What are your controversial Star Trek opinions?

[1001001]

Some people have an education, and some people don't...comparing two different cinema to each other is legit.

I’m not sure what you’re trying to accomplish here, but I’m sure “education” has little to do with it.

A lot of your posts don’t make sense, and you’ve been spoken to about it previously. That’s why you’re getting the reaction you did, not because we’re “uneducated.”

As our old boss used to say “you’re now on my radar.”

 

[XCV330]

controversial opinion: TOS got it right. Starships shouldn't have so many windows. Or any.

Starfleet ships while not outright warships, are often ships engaged in war, not Royal Carribean cruises. Yes I realize the windows are probably not glass, except when they're clearly shown to be glass, but it still complicates hull design and repair.

It's Space. There just isn't that much to see, normally unless they're around the daylight side of a planet or moon.. What there is to see could be better provided for by smart screens allowing you whatever view you want.

 

[Divinity Davey]

controversial opinion: TOS got it right. Starships shouldn't have so many windows. Or any.

Starfleet ships while not outright warships, are often ships engaged in war, not Royal Carribean cruises. Yes I realize the windows are probably not glass, except when they're clearly shown to be glass, but it still complicates hull design and repair.

It's Space. There just isn't that much to see, normally unless they're around the daylight side of a planet or moon.. What there is to see could be better provided for by smart screens allowing you whatever view you want.

It's probably just human nature to be able to see outside of a starship and view the cosmos up close.
(to a degree)

Though there are ships like the USS Defiant that had minimal view ports.