Worst Re-Casting Imagineable

[Captain Robert April]

I'm surprised you didn't suggest Gary Sinise as McCoy, because he bears a stronger facial and vocal resemblance to DeForest Kelley than any actor around today. There was even talk about him being considered for McCoy in the Abrams movie (though maybe that was just fan wishful thinking), but the filmmakers chose to go younger.

Because that would be a case of good recasting.

 

[Nerys Myk]

I'm surprised you didn't suggest Gary Sinise as McCoy, because he bears a stronger facial and vocal resemblance to DeForest Kelley than any actor around today. There was even talk about him being considered for McCoy in the Abrams movie (though maybe that was just fan wishful thinking), but the filmmakers chose to go younger.

Because that would be a case of good recasting.

Sinise was on a list Sela would love to see in the roles.

 

[Anji]

I would PAY to see/hear Queen Latifah say "hailing frequencies open".

Latifah as Uhura would be awesome. Heck, I'd actually go SEE the new Star Trek reboot if she had the part.

 

[Disruptor]

Kirk: Orlando Bloom
Spock: Keanu Reeves
McCoy: Charlie Sheen
Scotty: Larry the Cable Guy
Uhura: Tyler Perry as Madea
Chekov: Channing Tatum
Sulu: Gedde Watanabe
Pike: Gary Busey

 

[Isis]

I would PAY to see/hear Queen Latifah say "hailing frequencies open".

Latifah as Uhura would be awesome. Heck, I'd actually go SEE the new Star Trek reboot if she had the part.

I agree!

 

[gomtuu20]

Kirk: Cemil Sahbaz
Spock: Erol Amaç
McCoy: Ferdi Merter
Scotty: Yilmaz Sahin
Uhura: Füsun Olgaç
Rand: Elif Pektas

[yt]http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=utqnLoDfG3Y[/yt]

What in the world am I watching?

 

[Phoenicianknight]

Trek Hispano:


Kirk: Eric Estrada
Spock: Andy Garcia
McCoy: Jimmy Smits
Scotty: Edgar James Olmos
Sulu: Mario Lopez
Checkov: Wilmer Valderamma
Uhura: Salma Hayeck
Nurse Chapel: Sofia Vergara

 

[ToddPence]

Sulu:Jonathan Harris

This would be especially bad in light of the fact that Harris has been dead for several years.

 

[FormerLurker]

So is John Candy.

 

[Bixby]

Trek Hispano:


Kirk: Eric Estrada
Spock: Andy Garcia
McCoy: Jimmy Smits
Scotty: Edgar James Olmos
Sulu: Mario Lopez
Checkov: Wilmer Valderamma
Uhura: Salma Hayeck
Nurse Chapel: Sofia Vergara

I like this idea!! How about Blaxploitation Trek?

Kirk: Yaphett Kotto
Spock: Isaac Hayes
McCoy: Bill Cosby
Scotty: Rudy Ray Moore (Dolemite)
Sulu: Jim Kelly
Checkov: Ted Lange
Uhura: Pam Grier
Koloth: Antonio Fargas
Kang : Richard Roundtree (Shaft)
Dr Daystrom: William Marshall
Harry Mudd: Scatman Crothers
Andrea the Android: Vonetta McGee
Gary Seven: Billy dee Williams
Khan: Ron O'neal (Superfly)