Where's the Second TARDIS?

[Iamnotspock]

You know... I'm starting to wonder if "1103's" death was in fact caused by "909+" in the spacesuit while "909" was in the diner getting a straw.

Wibbly Wobbly indeed.

I can certainly see that.

As for the Ganger theory and others like it;

Amy: "Maybe he's a clone or a duplicate..."

Canton: "That most certainly is the Doctor, and he is most certainly dead."

and from Confidential.

Steven Moffat: "It is definitely him."

 

[David cgc]

Rule One: Moffat lies.

 

[Sindatur]

You know... I'm starting to wonder if "1103's" death was in fact caused by "909+" in the spacesuit while "909" was in the diner getting a straw.

Wibbly Wobbly indeed.

I can certainly see that.

As for the Ganger theory and others like it;

Amy: "Maybe he's a clone or a duplicate..."

Canton: "That most certainly is the Doctor, and he is most certainly dead."

and from Confidential.

Steven Moffat: "It is definitely him."

The Gangers episodes went out of their way to make sure we understood Ganger Doctor was indeed the Doctor, likewise the Paradoxical Older Amy, they also went out of their way to make sure we understood it was indeed Amy. So, Ganger, duplicate, etc, it would still be "Him", so, I don't think we can take any "duplicating the Doctor" theory off the table based upon that.

 

[Photoman15]

You know... I'm starting to wonder if "1103's" death was in fact caused by "909+" in the spacesuit while "909" was in the diner getting a straw.

Wibbly Wobbly indeed.

The 909's TARDIS is underwater in the lake. That's where 909 comes out with his NASA suit, walks out of the Lake, kills 1103 and then goes back into the lake, into the TARDIS, and pops back over to the diner. (My speculation).

 

[The Wormhole]

You know the spoilers are out there as to how this all get resolved.

Spoiler: Spoiler

And it doesn't involve Gangers.

 

[David cgc]

You're right. We should all just stop talking about the show since then ending has already been spoiled elsewhere, so there's no fun to be had in speculating.

 

[The Wormhole]

I'm not trying to be a buzzkill, but I figured someone might be interested in knowing how things will play out, and I'd provide the appropriate clues and hints.

 

[Veediotgamer]

You know... I'm starting to wonder if "1103's" death was in fact caused by "909+" in the spacesuit while "909" was in the diner getting a straw.

Wibbly Wobbly indeed.

The 909's TARDIS is underwater in the lake. That's where 909 comes out with his NASA suit, walks out of the Lake, kills 1103 and then goes back into the lake, into the TARDIS, and pops back over to the diner. (My speculation).

That's a good one!

 

[Veediotgamer]

You're right. We should all just stop talking about the show since then ending has already been spoiled elsewhere, so there's no fun to be had in speculating.

I beg to differ. Actually, speculation is what's half the fun of Doctor Who.

 

[Veediotgamer]

I'm not trying to be a buzzkill, but I figured someone might be interested in knowing how things will play out, and I'd provide the appropriate clues and hints.

It's understood. I must admit I am tempted myself, but I refuse to end the fun.

 

[Sindatur]

I'm not trying to be a buzzkill, but I figured someone might be interested in knowing how things will play out, and I'd provide the appropriate clues and hints.

It's understood. I must admit I am tempted myself, but I refuse to end the fun.

Exactly, it's spoilered, I can rely on my own restraint. When you start detailing it in replies "out of spoiler code", that's when it's wrong.

 

[The Nth Doctor]

You're right. We should all just stop talking about the show since then ending has already been spoiled elsewhere, so there's no fun to be had in speculating.

I beg to differ. Actually, speculation is what's half the fun of Doctor Who.

Sarcasm is a dead art.

 

[David cgc]

You're right. We should all just stop talking about the show since then ending has already been spoiled elsewhere, so there's no fun to be had in speculating.

I beg to differ. Actually, speculation is what's half the fun of Doctor Who.

Sarcasm is a dead art.

[yt]http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=J19-wMSwMkQ[/yt]

 

[Bacl]

You know... I'm starting to wonder if "1103's" death was in fact caused by "909+" in the spacesuit while "909" was in the diner getting a straw.

Wibbly Wobbly indeed.

I can certainly see that.

As for the Ganger theory and others like it;

Amy: "Maybe he's a clone or a duplicate..."

Canton: "That most certainly is the Doctor, and he is most certainly dead."

and from Confidential.

Steven Moffat: "It is definitely him."

How the hell does Canton know that.

River Song: Oh, well if this COMPLETE STRANGER who is nothing more than a character of the week insists that is the Doctor...

Is Canton in on it? He shows up seemingly aware of everything, including that the Doctor is going to die and that it is really him. How does he know this? Will he even be back? Why did the Doctor summon him out of all the universe? Martha Jones is alive and well during this time. Why Canton?

 

[Checkmate]

Yes, why would he call upon a professionally trained liar and deceiver...

 

[Veediotgamer]

I hadn't even thought of the Canton Connection...

 

[OmahaStar]

I can rely on my own restraint.

*smirk*

 

[Sindatur]

I can rely on my own restraint.

*smirk*

Well, I can....usually

 

[Bacl]

Yes, why would he call upon a professionally trained liar and deceiver...

I don't recall Canton's skills being lies and deception. He was a problem solver, sharp mind, security oriented. When exactly did he demonstrate excellence at lying and deceit? His participation int he farce of capturing the Doctor was both the Doctor's idea AND solely for the sake of tricking the Silence AND everyone else (Amy, Rory) were in on it.

Even so, being a liar and a deceiver does not quite qualify you to make claims about that corpse really being the Doctor. A strange out of nowhere comment that he has no ability to back up. How does he know that? Does he even know what regeneration is? Why was he called to witness the Doctor die in the first place? Why does he leave immediately afterwards?

 

[Sindatur]

Yes, why would he call upon a professionally trained liar and deceiver...

I don't recall Canton's skills being lies and deception. He was a problem solver, sharp mind, security oriented. When exactly did he demonstrate excellence at lying and deceit? His participation int he farce of capturing the Doctor was both the Doctor's idea AND solely for the sake of tricking the Silence AND everyone else (Amy, Rory) were in on it.

Even so, being a liar and a deceiver does not quite qualify you to make claims about that corpse really being the Doctor. A strange out of nowhere comment that he has no ability to back up. How does he know that? Does he even know what regeneration is? Why was he called to witness the Doctor die in the first place? Why does he leave immediately afterwards?

As far as his Deception skills go, he's CIA, they're all liars, it's a job requirement, LOL