• Welcome! The TrekBBS is the number one place to chat about Star Trek with like-minded fans.
    If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

Why did they make Linda Park's character Japanese?

Status
Not open for further replies.
I'm not talking about a contiunation of the soldier model. I'm talking about Star Trek future model, where travel to any point on the globe is as simple as stepping on a transporter pad.

Under that kind of a vision, racial divisions will be erased.
I did include "immigrant".

Assuming that people in significant numbers will want to go to location X and will procreate.

Given enough time, they will.
Why? No one is going to move to a place without some sort of motivation, be it political, financial or some other reason.
 
A lot of other people can't either. My Japanese wife is constantly mistaken for Korean. When we walked down the street in Korea she was questioned constantly until she got into the habit of delcaring (in English), "I'm Japanese!" She always told me, "I have a Korean face" but I didn't really believe her until we spent a week vacationing in Seoul.
I got on a elevator once with a friend of mine who's of Japanese and Korean ancestry. A group of Japanese business men were also in the elevator and they started talking to her in Japanese. They not only thought she was 100% Japanese but was actually from Japan. (or at least well versed in the language) She had no clue what they were saying. Her family had pretty much down played anything Japanese or Korean when she was growing up. I had to teach her how to use chopsticks when we went out for Japanese food.
 
Honestly I think Hollywood should just be safe and call their Pan-Asian actors "Hawaiian." LOL I mean, Hawaii has a lot of Japanese and Chinese as well as actual Native Hawaiians. I've met a few girls from Hawaii and honestly some of them you couldn't tell if they were Chinese, Japanese, Korean, Islander or what. Partially because they had a little of all of 'em in their family tree somewhere. Grandma was native Hawaiian, grandpa was Japanese, they had a little hawaiian japanese kid that married a korean chinese kid. And so on.

In some sims that I write, I've used Asian actresses that I liked and then just said they had family that lived in hawaii and left it there. Then it saved me from trying to figure out if the actress is korean, chinese, japanese, or whatever. Now us white folk... you can be any thing LOL.
 
Hawaii IS geographically and culturally mid-point between east and west in many ways.

I vacationed there once and was thrilled to look just like everybody else. For once I was in the majority. Many people there tried to speak to me in different languages - I was a little ashamed I only spoke English. Very likely the only time I expect that to happen!
 
At least Mr. Sulu's ethnicity is correct, even though "Sulu" was some made up name our heroic 1960's whisky swilling TOS writers came up with. I guess WWII was still in their recent past and having a Japanese in a series would be unpopular. I remember as a kid in the 1980's and many Americans then were resentful to the Japanese for the war.

The character was named after the Sulu Sea

The Star Trek character Hikaru Sulu is named after the Sulu Sea. According to Sulu actor George Takei, Gene Roddenberry's vision for Sulu was to represent all of Asia, being named for the Sulu Sea instead of using a specific country-specific name
 
Here's another version of the origin of Sulu's name.

I'm reading Inside Star Trek by Herb Solow and Bob Justman. From the book:

Justman thought the character's name came from the Philippine Islands' Sulu archipelago, which bomber pilot Roddenberry knew about from his World War II experiences flying in the South Pacific. Actually, the name "Sulu" resulted from Roddenberry's deision to "honor" Herb Solow by using a mispronunciation of his name "without the w," a running joke between Solow and many of his friends.
 
Hello. My name is Bina and I just joined.
The thing about Hoshi Sato was that, to me, she seemed nothing more than an American of Asian descent. There was nothing about her, other than her exotic sounding name and her physical features, that was Japanese in any way."

BINA writes: DUKHAT, Hoshi was EXCEPTIONAL. She spoke I think 24 languages. How many languages do YOU speak? :) It was mentioned in one episode. It was 24 or 26. She mentioned in that one episode that she wanted to rely less on the Universal Translator as well.
And as much as I like Lt. Uhura (the Communications officer in TOS), I think Hoshi was better then her in the linguistics field. In Star Trek: The Undiscovered Country, Uhura was not able to speak Klingon. And Uhura was serving on the flagship of the Federation-Enterprise. It took time for Hoshi to really get her "space legs." But she did eventually.
 
At least Mr. Sulu's ethnicity is correct...

No, it isn't. As others have mentioned, Sulu was not specifically intended to be Japanese, but rather "pan-Asian." Sulu is the name of a region in the Philippines. At no time in any episode or film was Sulu ever called Japanese onscreen. Actors of various ethnicities tested for the role, including James Hong. The only reason fans assumed the character was Japanese was because Takei got the part (well, that and the samurai in "Shore Leave"). His given name Hikaru was chosen by novelist Vonda McIntyre in 1981 and only officially applied to the character in the sixth movie.

Of course, now Sulu is being played by Korean actor John Cho. So even if he had been "correct" before, he isn't now.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

Sign up / Register


Back
Top