If the original NCC-1701 were completely decanonized from the TREK canon and lore and had the past two years' worth of Remastered TOS episodes not shown a simply more three-dimensional, detailed and dynamic version of the original Jefferies design I'd say the new movie ship fits extremely well into the starship lineages. But since the TOS Enterprise is still considered official and a pop culture icon there are problems.
I think mainly because the special effects were using models and not CGI. I guess the new movie is going back to that so it might win me over.

Maybe have Bob (who, thankfully, is still alive