• Welcome! The TrekBBS is the number one place to chat about Star Trek with like-minded fans.
    If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

Which Discovery loose ends bother you the most?

No sht. I mean I expected there to be SOMETHING. What we got was nothing.

IMHO this was the writing team telegraphing that they too thought the season was a steaming pile of shit, and just want is to mostly ignore what happened and move on.

Although I can say with some certainty that the spore drive will be used next season, even if they don't plan to now. It's too tempting of a plot device for the writers to avoid.
 
Yeah, the hell is the deal with the black badges? I wouldnt care but they made kind of a deal about them in episode 3, then nothing.
 
I think not, if I remember correctly. Been a long time since I was told the original season arc, but I think Lorca was always going to be prime Lorca. He was just going to be a morally questionable captain driven to desperation of tactics by war. I can't remember how, but they were going to end up in the mirror universe, but not because Lorca took them there. When they use the spore drive to jump back to the prime universe, it would have thrown them forward in time to post-Voyager era instead of just 9 months, where they would have been marooned.

The second season would then pick up with a post-Voyager era crew, and cut back and forth between Discovery's ongoings and the new crew, bringing the Discovery story to an end over 2-3 episodes, and handing off to the next crew. Then they would have had a new crew every season. CBS thought building sets, props, costumes etc for all these different crews/ships would have been crazy expensive, and since they didn't know if Season 1 would be successful, they told Bryan Fuller no and he didn't like that.

That would have been amazing
 
What do you want, Stamets to be crying in fetal position moaning "Huuuggghhhh!!!!"?

I think the Stamets vs. Ash/Voq scene and the fact that Stamets received Culber's medal of honor were more than just "barely acknowledgements."

We really haven't had much time this season since Culber's death to have an emotional scene with Stamets.
LOL. I don't want an emo scene with Stamets. I think a nice funeral service like they had for Spock or Tasha Yar would have been enough. It doesn't even have to be that long. Just a respectful goodbye.
 
Wow! Lets show a little patience, shall we? Its the end of season ONE!! We're still nine years away from Kirk era Trek. Plenty of time to figure out dangling questions like why no spore drive in the future. My guess? A tragic or enlightening event (take yer pick) sometime next season or even in 3 or 4 will render the drive inoperable. Probably some sentient form of spore will appear and prevent Starfleet and everyone else from using it for good. Outta sight outta mind as it were.
 
Wow! Lets show a little patience, shall we? Its the end of season ONE!! We're still nine years away from Kirk era Trek. Plenty of time to figure out dangling questions like why no spore drive in the future. My guess? A tragic or enlightening event (take yer pick) sometime next season or even in 3 or 4 will render the drive inoperable. Probably some sentient form of spore will appear and prevent Starfleet and everyone else from using it for good. Outta sight outta mind as it were.
If Wormhole's calculations are correct we're only months away from "The Cage". But there really is no way to reconcile Discovery with TOS, Discovery's timeline might as well be an alternate reality timeline like the Kelvin timeline. I really wished the writers had just made the decision to place it in an alternate timeline, saying it's Prime while introducing reboots of characters and technology just doesn't work.
 
Saru is officially First Officer, USS Discovery (and acting Captain). Burnham gave her speech in Command colors but took an assignment as Chief Science Officer, USS Discovery. So he is above her in the chain of command. Where each is grade-wise, in consideration for promotion to command of a different vessel is a different matter. I don't know how long Burnham was a commander on Shenzou or how her pre-mutuny record is appended with her discovery service. I don't know if Saru declined a promotion to Discovery Captain or other vessel captain (since serving as first officer to a capable captain is a big deal to him). Nor do I think such a thing will matter as Starfleet has losses right now exceeding BOBW from the Klingon war. Capable, battle experienced officers tend to have opportunity thrust upon them in times like Starfleet is facing.


Here's a brief list of the ones that left me hanging
Since Burnham got promoted to Commander, is she still outranked by Saru?
 
If Wormhole's calculations are correct we're only months away from "The Cage". But there really is no way to reconcile Discovery with TOS, Discovery's timeline might as well be an alternate reality timeline like the Kelvin timeline. I really wished the writers had just made the decision to place it in an alternate timeline, saying it's Prime while introducing reboots of characters and technology just doesn't work.

The events of The Cage happened in 2254; Discovery's events start in 2256, two years after The Cage.
 
If Wormhole's calculations are correct we're only months away from "The Cage".
I haven't seen Wormholes's calculations, but if they say, DISCO is only month away from The Cage, they aren't correct. The Cage happened two years before the start of DISCO
 
If Wormhole's calculations are correct
What the hell do you mean "If"? From The Vulcan Hello:
BURNHAM: First Officer's Log, Stardate 1207.3. On Earth, it's May 11, 2256, a Sunday.
Context is for Kings is six months later, as per the caption on the screen at the beginning, making it November 2256.
we're only months away from "The Cage".
As others have already pointed out, Disco is two years after The Cage.
 
What the hell do you mean "If"? From The Vulcan Hello:

Context is for Kings is six months later, as per the caption on the screen at the beginning, making it November 2256.

As others have already pointed out, Disco is two years after The Cage.
According to Anthony Rapp, Discovery takes place two years BEFORE The Cage.
 
If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

Sign up / Register


Back
Top