• Welcome! The TrekBBS is the number one place to chat about Star Trek with like-minded fans.
    If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

What if a BSG-styled remake of Babylon 5 was made?

My son bought me (as a delayed Birthday gift) Babylon 5 (the entire series and movies) and Crusade..I'm slowly binge watching the entire series and have to say, a TOS Trek style remaster of the special effects is sorely needed.. needed but probably not feasible in a dollars and sense sort of way..

I could be wrong but I think the original video FX files have been lost/misplaced/wiped so everything would have to be re-rendered from scratch.
 
My son bought me (as a delayed Birthday gift) Babylon 5 (the entire series and movies) and Crusade..I'm slowly binge watching the entire series and have to say, a TOS Trek style remaster of the special effects is sorely needed.. needed but probably not feasible in a dollars and sense sort of way..

I could be wrong but I think the original video FX files have been lost/misplaced/wiped so everything would have to be re-rendered from scratch.

Regardless, I would argue for maintaining the effects as they are. Even when the show aired they were subpar and a little cartoonish, but it was cutting edge CGI for the day and had its own artistic style and rendering that I feel fits nicely with the live action aesthetic of the show.
 
The nBSG style would work best in the Earth Minbari War. Imagine 5 years of certain doom with absolutely no hope.
 
I consider it a privilege to have been there when it originally aired.

To see the last batch of season 3 episodes and the INTENSITY they generated, making me shake with excitement.

NOTHING will replicate that.

JMS was in Australia at the time Sleeping In Light aired. He wasn't impressed with ch9's broadcast as broke a different points for ad breaks than how the show had originally been cut.

No doubt the later than scheduled broadcast didn't impress either.

Wow - that's interesting.

I actually wrote a letter to the Sunday Times tv magazine, the week before SiL aired, expressing my disdain for Ch. 9's treatment of B5 and the fact that the finale (which at that point, I had already seen) would not appreciated by the audience it deserved.

The editor put the typical snide, pithy response.

I kept the letter from the page it was printed on and I'll transpose it once it get home from work later.
 
It has to be a feature because those are the only rights JMS owns.

<Sigh> FFS WBs, either sh*t or get off the pot for Christ's sake.

I'll happily take a movie, but with the current spate of remakes/reboots/continuations, the continued gross under appreciation of one of the genre's greatest contributions, certainly on the small screen, is damned infuriating. :scream:
 
It has to be a feature because those are the only rights JMS owns.

<Sigh> FFS WBs, either sh*t or get off the pot for Christ's sake.

I'll happily take a movie, but with the current spate of remakes/reboots/continuations, the continued gross under appreciation of one of the genre's greatest contributions, certainly on the small screen, is damned infuriating. :scream:

Well, JMS will give WB an opportunity to be involved but - and this is a kicker - JMS and his Studio JMS are the only studio who would make the feature because he doesn't own the TV rights. Any other studio is naturally going to want all the rights. JMS doesn't care about that, apparently.

It may be around here upthread but in the interest of time, here's a link to the transcription I did of JMS making the announcement in July 2014:
http://freebabylon5.com/b5-movie-news-announcement-transcript/

I admit to being curious as to the effect the lack of TV rights might have on his getting funding but JMS is a much bigger name now than he was in 1993.

Jan
 
The only way that I would support a remake would be if we got to see JMS' original plot line (sans cast changes) put on screen.

Otherwise there is no point. The reason that BSG really worked was that it took the original premise of the old TV show far more seriously than the old show ever could. In essence it lived up to the potential that was originally missing. B5, on the other hand, largely did what it set out to do. Not only that, it managed to do so while being incredibly literate and nuanced in its storytelling/imagery. Plus B5, while having some questionable acting, mostly from Michael Ohare and Bruce Boxleitner, the rest of the cast was SUPERB. I do not think that anyone could replace Mira Furlan, Peter Jurassik, Andreas Katsulas and Jerry Doyle. Andreas Katsulas alone could never be replaced.

You do know that 'O'Hare' had some mental health issues, right? Aside from that, I think his acting (and Boxleitner's) was fine.

As well, since JMS is doing a Babylon 5 remake as soon as he can get a distributor and the financing for a movie, to say that nobody can replace the actors in question is presumptuous, since said movie will have said new actors in place replacing Michael O'Hare, Bruce Boxleitner, Mira Furlan, Peter Jurassik, Andreas Katsulas, Jerry Doyle and the rest.

<Sigh> FFS WBs, either sh*t or get off the pot for Christ's sake.

My sentiments exactly, and I'd also like to include CBS Studios in this sentiment as well for not letting Star Trek be back as a TV show on TV. Either do a new movie, TV show, put the original show back in syndication, or sell back the IP to JMS.

I admit to being curious as to the effect the lack of TV rights might have on his getting funding but JMS is a much bigger name now than he was in 1993.

Jan

He's also a much older man now, and time is of the essence in getting this off of the ground. It's time for the companies concerned to act or bugger off and get out of JMS's way.
 
Last edited:
As well, since JMS is doing a Babylon 5 remake as soon as he can get a distributor and the financing for a movie, to say that nobody can replace the actors in question is presumptuous, since said movie will have said new actors in place replacing Michael O'Hare, Bruce Boxleitner, Mira Furlan, Peter Jurassik, Andreas Katsulas, Jerry Doyle and the rest.

While hi might change his mind, JMS has said in the past that nobody will ever play G'Kar again. And in the reboot TV series that was contracted but fell through a few years ago, JMS said that G'Kar was a figure like G'Quan had been in the series - spoken of but not seen.

<Sigh> FFS WBs, either sh*t or get off the pot for Christ's sake.

My sentiments exactly, and I'd also like to include CBS Studios in this sentiment as well for not letting Star Trek be back as a TV show on TV. Either do a new movie, TV show, put the original show back in syndication, or sell back the IP to JMS.
Sadly, WB seems to prefer the 'we refuse to do anything but nobody else can have it, either' business model. Oh, and streaming the episodes for $2/episode.

He's also a much older man now, and time is of the essence in getting this off of the ground. It's time for the companies concerned to act or bugger off and get out of JMS's way.

Hey, he's only 61 - hardly at death's door. Seems like he gets busier every year.
 
^Anything can happen in your sixties, health-wise; I want Mike to do this while he's still here rather than let somebody else do it and (probably) fuck it up. This is not Star Trek that didn't really need Gene Roddenberry, this is Babylon 5 that needs JMS badly or it won't really work as well.

He said that he didn't want the fans to provide him with crowdfunding monies: heck, I say that he should get that money from a ton of fans just to buy Babylon 5 back from Warners.
 
Last edited:
He said that he didn't want the fans to provide him with crowdfunding monies: heck, I say that he should get that money from a ton of fans just to buy Babylon 5 back from Warners.

He's only mentioned it publicly a couple of times but apparently Joe did try to buy the rights back from WB and negotiations petered out after initial interest. For some reason WB seems determined for the show to fade to obscurity.
 
At this point I'd take any well written heavily serial space opera.

But I'd rather have an original one.

I'll bang the drum again for an adaptation of Alastair Reynolds' Revelation Space universe -- only a small number of weird aliens, an explanation for the Great Filter, transhumans of several varieties, nanotech going wrong, ubercool exotic weapons, no FTL except with unsettling consequences, no telepathy except using technology, bad robots who have a rationale for their extreme behaviour, planets being blown up in various different ways, religious zealotry and other hubris galore.
 
Last edited:
They could still do the Babylon 4 story. Technically not a reboot, but it could still be great if they put it on Netflix where JMS wouldn't be hounded by a crummy network like he was with Crusade. I also wouldn't mind at least a movie to truly wrap up Crusade, I liked that show.
 
I would absolutely love a Valen miniseries. B4, the end of the First Great Shadow War, or whatever it's called, B4 and Valen could show up in the last half of the series. Like if it's a 13 show season, he'd show up in episode 6 or 7 maybe? Give us some good time to meet the Minbari and establish the characters, and set the background, no previous knowledge of B5 would be necessary.
 
If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

Sign up / Register


Back
Top