• Welcome! The TrekBBS is the number one place to chat about Star Trek with like-minded fans.
    If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

Which Discovery loose ends bother you the most?

According to Anthony Rapp, Discovery takes place two years BEFORE The Cage.
Then either he's wrong or you're misremembering. The Menagerie takes place in 2267, and in that episode it is stated in dialogue that The Cage was thirteen years prior, which would make it 2254. Disco is stated in dialogue to be in 2256 when it started. 2256 is two years after 2254. This is both canonically and mathematically legitimate.
 
And that's enough for you ?

The spore drive represents the greatest discovery ( intended pun or not ? you choose ) that Starfleet has ever made, blows warp drive out the water. The ability to travel literally anywhere in the universe instantly.
That could have been handy during the Borg attacks, or the Cardassian War, or the Dominion war, or Voyager getting home or any one of a thousand other instances.
Yet the explanation we get, and some are happy to accept, is that Starfleet stopped using it because they couldn't find a suitable replacement for a human interface.
This despite the fact that the human interface seemed perfectly fine at the end of season 1.

Guys, it's an absolute clusterfuck. We speculated on here for months as to how the writers were going to get themselves out of the Spore drive situation. I don't think anyone saw this one coming.

Actually they closed this loose end,but only by making another one.

The human interface only works because of a DNA modification drug - recall that Stamets injected himself with the experimental substance . Due to the Federations ban on genetic modification, this is technically illegal. So the science problem is figuring out how to navigate the network without using this approach.

Of course ,the loose end then is why Stamets isn’t in court for illegal genetic experimentation. While I doubt he’d be jailed, the Federations always looked unkindly at genetic experimentation and would insist on a hearing to justify Stamets actions.
 
Then either he's wrong or you're misremembering. The Menagerie takes place in 2267, and in that episode it is stated in dialogue that The Cage was thirteen years prior, which would make it 2254. Disco is stated in dialogue to be in 2256 when it started. 2256 is two years after 2254. This is both canonically and mathematically legitimate.
Like they wouldn't simply change the date of "The Cage" if it suited them.

I'm starting to wonder if the above is true, come season two, those rumours that Michael Burnham was the Number One might come true.
 
  • Like
Reactions: pst
I'm starting to wonder if the above is true, come season two, those rumours that Michael Burnham was the Number One might come true.

Wouldn't this mean that Discovery gets destroyed, because Burnham would have to become the first office under Pike?

Also, they'd probably have to figure out how to explain Number One and Spock having nothing to do with one another in The Cage. And why Spock was acting emotional (just a phase?)
 
super secret science projects get protected by super elite security guards with black badges, I don't see a loose end here.
Also, with all the freedom Lorca had running his ship, it is not hard to imagine he gave black badges to his crewmen just to look cool and mysterious
Unfortunately all of that is only head-canon.
 
I really feel like DSC would have been a lot better as Trek literature. Presenting DSC over what felt like a rushed 15 episodes really did a disservice to the franchise.
 
Because Fuller was booted in the middle of writing the 4th. The other writers didn't like his Klingon War arc, and ESPECIALLY didn't like his end season idea, but CBS execs were pressuring the show delivery big time because they'd already delayed twice. So they said "fuck it" and filmed the first 4 episodes with Fuller's scripts, and then over the season tried to slowly undo his story line so that in Season 2 they could take the show in a more light hearted and Trek-like direction.

oh, do we know of Fuller's ideas for DIS?
What happened in Fuller's finale?
 
super secret science projects get protected by super elite security guards with black badges, I don't see a loose end here.
It never was established just what the Black Badges were guarding. It clearly wasn't anything related to the Spore Drive, yet there also wasn't anything else important on the ship.
 
No idea if it was in the original plans but I feel like the black badges/floating water/hundreds of science labs in the third episode implied a much more fun, vaguely X-Files like show that sadly wasn't to be. I was expecting future episodes to focus on a weird science project of the week, with Burnam playing the role of Mulder and Scully trying to figure out just what the heck was happening on board this ship. Alas.
 
There is clearly an interesting story to be told about how Discovery morphed during its creation. I think we will eventually hear the story, but not for years, not until it is safely in the rearview mirror. God would I love to write that book.
 
  • Like
Reactions: pst
I think the ultimate explanation for the spore tech disappearing has to be something shutting off access to the network. Maybe Starfleet intentionally does that in the future to keep Mirror terrors from coming through or to stop another disaster. It will be something like that. I wouldn't be surprised if the series ends with Discovery sacrificing itself to do that thereby explaining why nobody has heard of them.

If a spore drive were even an insanely dangerous option that wouldn't have stopped the Romulans or the Dominion or the Ferengi ... or Janeway. She and Torres would have been incubating spores as soon as they could find some.
 
There is clearly an interesting story to be told about how Discovery morphed during its creation. I think we will eventually hear the story, but not for years, not until it is safely in the rearview mirror. God would I love to write that book.
That’s the kind of loose ends that bug me. Introducing a Klingon ship covered with tens of thousands of dead warriors screams “army of zombie Klingons!!!” to me, but it went nowhere. I’m dying to know where Fuller was planning to take that.
 
If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

Sign up / Register


Back
Top