• Welcome! The TrekBBS is the number one place to chat about Star Trek with like-minded fans.
    If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

Why No Christma In Star Trek?

Who's to say really that Religion and religious holidays don't exist in ficticious future setting world, for all we know religion in it's many forms (and possibly more due to the introduction of alien cultures) do still exist on Earth in the 23rd and 24th century where people still go to church, abide by religious commandments and laws etc. Just because the 7-10 people we focus on during the run of each series don't make a mention of most of them or acknowledge them doesn't necessarily mean they don't exist. The average person in the background could, for all we know, be Jewish, Catholic, Protestant or whatever they may be but nobody really needs to know.

Sorry about the rant but it just seems that there's always a post on religion in Star Trek and almost all the time people start arguing about it. I just have to point out though that although I was raised Protestant and went to church with my parents I do not follow religion myself, just believe that it is there for a purpose.
Thank you! I have never understood why some sci-fi fans chose to totally ignore the belief systems of billions of people. Just because they personally hate those beliefs, they want them excluded from ALL science-fiction. I am proud of my beliefs and enjoy seeing them survive into the future. :vulcan:
 
Half the problem with Christmas trees in France is that since they found out they come from Germany, the French spend the whole season trying to surrender to the nearest tree...

OK, I'm sorry...

Don't apologize. Anyone who plays internet hearts knows which nationality is the first to quit. Anyway, I'm not complaining. It helps my winning %.
 
Who's to say really that Religion and religious holidays don't exist in ficticious future setting world, for all we know religion in it's many forms (and possibly more due to the introduction of alien cultures) do still exist on Earth in the 23rd and 24th century where people still go to church, abide by religious commandments and laws etc. Just because the 7-10 people we focus on during the run of each series don't make a mention of most of them or acknowledge them doesn't necessarily mean they don't exist. The average person in the background could, for all we know, be Jewish, Catholic, Protestant or whatever they may be but nobody really needs to know.

Sorry about the rant but it just seems that there's always a post on religion in Star Trek and almost all the time people start arguing about it. I just have to point out though that although I was raised Protestant and went to church with my parents I do not follow religion myself, just believe that it is there for a purpose.
Thank you! I have never understood why some sci-fi fans chose to totally ignore the belief systems of billions of people. Just because they personally hate those beliefs, they want them excluded from ALL science-fiction. I am proud of my beliefs and enjoy seeing them survive into the future. :vulcan:

Oh for fuck's sake.
As I said above, the idea, which Roddenberry inherited from better scifi writers, was to espouse a humanist philosophy. Back then scifi actually had something to say -- something a little more complex than "racism is bad!!" If you really want to address this issue you have to look at its source: the literary roots of the genre.
I don't know how so many people can watch something and miss so much of its subtext. Where's my spoon?
 
Who's to say really that Religion and religious holidays don't exist in ficticious future setting world, for all we know religion in it's many forms (and possibly more due to the introduction of alien cultures) do still exist on Earth in the 23rd and 24th century

It would seem that they do since the Hindu Festival of lights is mentioned in "Data's Day"
 
I personally like religion in Science Fiction. The idea that humans are all hyper-evolved humanists usually contributed to bad storylines... which is why DS9 made for the best trek with TNG a distant (but excellent) second.
 
If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

Sign up / Register


Back
Top