• Welcome! The TrekBBS is the number one place to chat about Star Trek with like-minded fans.
    If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

Why was Sulu played off as a normal person but Chekov as a caricature?

Re: Why was Sulu played off as a normal person but Chekov as a caricat

But then, it also says Spock's "other" name is Xtmprszntwlfd. :wtf:
That's been around for decades as well. The people who write the Valjiir Continuum stories (see my sig) decided to use it as the clan name for Spock's family.

Thus, Amanda's line in "Journey to Babel" and the conversation Spock has with Leila Kalomi in "This Side of Paradise" about Spock's family name being unpronounceable are not unreasonable at all. ;)
 
Re: Why was Sulu played off as a normal person but Chekov as a caricat

Thus, Amanda's line in "Journey to Babel" and the conversation Spock has with Leila Kalomi in "This Side of Paradise" about Spock's family name being unpronounceable are not unreasonable at all. ;)

Totally pronounceable! Let's do this:

Xtm

Shtim

prszn

pir-szin

Eastern European consonant clusters, holla! But now it gets tricky:

twl

tul-

(Sort of Welsh Gaelic-ish)

fd

-fud.

(And there again.)

So, Shtimpirszintulfud. No problem. :techman:

Ye Gods, for the delightfully bonkers days when you could just throw any old consonants together and have an Alien Name.
 
Re: Why was Sulu played off as a normal person but Chekov as a caricat

^Now trick him into saying it backwards.
 
Re: Why was Sulu played off as a normal person but Chekov as a caricat

With the "you couldn't pronounce it" business, I always imagined Spock's first name was similar to Superman's pain in the ass, Mr. Mxyzptlk.
 
Re: Why was Sulu played off as a normal person but Chekov as a caricat

Thus, Amanda's line in "Journey to Babel" and the conversation Spock has with Leila Kalomi in "This Side of Paradise" about Spock's family name being unpronounceable are not unreasonable at all. ;)

Totally pronounceable! Let's do this:

Xtm

Shtim

prszn

pir-szin

Eastern European consonant clusters, holla! But now it gets tricky:

twl

tul-

(Sort of Welsh Gaelic-ish)

fd

-fud.

(And there again.)

So, Shtimpirszintulfud. No problem. :techman:

Ye Gods, for the delightfully bonkers days when you could just throw any old consonants together and have an Alien Name.
How do we know Vulcans don't pronounce their "X"s like zeds, or "k" or... "x"?
 
Re: Why was Sulu played off as a normal person but Chekov as a caricat

Thus, Amanda's line in "Journey to Babel" and the conversation Spock has with Leila Kalomi in "This Side of Paradise" about Spock's family name being unpronounceable are not unreasonable at all. ;)

Totally pronounceable! Let's do this:

Xtm

Shtim

prszn

pir-szin

Eastern European consonant clusters, holla! But now it gets tricky:

twl

tul-

(Sort of Welsh Gaelic-ish)

fd

-fud.

(And there again.)

So, Shtimpirszintulfud. No problem. :techman:

Ye Gods, for the delightfully bonkers days when you could just throw any old consonants together and have an Alien Name.
How do we know Vulcans don't pronounce their "X"s like zeds, or "k" or... "x"?
"Z", Vulcans use 'Merican pronunciation. ;)
 
Re: Why was Sulu played off as a normal person but Chekov as a caricat

Thanks to Harvey. Emphasis mine.

TO: All Concerned
FROM: Gene Roddenberry
DATE: 4-20-66
SUBJECT: Finalized STAR TREK Running Characters
...
SULU -- Ship’s helmsman, to be played by actor George Takei. You saw this same actor in the pilot as ship’s physicist. However, since that role was not too identified, we are moving Sulu up to the helmsman position where greater use of the character is expected. Although an Oriental, Sulu is contemporary American in speech and manner. His exact ancestry will probably never be indicated.
However, he does have something of a Japanese characterization in one thing -- his hobby of space-botany...
 
Re: Why was Sulu played off as a normal person but Chekov as a caricat

^ Thanks, Maurice. Good info.

About the motive for creating Chekov, I think the Davy Jones idea is the most reasonable. The Monkees originally aired on NBC beginning in the fall of 1966--a year before the introduction of Chekov in TOS season 2, so it seems Monkee-mania was so potent, NBC (and/or GR) desired that same kind of feel pushed into TOS (after watching the tone of season 1), in a way that would fit. He was not singing, or getting into romance of the week, but just his presence (character age factor, wig, etc.) had the potential to draw in younger, female viewers.


I guess we should be thankful Chekov wasn't given singing scenes like early Uhura was. Regarding the Monkees connection, here's a box item from Shatner's 1993 TV Guide article:

ChekovandDaveyJonesTVGuidescancp.jpg
 
Re: Why was Sulu played off as a normal person but Chekov as a caricat

Interesting posts. Thanks guys.

Best thing I learned is half of the Enterprise bridge crew is Russian Jewish in origin, even the alien :eek:
 
Re: Why was Sulu played off as a normal person but Chekov as a caricat

Interesting posts. Thanks guys.

Best thing I learned is half of the Enterprise bridge crew is Russian Jewish in origin, even the alien :eek:

Brent Spiner too, and all the Ferengi on DS9 (Shimmerman, Grodencik, Eisenberg, and Shawn). Not necessarily Russian, but they're all Ashkenazic Jews.
 
Re: Why was Sulu played off as a normal person but Chekov as a caricat

On a side note, and I realize that the show's famous for getting many distinguished Trek alumni, one reason why I dislike the Big Bang Theory is because Raj is often the target of just so much microaggression from other characters, and when he complains, they handwave it and dismiss it, as if his experiences don't really count (unless, of course, it's a Raj-centric episode).


I don't see that at all. Among the five core characters, I think every one of them receives microagression from all the others, and dishes it out in kind.

I meant racial microaggressions. Nobody among the other five makes fun of the other characters for being ethnically white; most sort of jabs at the others are about personality quirks, habits, and intelligence -- in essence, individual traits rather than stereotypes. And Jewish jokes tend to come from Howard when he's self-depricating (but has no problems adopting a South Asian accent to mock his best friend on occasion).

It's one reason why a few of my South Asian friends in the sciences won't watch the show -- they get enough of those "small" jokes and are told to get over it by their workmates in real life (again, the "It's No Big Deal" handwave); they don't want to watch it in their escapist fiction, either, especially when Raj doesn't call his friends out on it. Raj is a character with a heart of gold and with more career achievements than my friends have at this time, and yet even someone like him isn't immune to race jokes.

George Takei, a Japanese American actor, requested to not play a stereotype or caricature of a member of his own ethnicity.
Sulu was created to be "Pan-Asian" so that did play to Sulu not being ethnic Japanese ... until they killed that idea in the movies by giving the character a Japanese first name.

Since the name Sulu is a Filipino name, I'd really like to think he's, in some way, part-Filipino himself. But that's never really been confirmed anywhere in the canon, I think.
 
Re: Why was Sulu played off as a normal person but Chekov as a caricat

Interesting posts. Thanks guys.

Best thing I learned is half of the Enterprise bridge crew is Russian Jewish in origin, even the alien :eek:

Brent Spiner too, and all the Ferengi on DS9 (Shimmerman, Grodencik, Eisenberg, and Shawn). Not necessarily Russian, but they're all Ashkenazic Jews.
Ashkenazic is more appropriate than Russian, especially considering (if I remember well) since Ashkenazic originally designated Jews of Germany and Sepharadic Jews from (Muslim) Spain. Shatner's grand-parents from his father side were Austrians and Nimoy's parents were Ukrainian. Anyway, the vast majority of North-American Jews are Ashkenazic. ;)
 
Re: Why was Sulu played off as a normal person but Chekov as a caricat

From Generations:

Chekov: I was never that young.

Kirk: No..(smiling) you were younger.

That bit always gets me, as it turns out to be one of the last things that Kirk ever says to him. A really nice touch in an otherwise mediocre movie.
 
Re: Why was Sulu played off as a normal person but Chekov as a caricat

On a side note, and I realize that the show's famous for getting many distinguished Trek alumni, one reason why I dislike the Big Bang Theory is because Raj is often the target of just so much microaggression from other characters, and when he complains, they handwave it and dismiss it, as if his experiences don't really count (unless, of course, it's a Raj-centric episode).


I don't see that at all. Among the five core characters, I think every one of them receives microagression from all the others, and dishes it out in kind.

I meant racial microaggressions. Nobody among the other five makes fun of the other characters for being ethnically white; most sort of jabs at the others are about personality quirks, habits, and intelligence -- in essence, individual traits rather than stereotypes. And Jewish jokes tend to come from Howard when he's self-depricating (but has no problems adopting a South Asian accent to mock his best friend on occasion).

It's one reason why a few of my South Asian friends in the sciences won't watch the show -- they get enough of those "small" jokes and are told to get over it by their workmates in real life (again, the "It's No Big Deal" handwave); they don't want to watch it in their escapist fiction, either, especially when Raj doesn't call his friends out on it. Raj is a character with a heart of gold and with more career achievements than my friends have at this time, and yet even someone like him isn't immune to race jokes.

Raj makes fun of them for being white/american quite a lot... (it would be a bit strange for one white person to make fun of another white person for being white - kind of like a trekkie saying 'You like star trek! Loser!') He also rather reinforces the whole business by making fun of his culture himself on a regular basis. Which i can certainly understand that turning people off, in and of itself - I just really don't see this as a question of Raj being unduly 'attacked' and not standing up for himself (if that were applicable to anyone it would be Sheldon, who usually doesn't understand that people are making fun of him).
 
Re: Why was Sulu played off as a normal person but Chekov as a caricat

By the way, since season 3, stereotyped gags about Raj are more about gays and than Indians. All the four guys also try to escape from their own origins as Sheldon with the Texan conservatism or Leonard with the weird mentality of his family of scholars.
 
Re: Why was Sulu played off as a normal person but Chekov as a caricat

I blame Gene Coon.
 
Re: Why was Sulu played off as a normal person but Chekov as a caricat

Interesting posts. Thanks guys.

Best thing I learned is half of the Enterprise bridge crew is Russian Jewish in origin, even the alien :eek:

I agree....:):)
 
Re: Why was Sulu played off as a normal person but Chekov as a caricat

With all the information accumulated in this thread the following is understandable (hopefully):

Walter Koenig ("König" is "king" in German, BTW) was supposedly once asked at a convention about his personal, favorite episode.

His answer: "Mind War" (a "Babylon 5" episode featuring his B5 character Alfred Bester, the Psi Corps antagonist)

As you can imagine, that was most definitely not the answer the Star Trek convention visitors expected. :lol:

Bob
 
Re: Why was Sulu played off as a normal person but Chekov as a caricat

But Walter's best film roles were probably Checkov in Trek II and IV. He was a pivotal character in II (albeit largely a damsel in distress) and he had some of the best comic-relief in IV. There's no sin being used for comic relief, as long as it works, and it did.

most sort of jabs at the others are about personality quirks, habits, and intelligence -- in essence, individual traits rather than stereotypes.

All the characters on BBT are one big stereotype anyway--the nerd. (plus Penny as the bimbo).
 
If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

Sign up / Register


Back
Top