• Welcome! The TrekBBS is the number one place to chat about Star Trek with like-minded fans.
    If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

Would Voq/Tyler still have a Klingon lifespan and live till the 24th/25h century?

He can't have gone through the same process as Voq, as in "Trouble with Tribbles" we see McCoy scan Darvin and immediately know that he's a Klilngon. OTOH, when Tyler/Voq was on the Discovery, all medical scans showed he was human.
While I do agree with you, one of the writers actually tried to say on After Trek that Darvin did undergo the same process as Voq Tyler. Which makes no damn sense, both for the reasons you state and presumably a drastic surgical overhaul by a race which doesn't value medical science should result in health complications that wouldn't make living to 100 possible, let alone well passed it. And then, why would any intelligence agency subject their operatives to an irreversible procedure? You're basically guaranteeing you can only use your operatives once and only once.
the answer to that very difficult riddle is: Passage of time!
Voq turned into Ash -> The Federation doesn't find out -> The Federation finds out -> The Federation now has data about that process - The Federation uses that data about a decade later on Darvin

I really don't see the problem here
Thing is, the red flags McCoy noticed with Darvin were irregular heartbeat and blood pressure, which he detected with one wave of the tricorder and based on that, immediately surmised Darvin was a Klingon. Tyler was in Disco's sickbay and presumably had a full work-up done after he was rescued. That would mean Culber overlooked Tyler's irregular heartbeat and blood pressure. In fact he would have done it twice, since we see Tyler being looked after in sickbay again after the away mission he went on with Michael and Saru. Culber only started to detect a hint of something after Tyler begged him to, and that's his third known time being scanned by one of Starfleet's most advanced medical computers.
Wow, now I feel a bit ashamed for being anxious about turning 30 this November.
Meh, don't feel bad. The entire year I was 29 I basically lived in a state of constant fear of the looming three oh. Then I hit 30 and I realized it wasn't so bad after all. Now I'm approaching 34 and I got health issues cropping up that are making me realize my youth is behind me. Nothing life threatening, and it is easily medicated (a vitamin deficiency) but it's not doing my mental health any favours.
 
...by a race which doesn't value medical science

But we now learn (if we didn't previously already) that this is a stereotype: Klingons come in all colors, and some have advanced technologies Earth or the UFP can only dream of, including medical ones. Tyloq himself was ignorant of the potential of nanotech possessed by House Kor in "Point of Light"...

And then, why would any intelligence agency subject their operatives to an irreversible procedure? You're basically guaranteeing you can only use your operatives once and only once.

Wouldn't this be optimal in many cases? It saves you the trouble of killing the operative afterwards.

Timo Saloniemi
 
Well, given evidence of Darvin, then the answer is Yes, Klingons live past 150 easily, so He would make 2365. now 2399? might be a bit of a stretch..
 
Thing is, the red flags McCoy noticed with Darvin were irregular heartbeat and blood pressure, which he detected with one wave of the tricorder and based on that, immediately surmised Darvin was a Klingon.


Really? That seems a bit thin.
 
It's a TV show that needed a quick reveal and solution to the problem of the week.
Well, we don't actually know what McCoy saw in the tricorder. He started with heartbeat all wrong and temperature, and then he stopped. He saw something horrifying and said "This man is a Klingon".

Maybe Starfleet tricorders updated since Discovery to identify the ghastly organ transplants etc. that go into these transformations, and McCoy decided to spare Kirk the gory details.
 
Well, we don't actually know what McCoy saw in the tricorder. He started with heartbeat all wrong and temperature, and then he stopped. He saw something horrifying and said "This man is a Klingon".

Maybe Starfleet tricorders updated since Discovery to identify the ghastly organ transplants etc. that go into these transformations, and McCoy decided to spare Kirk the gory details.
An extra penis?
 
It just occurred to me that the last time we saw a Klingon turned into a human, Arne Darvin still maintained a Klingon lifespan and easily lived until Deep Space 9. Would Voq turn out the same way? Or was his lifespan reduced to a human's to fool sensors? I don't think this was ever discussed.

In this scenario, it's entirely plausible that Tyler/Voq would be around in the TNG era, or could even show up in the Picard show. They might have to age up Shazad with makeup or get an older actor to portray him though.

What, exactly, is a "Klingon lifespan" Because Darvin was alive at the time of TOS and later in the 24th Century? So was McCoy. Humans also routinely live decades above 100.
 
What, exactly, is a "Klingon lifespan" Because Darvin was alive at the time of TOS and later in the 24th Century? So was McCoy. Humans also routinely live decades above 100.
We also saw Kor, Kang and Koloth. And I guess the Albino.
 
He just trimmed his eyebrows and shaved.
Well, TOS Klingons had a slight greenish tinge to the makeup (at least the darker versions such as in Errand of Mercy). So something would have to be done about that as well.

Kor
 
Well, TOS Klingons had a slight greenish tinge to the makeup (at least the darker versions such as in Errand of Mercy). So something would have to be done about that as well.

Kor
Considering all the Klingon designs we've seen over 50 years, greenish tinges seem the least of our worries. I mean, we now know from L'Rell that Klingons can change the shape of their heads. :klingon:
 
Well, TOS Klingons had a slight greenish tinge to the makeup (at least the darker versions such as in Errand of Mercy). So something would have to be done about that as well.

Kor
He's from House Koloth, who look like pale hipsters.
Yc0Q88b.jpg
 
I vaguely remember that before the TOS Klingon trio came back in DS9, fandom had this idea that Klingons actually had shorter lifespans than humans. I could be remembering wrong, though.

Kor
 
If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

Sign up / Register


Back
Top