• Welcome! The TrekBBS is the number one place to chat about Star Trek with like-minded fans.
    If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

Spoilers What are your unpopular Sci-Fi & Fantasy Opinions?

Super pedantic but it's actually 254 episodes-- 144 for Buffy and 110 for Angel. :D
Oops, I guess I must have hid a wrong number on my calculator when I was adding them up.
Kinda like how, much as I enjoyed the first Fantastic Beasts movie, the whole concept of Fantastic Beasts is nonsense. They're animals. How would they have the wherewithal to keep themselves hidden from the Muggle world? Indeed, one of the key plot points is how the niffler is constantly in danger of exposing everything because it can't stop itself from stealing stuff. If these animals really existed, their existence would be well known because they would inevitably bumble their way into the path of nearby Muggles without the constant active intervention of wizards to keep them hidden.

The only way that this makes sense is if they're so rare and only came into existence very recently. Perhaps, a thousand years ago, a wizard was experimenting with various animals and created whole races of magical creatures. The other wizards tried to keep the existence of them under wraps but a few would occasionally escape and make their way into the local ecosystem.
This one actually is a fair point. At least in most of this kind of stuff, like Dresden Files, all of those kind of things are off in other worlds.
I think you could get away with a bit easier in the era of the Fantastic Beasts movies, but once you get to the modern day with satellites and cell phones, it's a lot harder to buy that these creatures wouldn't have been discovered by Muggles.
 
And what even qualifies it as a Fantastic Beast instead of just a regular animal? Some of them, like the niffler and those stick insects just seemed like variants on real animals but not really with any sort of magical powers. Sure, they perhaps seemed a bit more intelligent & better trained than normal animals IRL but I figured that's just because movie animals often tend to be like that.
 
Yeah, some of them do just seem to animals Muggles aren't familiar with.
 
And what even qualifies it as a Fantastic Beast instead of just a regular animal? Some of them, like the niffler and those stick insects just seemed like variants on real animals but not really with any sort of magical powers. Sure, they perhaps seemed a bit more intelligent & better trained than normal animals IRL but I figured that's just because movie animals often tend to be like that.

The niffler had powers, didn't it?
 
New (!?) Doctor Who needs a rest.

Voyager is a bad Star Trek show, but on average has better characters than TNG.
 
Voyager is a bad Star Trek show, but on average has better characters than TNG.

Agreed. It's also aged better than TNG. The formula was starting to get stale at that point but at least Voyager didn't get bogged down in angst & bad guest star melodrama all the time. (Looking at you, "New Ground," "Hero Worship," "The Loss," et al.) Voyager mostly had its eye on being a sci-fi adventure show first & foremost.
 
unpopular opinion: alternate history is usually not sci-fi and belongs in its own subgenre in speculative fiction, just as horror, science fiction, fantasy, have theirs.
 
^I don't think that's an unpopular opinion. It's just that no one cares enough about these sub-genre distinctions to do anything about it. The lines between genres are often very blurry. And while it's fun to categorize things, it doesn't really mean anything. Heck, one of my local video store chains recently merged the action, drama, & sci-fi sections into one big alphabetized mush. Comedy, horror, westerns, & musicals still have their own separate sections. But since so many dramas have violence, murder, & gunplay and so many modern action movies have implausible SF/F elements, there's just no point in parsing them out.
 
^I don't think that's an unpopular opinion. It's just that no one cares enough about these sub-genre distinctions to do anything about it. The lines between genres are often very blurry. And while it's fun to categorize things, it doesn't really mean anything. Heck, one of my local video store chains recently merged the action, drama, & sci-fi sections into one big alphabetized mush. Comedy, horror, westerns, & musicals still have their own separate sections. But since so many dramas have violence, murder, & gunplay and so many modern action movies have implausible SF/F elements, there's just no point in parsing them out.
You have a video store?
 
Not a rental store. It's for buying & selling new & used movies, TV shows, CDs, vinyl, books, video games, & various geeky knick-knacks. There's actually a couple chains that do that here in Arizona-- Bookmans and Zia (which also has a couple locations in Nevada). Zia is the one I was referring to.
 
I think the premise of Fantastic Beasts (as a schoolbook) is that many of these creatures look enough like their mundane equivalents that muggles can't tell the difference on sight, and will usually dismiss the magical properties as tricks of the light or something. The niffler, for instance, looks like a platypus without the beavertail. A muggle could see that, wonder what a platypus is doing outside of Australia, and never consider the idea that it might be something else, even without the beavertail.
 
I agree. Has there been any attempt to name that type of genre? What about something like The Handmaid's Tail? Definitely not science fiction, and it could be called "alternate history" but it's more like "alternate present." I'm curious as to how people classify stuff like that.
"Speculative fiction."

Kor
 
New (!?) Doctor Who needs a rest.

I'm starting to agree with you on this, even though they take such huge breaks between seasons. I like the current Doctor and cast but New (?!) Who used to have so much creativity and weirdness in so many of their episodes...it just seems to be getting a little stale now.
 
If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

Sign up / Register


Back
Top