• Welcome! The TrekBBS is the number one place to chat about Star Trek with like-minded fans.
    If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

WTF? Is Gillian Anderson British?

Christian Bale switches his Welsh accent to an American one a lot of the time when doing press, especially for the Bat flicks where he admitted to doing it as 'no one wants to hear a Welsh Batman'.

I'd like to hear him do his "Batman voice" with a Welsh accent.
 
I definitely think it's possible to have different accents and switch back and forth depending on the occasion. Even within my own family, my father normally had a thick Southern drawl but he would adopt a more neutral accent whenever when he was at work or conducting business over the phone. He indeed called it his "business voice".
 
Because, in my opinion it seems strange to take on an accent after a certain age. I talked about it more in my other posts.
 
Because, in my opinion it seems strange to take on an accent after a certain age. I talked about it more in my other posts.
But if she had the accent as a child wouldn't she just be reverting to it? Or maybe she never lost it and took on a American one to fit in and get jobs.
 
Because, in my opinion it seems strange to take on an accent after a certain age. I talked about it more in my other posts.

It just happens. I doubt she does it consciously. My mom is originally from Pittsburg, and as soon as she starts talking on the phone to her family, by the end of the conversation you can start to hear the Pittsburg accent coming back through. I even adapt that accent if I visit them for a day or two. I don't do it on purpose; it just happens.
 
Because, in my opinion it seems strange to take on an accent after a certain age. I talked about it more in my other posts.
Your opinion is, of course, just that. It's also not supported by any concrete evidence.

Plenty of people's accents wander, depending on who they talk to or where they are. It happens to kme as well. As others have pointed out, contrary to your opinion, everyone is different. A wandering accent is no indiction of phoniness, weak-mindedness, or anything else derogatory.
 
Because, in my opinion it seems strange to take on an accent after a certain age. I talked about it more in my other posts.
Your opinion is, of course, just that. It's also not supported by any concrete evidence.

Plenty of people's accents wander, depending on who they talk to or where they are. It happens to kme as well. As others have pointed out, contrary to your opinion, everyone is different. A wandering accent is no indiction of phoniness, weak-mindedness, or anything else derogatory.

True. On the contrary, a wandering accent I feel is also a sign of someone who has had broad horizons, a wide selection of experiences from which to draw, and has lived an eventful and cosmopolitan life so far.
 
or a gift for mimickry. i know a girl who does a really good Aussie accent and she could do that before she went there. when she came back, it was better still...
 
i was just about to mention JB. he pulled the accent switch on BBC Breakfast as well when he was on talking Torchwood. Sian Williams the presenter went all gooey over the Scots accent...

Christian Bale switches his Welsh accent to an American one a lot of the time when doing press, especially for the Bat flicks where he admitted to doing it as 'no one wants to hear a Welsh Batman'.

Odd that you'd say that, considering that Bale has made it clear in interviews that while he was born in Wales, he is not Welsh. He's English.
 
The switch is definitely better than the mix though. I grew up in Canada so I have the Canadian accent. My brother spent his first 10 years in Wales, then 10 here in Canada, and now another 10 in London. The "Souf-East London" part comes through, the Canadian and the Welsh are all there. No matter where he is he sounds like he's from somewhere else.

I'd take the dual accent thing anytime.
 
I doubt it's a case of "fake" or not. Some people adapt to a local accent really, really quickly, esp. if they're used to doing so or are particularly good social chameleons. Personally, I'm not particularly fast, but even my own accent undergoes small changes (esp. tone and inflection) after a few weeks in a different country.

I pay good money to hear what you sound like after a couple of weeks in Glasgow.
 
I doubt it's a case of "fake" or not. Some people adapt to a local accent really, really quickly, esp. if they're used to doing so or are particularly good social chameleons. Personally, I'm not particularly fast, but even my own accent undergoes small changes (esp. tone and inflection) after a few weeks in a different country.

I pay good money to hear what you sound like after a couple of weeks in Glasgow.

[whimpering] "let me go home... for the love of God, let me go home..." [/whimpering]

:D
 
I grew up in Detroit but moved down to Tennessee at age 11 and now live in Ohio. The other kids made fun of my speech at first but I don't remember anyone ever really batting an eye after a few years. So my accent must have adapted slightly. In fact, when I talk to relatives who still live in Detroit, it's startling to hear their Northernish accent which is kind of like a softer version of a Chicago accent.

I did spend almost two weeks in Ireland and I found myself developing a slight brogue over there. I was out drinking with some locals and I did an impression of an Irishman talking like an American which had them all on the floor. Although, I did steal it from the office scene from Meaning of Life.
 
I start picking up an accent after being on the phone with someone for a few minutes. Sometimes it's hard to keep it down and there's been a couple times I inadvertently offended people who thought I was mocking them. I'm nearly 50 years old. Dunno what I'd sound like if I spent a week or two somewhere where everyone had an accent.

Also, I don't know if it's a hard accent or not but after watching about a billion hours of Beatles interviews, I spent some time chatting with a friend who came from London and she said I sounded like a "dead-on scouser" when I did the dialect for her. She then went into some kind of grumbling Scottish thing of which I dinna unnerstan' a single werd!"

Trust me, age is NOT a factor against picking accents for some people.
 
If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

Sign up / Register


Back
Top