What if the Enterprise has a female captain?

[Ryan Thomas Riddle]

^ I managed to find this one:


http://farm4.static.flickr.com/3637/3310252268_6e3257216d_m.jpg

 

[Joemac]

how about B'Ellanna torres/paris for captain of the enterprise. i think she's got flair,anger,stubboness and daring.so what if she breaks a few noses in the process

 

[BolianAuthor]

What if the Enterprise-D has a female captain instead of Jean-Luc Picard, who retired from Starfleet after the battle of Maxia?

It would have royally rocked. For the simple reasons that it would not have been Janeway, and TNG had the best writers of any Trek ever.

Picard was perfect for the 1701-D, and I'm glad we got him, but if ANY Trek series could earn my trust and faith to do a female Captain right, it's TNG, hands down.

 

[Rii]

Then the Enterprise would have a female captain. Beyond that, who can say.

Beyond that it would mean no Picard.

 

[SmoothieX]

^ No Picard woulda been a major disappointment for me. He's much different than the other Trek captains and by far my favorite.

 

[Red Ranger]

Captain Rachael Garrett (they could pick someone else to be the captain of NCC-1701-C). I thought she had a really great persona. Even better than Captain Janeway.

Agreed, Gary7. Rachel Garrett was a commanding presence, and so freaking hot! Wish they had cast that actress, Tricia Neal, as Janeway in VOY. She had the most adorable lips, esp. when she pursed them tensely! -- RR

 

[Nerys Myk]

Then the Enterprise would have a female captain. Beyond that, who can say.

Beyond that it would mean no Picard.

Or maybe just no Patrick Stewart. The things that a Jeannine Picard could do arent different than a Jean-Luc Picard.

 

[Rii]

Then the Enterprise would have a female captain. Beyond that, who can say.

Beyond that it would mean no Picard.

Or maybe just no Patrick Stewart. The things that a Jeannine Picard could do arent different than a Jean-Luc Picard.

Eh, sorry, I like Picard just the way he is. Feel free to replace Archer with a female Captain, or Janeway with a better female captain, or to create a sixth series with a female captain, or to remake TNG (like nBSG) with a female captain, but Picard stays where he is.

 

[Nerys Myk]

Beyond that it would mean no Picard.

Or maybe just no Patrick Stewart. The things that a Jeannine Picard could do arent different than a Jean-Luc Picard.

Eh, sorry, I like Picard just the way he is. Feel free to replace Archer with a female Captain, or Janeway with a better female captain, or to create a sixth series with a female captain, or to remake TNG (like nBSG) with a female captain, but Picard stays where he is.

It's still Picard, just played by a different actor. The Picard played by Patrick Stewart would not exist.

 

[Rii]

It's still Picard, just played by a different actor. The Picard played by Patrick Stewart would not exist.

Yeah, and I'm very fond of Picard as portrayed by Patrick Stewart and have no interest in rolling the hypothetical dice on the off-chance that another actor (male or female) could've done a better job with the character. If one were to remake TNG there'd of necessity be a recast regardless, in that case I'd have no issue with Jeanine Picard.

 

[Anji]

Female captains? Maybe as a guest shot, but not in the lead.

My guess is because it is still difficult in our culture for women to find the line between maintaining their feminity and then having to assert power and authority in a command position. It's an issue I struggle with.

Perhaps if there was a writer that could clearly portray that internal conflict and then write episodes showing possible solutions...maybe.

 

[JustKate]

^ I am hoping and praying that within a few decades there won't be any internal conflict (I'll probably be dead before then, but I'm hoping it's not too far off). So while I appreciate what you're saying, Anji, I'd rather Trek not deal with this as part of its plots. It would be anachronistic - like having Trek characters worry about race relations or something.

 

[C.E. Evans]

Although I like Picard as captain, I think I would have also liked a female captain in TNG as well. We've already got Riker as "the man of action" leading the away teams, so a "Captain Jeanette-Marie Piquette" would have been perfect delegating authority on the bridge just as Picard did, IMO...

 

[Myasishchev]

Some sexual tension with Riker?

Seriously, some of the roles might have changed gender. For example, there might not have been a Doctor Crusher (NO!!!!!!!) or Ten-Forward might have had a male bartender. There might have "balancing out" of gender in other areas.

Some years ago, I read that Robert Picardo feared his or a couple of the other male characters on Voyager might have switched to female if they had gone with a male captain after Genevieve Bujold bowed out, thus they would be out of jobs.

Really? It would go to show how little Voyager cared about its characters, if at that late stage of the game they could be given sex changes without changing anything.

 

[Herkimer Jitty]

Some sexual tension with Riker?

Seriously, some of the roles might have changed gender. For example, there might not have been a Doctor Crusher (NO!!!!!!!) or Ten-Forward might have had a male bartender. There might have "balancing out" of gender in other areas.

Some years ago, I read that Robert Picardo feared his or a couple of the other male characters on Voyager might have switched to female if they had gone with a male captain after Genevieve Bujold bowed out, thus they would be out of jobs.

Really? It would go to show how little Voyager cared about its characters, if at that late stage of the game they could be given sex changes without changing anything.

"Here's the report you wanted, Captain."

"Ensign Kim? Weren't you a man last week?"

"Not that I can recall, sir."

 

[Myasishchev]