What do you think the music should be like in Star Trek XI?

[beamMe]

Let Giacchino do his work. His soundtrack was by far the most memorable of 2009 And it was great

At least as good as the score for TUC!! The score for Trek 09 was pretty good, actually.

It really is - in connection with the pictures it was written for. It is not quite as nice to listen to on its own.
Aften listening to the OST for X-Men: First Class this week (and loving it) I think I could live with replacing Giacchino with Jackman.

 

[Jon1701]

I'm hanging my hopes on a flute solo for the new movie.

 

[beamMe]

I'm hanging my hopes on a flute solo for the new movie.

"American Pie" already had a flute solo over a decade ago...

 

[number6]

I'm hanging my hopes on a flute solo for the new movie.

"American Pie" already had a flute solo over a decade ago...

That clip is wayyyyyyyy older!!

 

[Saquist]

To my ear, it just sounded just like the show's version of the theme.

Same here.

Have your hearing checked then.

For you there is ritalin. Please use as directed. Don't stop using ritalin unless consulted by your doctor. Ritlain may cause nervousness, decreased appetite, insomnia, nausea, palpation and in extreme situations death. Ask Commodore Saquist if Ritalin is right for you.

Saquist: DO IT!! DO IT NOW!!!

 

[beamMe]

Same here.

Have your hearing checked then.

For you there is ritalin. Please use as directed. Don't stop using ritalin unless consulted by your doctor. Ritlain may cause nervousness, decreased appetite, insomnia, nausea, palpation and in extreme situations death. Ask Commodore Saquist if Ritalin is right for you.

Saquist: DO IT!! DO IT NOW!!!

 

[M'Sharak]

Same here.

Have your hearing checked then.

For you there is ritalin. Please use as directed. Don't stop using ritalin unless consulted by your doctor. Ritlain may cause nervousness, decreased appetite, insomnia, nausea, palpation and in extreme situations death. Ask Commodore Saquist if Ritalin is right for you.

Saquist: DO IT!! DO IT NOW!!!

beamMe's remark may have been blunt, but it had the virtue of being more or less on topic. Your response, on the other hand, is not on topic, it's overly personal, it's trolling, and it will earn you a warning.

Any and all comments concerning this matter should be taken to PM.


The discussion will now return to the thread topic, please.

 

[Set Harth]

I think I could live with replacing Giacchino with Jackman.

Because I didn't know the name of the FC composer, at first I thought you were talking about replacing Giacchino with Hugh Jackman.

 

[bullethead]

I'd be fine with Giacchino as long as the music used in the final cut wasn't as repetitive and poorly sound balanced as in STXI.

I'd much rather have Bear McCreary, Clint Mansell, or some other composer.

 

[number6]

You could always wear your iPod in the theatre.

 

[Jon1701]

Screw Jazz. What about the disco version?

 

[Saquist]

Have your hearing checked then.

For you there is ritalin. Please use as directed. Don't stop using ritalin unless consulted by your doctor. Ritlain may cause nervousness, decreased appetite, insomnia, nausea, palpation and in extreme situations death. Ask Commodore Saquist if Ritalin is right for you.

Saquist: DO IT!! DO IT NOW!!!

beamMe's remark may have been blunt, but it had the virtue of being more or less on topic. Your response, on the other hand, is not on topic, it's overly personal, it's trolling, and it will earn you a warning.

Any and all comments concerning this matter should be taken to PM.


The discussion will now return to the thread topic, please.

rewarding people for flame baiting on topic is wreckless.

 

[Herkimer Jitty]

I think I could live with replacing Giacchino with Jackman.

Because I didn't know the name of the FC composer, at first I thought you were talking about replacing Giacchino with Hugh Jackman.

Well, he does know how to sing.

 

[A Little Otter]

I agree that the movies have generally had consistently good music, even if the score for Voyage Home sounded like Christmas music. Truthfully, though, I got a little sick of hearing the Goldsmith score. I love the music composed for Trek 09 and hope the same composer returns. James Horner's Wrath of Khan score is my favorite, though.

 

[22 Stars]

I think you mean XII. XI was years ago and it had a fantastic soundtrack.

I want an epic version of the "Amok Time" fight music in the next movie. That would be awesome.

Me too! When Giachino was asked about this possibility, he said he would consider it!

 

[Hythlodeus]

loud!