• Welcome! The TrekBBS is the number one place to chat about Star Trek with like-minded fans.
    If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

Which Potential Guest Star Would Have Killed A ST Episode?

Wally Cox is in the very first episode of Mission: Impossible as a member of the team, playing a safecracker who has to be smuggled into a compound. He has one scene wearing an athletic shirt, and his arms were muscular. In real life, he was athletic, rode motorcycles, and was a qualified electrician, wiring his own house.

I'm not sure what the intent of this all is, if the object is to throw out names of people who were primarily known as comedians at the time. TOS generally cast actors with a history of theatrical work and 1950s dramatic television. Of all the guest actors, Frank Gorshin is the only one I can think of primarily known for comedy at the time, but he had done dramatic work. His showing up was when Freiberger was calling the shots anyway.

Here's some more ridiculous examples, since it seems to be what the thread's about-- Jim Nabors, Jerry Van Dyke, Milton Berle, Pinky Lee, Stanley Myron Handleman, the Smothers Brothers, Don Knotts, Avery Schreiber, etc.
 
Huh? I'm asking why Bette Davis would have "killed a ST episode" and explaining why she would be a good choice rather than a bad one.

Typecasting. Nobody would take it seriously...
Again I would ask why? Not sure Davis was known for playing sympathetic mothers like Amanda.

It might be distracting to have Davis pop up. "Hey, it's Bette Davis and she's Spock's mom!"

Right! That's exactly what I mean.
 
Typecasting. Nobody would take it seriously...
Again I would ask why? Not sure Davis was known for playing sympathetic mothers like Amanda.

It might be distracting to have Davis pop up. "Hey, it's Bette Davis and she's Spock's mom!"

Right! That's exactly what I mean.

When I saw Jane Wyatt show up in "Amok Time" during first run, my reaction was "Hey, it's the mom from Father Knows Best!"
 
Again I would ask why? Not sure Davis was known for playing sympathetic mothers like Amanda.

It might be distracting to have Davis pop up. "Hey, it's Bette Davis and she's Spock's mom!"

Right! That's exactly what I mean.

When I saw Jane Wyatt show up in "Amok Time" during first run, my reaction was "Hey, it's the mom from Father Knows Best!"
And Niles Baris was Patty Duke's dad and Dobie Gillis' teacher.
 
Yeah, I knew William Schallert as Mr. Pomfritt on Dobie Gillis. Just like I always remember Bob Denver as Maynard G. Krebs instead of Gilligan.
 
^Took me awhile to understand the thread. Besides, at first I read it wrong and thought it said "killed a ST character.
 
Here's some more ridiculous examples, since it seems to be what the thread's about-- Jim Nabors, Jerry Van Dyke, Milton Berle, Pinky Lee, Stanley Myron Handleman, the Smothers Brothers, Don Knotts, Avery Schreiber, etc.

Don Knotts could have been cast-against-type as the booming Guardian of Forever voice.

He could be pretty dramatic: "Your ship, your world, all that you knew has been nipped. Nipped in the bud!"
 
Don Knotts as Dr. Richard Daystrom.
DON KNOTTS: Colleagues. Colleagues laughing behind my back at the boy wonder and becoming famous building on my work. Building on my work.

MCCOY: Jim, he's on the edge of a nervous breakdown, if not insanity.

KIRK: The M-5 must be destroyed.

DON KNOTTS: Destroyed, Kirk? No. We're invincible. Look what we've done. Your mighty starships, Four toys to be crushed as we choose.
 
Here's some more ridiculous examples, since it seems to be what the thread's about-- Jim Nabors, Jerry Van Dyke, Milton Berle, Pinky Lee, Stanley Myron Handleman, the Smothers Brothers, Don Knotts, Avery Schreiber, etc.

Don Knotts could have been cast-against-type as the booming Guardian of Forever voice.

He could be pretty dramatic: "Your ship, your world, all that you knew has been nipped. Nipped in the bud!"

LMAO!

That was damn funny!
 
Here's some more ridiculous examples, since it seems to be what the thread's about-- Jim Nabors, Jerry Van Dyke, Milton Berle, Pinky Lee, Stanley Myron Handleman, the Smothers Brothers, Don Knotts, Avery Schreiber, etc.

Don Knotts could have been cast-against-type as the booming Guardian of Forever voice.

He could be pretty dramatic: "Your ship, your world, all that you knew has been nipped. Nipped in the bud!"

LMAO!

That was damn funny!

:lol: :guffaw:
 
If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

Sign up / Register


Back
Top