• Welcome! The TrekBBS is the number one place to chat about Star Trek with like-minded fans.
    If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

What Changed All Good Things?

So, my question is, what the hell changed? At the end of All Good Things, Picard does tell the crew about how they drifted apart in the future. As far as he knew, though, the Enterprise-D survived. If we saw it in the future of All Good Things, how could it have been destroyed and replaced by the Ent-E in GEN?!?!?

I think that the future changed the very instant that Picard told the crew about the future he saw. Think about it -- by telling the crew about what happened to them they had thoughts in their mind when they were making decisions that they didn't have before. Riker might have thought about giving Worf a black eye, but then remembered the future where neither of them got Troi and decided to hold back his anger. By being told their potential futures their futures were changed.

The Enterprise-D survived into the future in the original time line. However, when Picard shared information about the future, the time line changed, and as a result, the Enterprise-D got jumped by an old Klingon ship and destroyed.

I think the fact that Q didn't erase Picard's memories in favor of protecting the time line as a sort of personal gift to his old friend/rival. Normally Starfleet frowns on messing with time so Picard telling the crew what he saw was actually a pretty gutsy leap.
 
I think I said that. ;)

$35 million doesn't buy you much, not even when you're using the same sets, costumes, and props you've been using the last seven years.
 
Plus didn't they change uniform designs mid-movie? Or was that FC? Can't remember now!
 
Plus didn't they change uniform designs mid-movie? Or was that FC? Can't remember now!

In Generations they switched back and forth randomly between the TNG (season 3+) uniforms and the DS9 (original "jumpsuit") uniforms. There was supposed to be a new uniform design for Generations (basically a modified version of the TV uniforms) but they got axed by budget concerns. The new "blues" debuted in First Contact and got adopted on DS9 thereafter. (And I think showed up on Voyager once in awhile after they reestablished contact with the Federation.)

And put me in the "AGT future was all a Q-generated simulation, or 'never happened' because of Picard's solution to the problem" camp. Things reverted to the "present" and events from the end of AGT forward simply played out differently due to any number of small decisions going differently. Presumably, somewhere out there in the metaverse, there's a universe where the AGT future did indeed come to pass.
 
Sadly, based on what we've seen in "The Visitor" and "Endgame," it looks like Q's 'prediction' about the future design of Starfleet uniforms will come to pass. Apparently by the turn of the 25th century, it'll be high fashion to pull our pants up past our waist like our grandparents.
 
Sadly, based on what we've seen in "The Visitor" and "Endgame," it looks like Q's 'prediction' about the future design of Starfleet uniforms will come to pass. Apparently by the turn of the 25th century, it'll be high fashion to pull our pants up past our waist like our grandparents.

I'm sorry, I can't hear what you're saying. I'm too busy staring at your avatar.
 
Sadly, based on what we've seen in "The Visitor" and "Endgame," it looks like Q's 'prediction' about the future design of Starfleet uniforms will come to pass. Apparently by the turn of the 25th century, it'll be high fashion to pull our pants up past our waist like our grandparents.
It could be a 24th-25th century equivalent of the TMP space PJs (I could only hope...).
 
There was supposed to be a new uniform design for Generations (basically a modified version of the TV uniforms) but they got axed by budget concerns.

They were made and then discarded, because they didn't look good on screen, and were very uncomfortable under movie lights. They simulated the shoulder flap of the ST II costumes. Playmates' "Generations" figures featured the unused costumes.

A decision was made to borrow some DS9 outfits and they were introduced slowly throughout the film.
 
That reason makes a lot more sense than the silly "too many changes" reason that's been kicked around for years. The change in that uniform design certainly wouldn't have been as radical as the change from TOS to TMP, or TMP to TWOK (or TWOK-TVH to TNG, for that matter).
 
There is probably no good explanation for this, considering the deux ex machina plot device that was the Nexus in GEN, but here it goes:

Ok, in the final TNG episode, All Good Things, we saw a future where the Enterprise D wasn't destroyed, Picard was a retired ambassador (who never attained the rank of admiral), Riker was an admiral, Data occupied the Lucasian chair at Oxford, etc.

In GEN's first timeline, though, the Enterprise D and all hands was destroyed.
In the second altered timeline, the Enterprise D was still destroyed, although the crew was saved (thanks to the sacrifice of Captain James T. Kirk).

So, my question is, what the hell changed?

I think you are leaving out the part that may have the answer. AGT has three storylines:

Storyline1--Seven years before "now" and the crew is clueless.

Storyline2--"now" and the crew has something of a handle of it. This is "our" storyline.

Storyline3--decades after "now" and the crew is mostly clueless but most importantly does not remember Storyline2.

This detail is, I think, the answer. That the Storyline3 crew does not have any recollection about the antitime thing twenty-odd years ago and a final encounter with Q and the judgement of humanity means those events are not in their past. It's a whole different reality, just like the Storyline2 crew does not remember skipping the Farpoint mission altogether and doing the antitime thing seven years earlier--and getting destroyed!

The outcome of Storyline2 erased both the other storylines since that storyline's resolution cannot exist in Storyline1's future and does not exist in Storyline3's past.

Or it might be just a tv show.
 
If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

Sign up / Register


Back
Top