games, whenever they have a major glitch they've had to issue new disks. It's unfortunate, but it's the way the operating system was designed.

I've relented in getting a new system since getting the first Xbox, and I've avoided the Wii like the plague specifically because of how fucking terrible the Wiimote is. I've played Wii Fit and several other games with it at a friend's house, and I wasn't at all charmed by the fact that the only moves the Wiimote responds to are nothing like what you would do (or expect) in real life.

For example, in WiiBowling, the game responds in the same manner if you try to bowl normally of if you "granny bowl" (i.e. chuck the ball from between your legs like a dumbass.) Cooking Mama is the perfect game for developing carpal tunnel syndrome. Zelda seemed to work as well as any prior incarnations I've tried, though all I really could do with the controller was aim and tell him when to fire. Honestly, I didn't see how much better the Wiimote was for a game like Zelda.
The real problem is the Wiimote can only detect strait line movements. Because of that it comes down to how well individual developers implement motion controls. For example I felt No More Heroes implement motion controls very well, normal attacks used buttons but finishing moves, where you decapitate someone or cut them in half, used motion controls. An arrow showed you which direction to slash and it worked just fine 99% of the time.

Of course the pointer is awesome, much better for shooters then duel analog (though not as good as a keyboard and mouse of course). Games like Resident Evil 4 and Metroid Prime 1/2 control much better then their Gamecube counterparts.

From my experience, the original Wiimote is just the next-gen version of the PowerGlove; the PowerPimpstick. I'd love to try out how well the Wii MotionPlus performs, but I'm convinced of it's performance just from reviews, and because the addition of a second data stream is something that any moron who passed fucking high-school algebra would have figured out long before the Wii's concept stage.

Yes, I had a terrible time with the Wii. :lol:
Actually they did originally consider including a gyroscope in the Wiimote, but at the time they were too big and too expensive. Only recently did they become small enough and cheap enough.
 
Nothing, because such a system obviously isn't fresh at all. But then I never said such a system would be. I said what I said while under the impression that they actually send you a fresh, new console. If I'm wrong, then I stand corrected.

Nope, where do you think all those consoles they repair go? The turnaround is somewhat quick because they send you a console they've already repaired, and once they fix your console, someone else will be getting it. For all I know, the 360 Pro I have could've been sent in by someone on this very board, and someone here has mine.

Well, I stand corrected then. Thanks for correcting me.

Well it's not guaranteed that you'll get someone elses. My brother in law got the same system back, scratches and all.

You can fix the rrod with about 15 bucks worth of parts and some elbow grease. I fixed mine about a year ago and its still going strong.
 
Nope, where do you think all those consoles they repair go? The turnaround is somewhat quick because they send you a console they've already repaired, and once they fix your console, someone else will be getting it. For all I know, the 360 Pro I have could've been sent in by someone on this very board, and someone here has mine.

Well, I stand corrected then. Thanks for correcting me.

Well it's not guaranteed that you'll get someone elses. My brother in law got the same system back, scratches and all.

Ah, I see.

You can fix the rrod with about 15 bucks worth of parts and some elbow grease. I fixed mine about a year ago and its still going strong.

True, one could do that. But it cost absolutely nothing the way I did it. Plus I got a free month of LIVE.
 
Nope, where do you think all those consoles they repair go? The turnaround is somewhat quick because they send you a console they've already repaired, and once they fix your console, someone else will be getting it. For all I know, the 360 Pro I have could've been sent in by someone on this very board, and someone here has mine.

Well, I stand corrected then. Thanks for correcting me.

Well it's not guaranteed that you'll get someone elses. My brother in law got the same system back, scratches and all.

You can fix the rrod with about 15 bucks worth of parts and some elbow grease. I fixed mine about a year ago and its still going strong.
Indeed, I got my console back as well (sent it in during the spring of 2008)
 
If you like keeping your console, I suggest a PS3, or a Wii. Four letters. RROD. The consoles' failure rate is staggering! I've had my Wii since 2007, and use it regularly. No problems whatsoever. I played Zelda Twilight Princess for almost 6 hours in one sitting, and had no issues. I plan on getting a PS3 next. That is definately the safest next-gen system to get. XBox has great exclusves, but I don't want to pay $249-$299 on a console that might not work when I want to play after work.

QFT... mostly...

The PS3 has had a few issues but, it's also been redesigned. It should be fine now.

I would go with the Wii, myself. Nintendo consoles take about as much abuse as a Auto-Wrecker and have much more kid-friendly titles.
 
If you haven't picked up a Wii yet, there's an unconfirmed rumor floating around that it's going to be $200 in the 9/27 Toys R Us ad, which may signify a price drop to counter the 360 and PS3 price drops if true.
 
If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

Sign up / Register


Back
Top